Manly v Dogs [Round Finals Week 2 2014]
- Thread starter HappilyManly
- Start date
Roger_Ramjet
Ex Forum boofhead, now legennnnd!
panash said:
Read if you can...I just got in...to watch the match and unfortunately it finished...that's why i asked what happened. that's OK dickheads like you are in many places. Dig it?
Looking for positives, the rugby league journos can go on holidays now.
Roger_Ramjet
Ex Forum boofhead, now legennnnd!
mickqld said:
Well maybe I didn't say it that nicely, I meant to say to Jerry to enjoy the off season, in a nice way, not meant to sound like I'm mocking you guys cause I never did or never will BUt if your sentiments are still the same Mick QLD, then I can't change that. Manly are my 3rd fave team in the comp and that's why I am here. I hate the Dogs and other than the vermin losing, next would have been that manly would have beaten those dirty dogs. Anyway you guys take it the way you want
Roger_Ramjet said:
No mate !!! It's those that try to get some attention in a opposing club forum.
Get a life looser !!! You honestly think any of us here believe ur kindergarten story about not knowing what happened.
It's almost as good as my dog ate my homework.
Typical tool
Roger_Ramjet
Ex Forum boofhead, now legennnnd!
panash said:
Ahh go away DH! Not worth wasting time on you.
Jatz Crackers
First Grader
Lets leave it that fellas so we dont have to lock the thread. Ok.
Great comeback and proud of the boys. I'm assuming a few who posted earlier in the match are too embarrassed to come back-slapping now.
But this is going to sound weird, in a way I'd rather get flogged than lose a match we could/should have won. There's no dwelling on the 'what ifs' when you lose big. It's easier to suck it up and move on I think.
And I'll say something a little controversial, if Killer converts that last try, we win. Bull scum didn't have another try in them, and they couldn't win by kicking 3 field goals - that's too much of an ask, even for Dogkinson. I hated saying that, and that's what I hate about close losses.
But this is going to sound weird, in a way I'd rather get flogged than lose a match we could/should have won. There's no dwelling on the 'what ifs' when you lose big. It's easier to suck it up and move on I think.
And I'll say something a little controversial, if Killer converts that last try, we win. Bull scum didn't have another try in them, and they couldn't win by kicking 3 field goals - that's too much of an ask, even for Dogkinson. I hated saying that, and that's what I hate about close losses.
HoldenV8
Journey Man
Just a few match stats from the NRL Match Centre
Time in Possession:
Dogs - 51%
Manly - 49%
Total Run Metres:
Dogs - 1,853
Manly - 1,729
Offloads:
Dogs - 9
Manly - 16
Kick Metres:
Dogs - 654
Manly - 596
Total Tackles:
Dogs - 319
Manly - 354
Missed Tackles:
Dogs - 42
Manly - 65
Errors:
Dogs - 8
Manly - 10
Our individual stats leaders were:
Metres: Josh Starling (196), Peta Hiku (176), Cheyse Blair (152)
Tackles: Tom Symonds (44), Daniel Harrison, Brenton Lawrence (33), Josh Starling (32)
Missed Tackles: Jayden Hodges (7), Daly Cherry-Evans, Peta Hiku, Steve Matai (6), Brett Stewart, Kieran Foran, Justin Horo (5)
Time in Possession:
Dogs - 51%
Manly - 49%
Total Run Metres:
Dogs - 1,853
Manly - 1,729
Offloads:
Dogs - 9
Manly - 16
Kick Metres:
Dogs - 654
Manly - 596
Total Tackles:
Dogs - 319
Manly - 354
Missed Tackles:
Dogs - 42
Manly - 65
Errors:
Dogs - 8
Manly - 10
Our individual stats leaders were:
Metres: Josh Starling (196), Peta Hiku (176), Cheyse Blair (152)
Tackles: Tom Symonds (44), Daniel Harrison, Brenton Lawrence (33), Josh Starling (32)
Missed Tackles: Jayden Hodges (7), Daly Cherry-Evans, Peta Hiku, Steve Matai (6), Brett Stewart, Kieran Foran, Justin Horo (5)
HK_Eagle
First Grader
Merdy33 said:
Not controversial, except to upset some who rightfully love and appreciate all the positive things that Lyon is and does for the team. Nevertheless, it was a missed kick that would have won us the match. While Jamie is a reasonable goal-kicker, it hurts not to have a sharp-shooter who could be relied on to hit such kicks under the pump.
Like I said elsewhere the better team lost tonight. Great performance from a injury ravaged Manly side. The dog's will get knocked out next week and so will Ennis hoping so.
Nice that guzzler didn't come on here straight away to troll. (not that he trolls anyway....unlike one seemingly protected troll)
IN a complete lack of surprise to everybody.
The "don't question our integrity" match review committee has decided not to chanrge Josh Jackson for his chicken wing tackle, nor Ennis for his late hit on DCE.
"If you pick on us, Toddy will protect us," the gutless mrc said upon departing nrl headquarters with $100 notes falling from their pockets.
edit: Just saw the NEW thread on this.
My rant still stands.
The "don't question our integrity" match review committee has decided not to chanrge Josh Jackson for his chicken wing tackle, nor Ennis for his late hit on DCE.
"If you pick on us, Toddy will protect us," the gutless mrc said upon departing nrl headquarters with $100 notes falling from their pockets.
edit: Just saw the NEW thread on this.
My rant still stands.
Guzzler said:Been a while since I have visited Silvertails not by choice just changed jobs and went from office worker to back on the tools so computer time is less than it used to be.
Anyway good luck and as always should be a cracker of a game.
Just quietly go the dogs😛
By the way miss you GE😀
Awww... I just saw this!
lol
Good luck with your new job, hope it pays more!
B
Bulldogfan1
Guest
A couple of things from this game that are not mentioned at all.
Can someone explain to me why Josh Jackson' try was disallowed? The one where Reynolds ran from about 5 metres out from the Eagles line. It doesn't matter HOW the ball out, wether it was stripped or not. The bottom line is, the ball NEVER went forward, it "spurted" out BACKWARDS, Jackson picks it up and scores. That would have made it 22-0. All what Gus Gould kept on harping on about was Reynolds trying to pass the ball. How on earth can he conclude Reynolds was trying to pass it is beyond me, but in anycase, the ball went BACK, NEVER went forward. Fair Try DISSALOWED.
I have also seen a picture in regards to Reynolds being offside. What people haven't talked about is the positioning of the referee which was incorrect.
The Manly player who played the ball (I cant remember which one) was playing it between 12-13 metres out from the Dogs line. The referee had the dogs team on the tryline. Instead of the 10 metre rule, it was a 12-13 metre rule which is not in the rule book. A metre here and there can make the world of difference.
The referee had incorrect positioning in the first place.
In terms of Reynolds kicking the ball into the ref. I don't believe he did it deliberately. He got lucky. What no one talks about is, if this same scenario happened on the other side of half way ( a bulldogs player kicking it into a ref in the Dogs half), it would be a Manly feed and it would it a non issue here. Its just the way the cookie crumbles sometimes.
I agree the rule is a but stupid. But you play to the rules.
Can someone explain to me why Josh Jackson' try was disallowed? The one where Reynolds ran from about 5 metres out from the Eagles line. It doesn't matter HOW the ball out, wether it was stripped or not. The bottom line is, the ball NEVER went forward, it "spurted" out BACKWARDS, Jackson picks it up and scores. That would have made it 22-0. All what Gus Gould kept on harping on about was Reynolds trying to pass the ball. How on earth can he conclude Reynolds was trying to pass it is beyond me, but in anycase, the ball went BACK, NEVER went forward. Fair Try DISSALOWED.
I have also seen a picture in regards to Reynolds being offside. What people haven't talked about is the positioning of the referee which was incorrect.
The Manly player who played the ball (I cant remember which one) was playing it between 12-13 metres out from the Dogs line. The referee had the dogs team on the tryline. Instead of the 10 metre rule, it was a 12-13 metre rule which is not in the rule book. A metre here and there can make the world of difference.
The referee had incorrect positioning in the first place.
In terms of Reynolds kicking the ball into the ref. I don't believe he did it deliberately. He got lucky. What no one talks about is, if this same scenario happened on the other side of half way ( a bulldogs player kicking it into a ref in the Dogs half), it would be a Manly feed and it would it a non issue here. Its just the way the cookie crumbles sometimes.
I agree the rule is a but stupid. But you play to the rules.
RiverEagle
Bencher
What you conveniently disregard from the Manly v Dogs game @Bulldogfan1
IS : The difference Ballin, Choc, Buhrer and Glenn Stewart would've made on the night. FAR more than a lucky kick, a few metres here or there, or any rules U want to include or excuse.
IF it had been Golden-Try (not Golden Point) that too could've been far more relevant and indicative of who was the better football team (not just who can execute a Field-Goal better).
I don't care about last night's game. Except I wish the Riff had won.
I hope Souths steam-roll and batter De$ and your Bulldogs now.
And...Channel Nein : "Live and Free" (in Standard Definition)??
What a crock, and insult to all viewers and fans in 2014.
IS : The difference Ballin, Choc, Buhrer and Glenn Stewart would've made on the night. FAR more than a lucky kick, a few metres here or there, or any rules U want to include or excuse.
IF it had been Golden-Try (not Golden Point) that too could've been far more relevant and indicative of who was the better football team (not just who can execute a Field-Goal better).
I don't care about last night's game. Except I wish the Riff had won.
I hope Souths steam-roll and batter De$ and your Bulldogs now.
And...Channel Nein : "Live and Free" (in Standard Definition)??
What a crock, and insult to all viewers and fans in 2014.
Users who are viewing this thread
Latest posts
| Team | P | W | L | PD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 38 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 36 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 30 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 22 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 8 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 6 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 |
|
1 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 |
|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -2 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -2 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -6 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -8 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -22 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -30 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -36 | 0 |
|
1 | 0 | 1 | -38 | 0 |