Salary Cap Witch Hunt. **Appeal unsuccessful**

[Chip and Chase]

Apparently two former players have turned into whistle blowers..If true who are the disgruntled players.

May be one who didn't get paid one of his TPA's

 

[eaglebuzz]

Apparently two former players have turned into whistle blowers..If true who are the disgruntled players.

Let me tell you a little story.

When asked if he would like to accept a job cutting the grass at Brookie, a local youth was heard to reply:

"What, mow all that grass? I'd be out there for an eternity!"

But who could these disgruntled former players possibly be?

 

[manly al]

Missed N R L 360 and Kent"y take on the matter but still seems very light on specifics and detail . The most alleged serious claim , what some 350 grand over 5 years , and no designated year break down , so allegedly occurring every year for five years or in individual years ? And based on the version of two former and now disgruntled players ? Two present Manly officials with a case to answer ? Not an accountancy discrepancy or, management stuff up but intentional cap cheating and taking into account the fact that the final cap arrangement that is supposed to receive the approval of a club board every season .Just really need more detail for the benefit of most people to be able to form a balanced judgement and opinion

 

[eaglebuzz]

The NRL press release is full of weasel language too.

"Significant" can mean either substantial, or just big enough to notice. And "current NRL official" doesn't mention which club they're working at.

 

[sheridanstand78]

I think it is important that we do not have a witch hunt against the alleged disgruntled ex-players, they may well have legitimate reasons for doing this. All I hope is that we learn of the context of these allegations and that we get it concluded, sooner rather than later.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

The witch hunt continues, hope you are happy with your dirty work Toggy.

By the end of it you will have tarnished our brand for years to come.

Sad day for all concerned.

 

[eaglebuzz]

This could all end up being a blessing in disguise. Signing Hodkinson or Carney would have been a bandaid solution at best, but if Hastings or Croker have a break out year then we'll be in great shape.

 

[NYEagle]

This is obviously a witch hunt and I hate the NRL more every day.

Add to this the fact you don't hear about Manly at all and as soon as something negative comes out they are top 3 stories on NRL.com.

NYEagle

 

[Harvies elbow]

Missed N R L 360 and Kent"y take on the matter but still seems very light on specifics and detail . The most alleged serious claim , what some 350 grand over 5 years , and no designated year break down , so allegedly occurring every year for five years or in individual years ? And based on the version of two former and now disgruntled players ? Two present Manly officials with a case to answer ? Not an accountancy discrepancy or, management stuff up but intentional cap cheating and taking into account the fact that the final cap arrangement that is supposed to receive the approval of a club board every season .Just really need more detail for the benefit of most people to be able to form a balanced judgement and opinion

They did say on 360 that they thought Mitchell Pearce had wind, the mention of which I thought was interesting in itself, until they explained that he had got wind of the breach findings against us.
Which again, I find interesting but not surprising.

 

[wombatgc]

http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...salary-cap-breach-notice-20171211-h02l94.html

 

[The Royal Soup]

@strone33 is hoping that one of them is Barrett

The plot thickens....

 

[Lewis Brown]

If we need to shed players then Lewis Brown could be one .
The worst part out of all this is that I can’t call Storm and Eels fans salary cap cheats anymore haha

How dare you contemplate getting rid of me I am the best dam utility this club has ever signed!!!

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

what is the benefit to the 2 players wanting to be whistleblowers.

I think it is important that we do not have a witch hunt against the alleged disgruntled ex-players, they may well have legitimate reasons for doing this

As Batty just posted above, there was a match fixing investigation, remember?

 

[ALinda]

Possibly someone who moved miles away down south and another that moved to a foreign country across the ditch...

Not necessarily and me thinks highly unlikely. Why would they...
'Someone' or two with an axe to grind would be more probable. @eaglebuzz has the right idea - that was my immediate thought.

 

[CorkQld]

Yep thanks for ruining Christmas, New Years, my holidays, my social life, my mental health status. This is all I am going to be able to think about until it’s resolved, and I’ll be checking for updates every five minutes. I don’t even know who to blame, Manly, the NRL, Foz, myself for loving Manly so damn much. Why.....Whyyyyyyyy!!!!!

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

I don’t even know who to blame, Manly, the NRL, Foz, myself for loving Manly so damn much.

To be perfectly frank, sorry but it is definitely your fault.

 

[Rosko]

So the Fulton’s and Penn’s have thrown Joe Kelly under the bus?

Concrete truck preferably.

 

[Rosko]

Kenty said on 360 that there is alleged evidence of the club signing a contract with a player for $150k. But then only registering the contract with the NRL for $100k.

Why would anyone bother? That is reserve grade money.

 

[Rosko]

I still think this is witch hunt.

The figures being thrown around are not big enough to be classified as "cheating". Does anyone really think that the combined incomes of Manly's roster exceeds that of the Donkeys or Rorters ?

What sort of unfair advantage have we gained ? Is our side filled with internationals and SOO players ? This is just another attempt by Greensnot to drag our name through the mud.

Personally, I'm about done. I'm becoming more of a Sydney F.C. supporter that takes a passing interest in Manly when it has always been the other way around.

Yep. No rorts and influence peddling in soccer.

 

[The McCarrs Creek Eagle]

Yep thanks for ruining Christmas, New Years, my holidays, my social life, my mental health status. This is all I am going to be able to think about until it’s resolved, and I’ll be checking for updates every five minutes. I don’t even know who to blame, Manly, the NRL, Foz, myself for loving Manly so damn much. Why.....Whyyyyyyyy!!!!!

Well it looks like there will be some interesting conversations with friends over the Christmas / New Year's break, this has really tarnished our reputation even if it turn's out to be minor. And I don't like giving any Ammo to the opposition.
We will get through this.........