Garrick

[z1eyedeagle]

Anyone but Garrick, can only score a try when noone is in front of him and will never stop one. While he hasn't been rag-dolled the last two weeks he does nothing for the team and will continue to cost us in close games; three tries today, ****e!

 

[XV-1]

I think Harper would make a good winger. Suli is back soon, IF he comes back in surely Harper has jumped ahead of Parker for the other centre spot.
I like our right edge as is though!

You cannot ne serious. Laziboi Suli can never play first grade for Manly again.

 

[Scorpio]

Might not be a superstar... but I didn't think he did that badly today. I think we were a bit harshly done on some of those strip calls too. Not going to call for his head after 1 ordinary game.

That being said... I think today showed we lack some punch in a few positions compared to the competition benchmark.

 

[pjayz]

Back to his crappy best.

 

[pjayz]

Might not be a superstar... but I didn't think he did that badly today. I think we were a bit harshly done on some of those strip calls too. Not going to call for his head after 1 ordinary game.

That being said... I think today showed we lack some punch in a few positions compared to the competition benchmark.

It isn’t one ordinary game, it’s about his third of fourth this year.

 

[Brisbane Tragic]

Would’ve been 22-20 with 5 to go if we kicked the two goals we should have.

Spot on and pretty easy shots!

 

[Brisbane Tragic]

Garrick cost the side on more than one occasion, today. But he had a crack.

He did have a crack but those errors were poor and the missed kick along with DCE poor as well.

 

[winnyason]

Why the ref did not go back to check strip we amazing. Very blatant

 

[manlyfan76]

Back to being Baldrick yesterday.

 

[Kevinward777]

Back to being Baldrick yesterday.

Woodrow Baldrick the third.

 

[Woodsie]

Season stats according to NRL ..

Garrick 5 tries ... Saab 5 tries
Garrick 8 missed tackles ... Saab 26 missed tackles ..

Saab has a long way to go before becoming a complete footballer ...

 

[Bearfax]

You cannot ne serious. Laziboi Suli can never play first grade for Manly again.

Love it 'Laziboi'. Sent me on the floor in stitches

 

[Bearfax]

Koula or Tippy toes

 

[Kevinward777]

Unfortunately, all of Garrick's blunders led to tries yesterday - this situation has plagued his short career.

He also misses way too many kicks from beside the posts.

No way he scores any of the four long range tries that Saab has scored. He would not have out leaped Noafoluma either.

 

[Leho]

Season stats according to NRL ..

Garrick 5 tries ... Saab 5 tries
Garrick 8 missed tackles ... Saab 26 missed tackles ..

Saab has a long way to go before becoming a complete footballer ...

Wrong thread mate

 

[jbb/james]

He is a slender winger built for finishing rather than starting sets. He had a go and if he was DCE he would have got a pass mark for trying hard. Maybe he was trying to do too much , that in itself is a 7 out of 10 on here

We were on the back foot a lot , a hard game for wingers and the riff were physical all over the park. He made some crucial mistakes but our lack of leadership at times had more impact on the result

 

[BOZO]

Season stats according to NRL ..

Garrick 5 tries ... Saab 5 tries
Garrick 8 missed tackles ... Saab 26 missed tackles ..

Saab has a long way to go before becoming a complete footballer ...

Perspective time ...

You are only as Great as the Great team you compete against

and Saab proved how Great he is against the best team in the comp
with a Great all round performance

We also saw how Garrick crumbled under the big match pressure

 

[manlyfan76]

Saab is easily out better winger when it comes to
1) trys conceded
2) errors made
3) catching kicks - attack and defence
4) speed
5) not having the ball stripped.

Pretty good for a 20yo with a dozen games.

 

[Kevinward777]

Perspective time ...

You are only as Great as the Great team you compete against

and Saab proved how Great he is against the best team in the comp
with a Great all round performance

We also saw how Garrick crumbled under the considerable match pressure

Don't bother wasting your time. The guy is entirely incapable of admitting that he got it wrong. He is obstinately stubborn to the point of ignorance.

 

[Kevinward777]

I thought Garrick at least kept his chin up after the errors - a big improvement compared to how he imploded last season.