[Resurrected] Kane Elgey our new 5/8

Hahahaha.... c'mon Woodsie mate. While Lewis Brown is average, you can't possibly defend Barrett's decision to have it the way he did. That was complete and utter stupidity from Barrett. They could have had Hodko at 6, Dylan at centre and Manese at hooker with Brown on the bench (or even Wright). But to have Hodko at reserve hooker was dumb.... completly dumb.

You didn't see the game Brown played at hooker then ?? ... We were carved a new arrsehole up the middle, ... also Brown was injured for a lengthy period at the end and not available ...... there was no ideal solution .... but I do understand why it was done ....
 
Surprising the number of current N R L clubs who do not have a development or even specialist type 5 / 8 as their regular six in recent times . The majority of clubs have converted full backs or even utility type players to play in the six role and again as an even more pronounced current trend .. Elgey has had more of a traditional back ground developing or emerging as a half , has he full filled his previous potential rating , well not really overall . Does have a bit of sharpness in his game , passing selection seems O K , good support player but his defensive issues still seem to be a bit of a concern . Actually seems to have been a bit more effective in the half back role [ and that will not be happening at Manly next season ] ; ] . players like Luke Keary have shown that even lighter weight type and capable 6 "s can be quite influential but he is a very determined individual and has also had the benefit of playing behind some pretty useful forward packs in recent years . Manly management have put some faith that Elgey will be able to produce something worth while , personally think that young Metcalfe potentially has the most to offer in due course if he can show a bit more improvement . Can 't see Cust or Hodko coming into any real serious calculation for the Manly 6 next season, Metcalfe a good prospect if he stays around or if Elgey can not cut it as a 6 in the short term . just revert back to Walker .
 
From nrl.com

ON THIS DAY....


2015

Gold Coast rookie Kane Elgey rejects a lucrative offer from Manly to re-sign with the Titans. Elgey’s decision to remain loyal to the Titans costs him a reported $200,000.
 
With DCE out and likely LG back in I think we will get a better indicator on LG next week. Hopefully a more dominant confident role.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 18 15 0 3 132 34
2 Bulldogs 17 13 0 4 98 32
3 Storm 17 12 0 5 218 30
4 Warriors 17 12 0 5 36 30
5 Broncos 17 10 0 7 80 26
6 Panthers 17 9 1 7 45 25
7 Sea Eagles 17 9 0 8 60 24
8 Sharks 18 10 0 8 21 24
9 Dolphins 18 9 0 9 169 22
10 Roosters 17 8 0 9 8 22
11 Dragons 17 6 0 11 -58 18
12 Tigers 18 7 0 11 -101 18
13 Cowboys 18 6 1 11 -163 17
14 Knights 18 6 0 12 -90 16
15 Eels 17 5 0 12 -149 16
16 Rabbitohs 18 6 0 12 -149 16
17 Titans 17 4 0 13 -157 14
Back
Top Bottom