Post-Game Discussion Eels v Manly [Round 11, 2022]

[StuBoot]

We had no rub of the green tonight.

At 20-10, Koula almost scores but drops it over the line, cherry puts in a nice grubber but bad bounce over Quacs head when he looks almost certain to score, Walker almost breaks free to score but could not finish it off.

Absolutely had them on the ropes, and penalities got parra back in it.

Yep, l think four of their penalties were coming out of their end mid to late in the tackle count....and l think they then scored from two of them.

 

[Jethro]

From Post #1

FULL TIME SCORE

Eels: 22
Manly: 20

Pic: Manly Warringah Sea Eagles Facebook Page


Team Victory Song:

Pressers:

Round 11: Post Match Press Conference | Sea Eagles

Daly Cherry-Evans and Des Hasler chat to the media after their Round 11 clash with the Eels

www.seaeagles.com.au

Sea Eagles: Round 11

Daly Cherry-Evans and Des Hasler chat to the media after their Round 11 clash with the Eels

www.nrl.com

Eels: Round 11

Clint Gutherson and Brad Arthur chat to the media after their Round 11 clash with the Sea Eagles

www.nrl.com

Post Match Interviews: TBA



Match Report:

Eels snatch late win as Turbo injured

An 79th minute sideline conversion by Mitchell Moses snatched a 22-20 win for Parramatta as Manly were unable to hold on after losing Tom Trbojevic to injury.

www.nrl.com

Sea Eagles Stats Review: TBA



Match Highlights:

NRL 2022: Match highlights, Eels v Sea Eagles, Round 11 | Sea Eagles

The Parramatta Eels host the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles during Round 11 of the 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership

www.seaeagles.com.au

Match Highlights: Eels v Sea Eagles

The Parramatta Eels host the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles during Round 11 of the 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership

www.nrl.com

Extended Match Highlights: TBA



Full Match Replay Link: TBA



Manly Tries:

Garrick opens the scoring

A slick backline move gives Reuben Garrick the opening try

www.nrl.com

Christian Tuipulotu benefits from a lovely DCE pass

DCE cuts out everyone to hit Tuipulotu on the wing

www.nrl.com

Turbo opens up to give Harper a try

Morgan Harper and Tom Trbojevic combine for a long range try

www.nrl.com

Garrick gets his second to extend lead

Reuben Garrick on the end of a deft Foran kick to extend the lead

www.nrl.com

Game Pics & Video Clips:

Schuster opens up

Josh Schuster collects a Mitch Moses kick and finds himself in open space

www.nrl.com

Tom Trbojevic leaves the field injured

Tom Trbojevic has left the field with a shoulder injury

www.nrl.com

Press Print & Video Articles:

Raiders star’s hamstring blow, Souths lose two players to concussion: NRL Casualty Ward

Raiders star’s hamstring blow, Souths lose two players to concussion: NRL Casualty Ward

www.foxsports.com.au

Moses’ maturity shines through in clutch moment; Turbo-less Manly face brutal road ahead: 3 Big Hits

Moses’ maturity shines through in clutch moment; Turbo-less Manly face brutal road ahead: 3 Big Hits

www.foxsports.com.au

‘Heartbreaking’: Turbo’s injury a ‘killer blow’ for Manly as big Origin headache created

‘Heartbreaking’: Turbo’s injury a ‘killer blow’ for Manly as big Origin headache created

www.foxsports.com.au

Tom Trbojevic injured as Paramatta come from behind to beat Manly

An injury to Tom Trbojevic is cause for concern for Manly and NSW, as Parramatta rally late to beat the Sea Eagles.

www.abc.net.au

Killer blow: Sea Eagles, Blues rocked by Turbo injury​

‘Season over’: NRL superstar left distraught​

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[KaZa]

Cherry should have passed on the 2nd last tackle rather than go himself, looked like an overlap

He doesn't know how to pass

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

He doesn't know how to pass

Walker also had a wide open Tom in the first half and held onto it. Just saying.

 

[KaZa]

Walker also had a wide open Tom in the first half and held onto it. Just saying.

Who's the half back? I swear Koula never has more than 2-3 passes from a setplay. We never spread the ball to the right. It dies when DCE starts crabbing. Why do we always have Tom doing forward style hit ups on the 4th. We have a dumb footy side I'm afraid

 

[Jethro]

Set Restarts x 2

05:07 - Set Restart - Eels - 05:07 - Ruck Infringement - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
25:09 - Set Restart - Eels - 25:09 - Ruck Infringement - Jake Trbojevic - Sea Eagles

Harper: 1
Jake: 1


Penalties x 9

11:56 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Toafofoa Sipley - Sea Eagles
16:07 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Jake Trbojevic - Sea Eagles
24:10 - Penalty - Slow Peel - Dylan Walker - Sea Eagles
58:05 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Sean Keppie - Sea Eagles
61:47 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Haumole Olakau'atu - Sea Eagles - 62:20 - On Report
68:45 - Penalty - 2nd Effort - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
72:09 - Penalty - Late Tackle - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
72:52 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Sean Keppie - Sea Eagles - 72:58 - Sin Bin
73:12 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Christian Tuipulotu - Sea Eagles - 74:00 - On Report

Harper: 2
Keppie: 2
Jake: 1
Olakau'atu: 1
Sipley: 1
Tuipulotu: 1
Walker: 1


Errors x 8

11:18 - Error - Tom Trbojevic - Sea Eagles
28:25 - Error - Martin Taupau - Sea Eagles
34:20 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
39:50 - Error - Haumole Olakau'atu - Sea Eagles
48:13 - Error - Tolutau Koula - Sea Eagles
70:29 - Error - Kieran Foran - Sea Eagles
71:17 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
76:30 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles

Harper: 3
Foz: 1
Koula: 1
Olakau'atu: 1
Taupau: 1
Tom: 1

 

[simon64]

Always knew Mark Waugh was a smart man.

 

[Remy]

We can put the best defenders at second row, centre and wing on our right side and it will still leak points. DCE is the problem. He needs to fix up the way he defends, because every player who plays outside him is a casualty to that and is put in such a vulnerable position. I really believe Koula and Tui can become sensational defensive outside backs but they are victims to DCE's poor defensive choices that compromises them. It's been happening for years, teams expose it, they know it. SO WHY DON'T WE NOTICE IT AND FIX IT FFS!!!! DCE needs to learn and fix these mistakes.

Defence wins premierships and whilst that edge continues to be a glaring problem that teams can target effectively, we cannot touch the Provan Summons trophy.

 

[Remy]

It seems like for years we've been average an injury or two a week. It's always just an impending number of casualties. I know it happens to other clubs, but we've copped it year after year. It's obvious that it needs to be addressed and made a priority to fix up if we are to win a comp. Because Melbourne, Penrith, Roosters (except last year) are on top because they have close to their strongest side fielded on week in and week out. We are a true gritty tough team but we cannot continue with this. Get it out of the system one final time this year and make changes so we can challenge for a premiership next year.

 

[jbay]

Look up the definition of robbed,
And there will be a picture of Cummings smiling fat head looking back at you🤯

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

Who's the half back? I swear Koula never has more than 2-3 passes from a setplay. We never spread the ball to the right. It dies when DCE starts crabbing. Why do we always have Tom doing forward style hit ups on the 4th. We have a dumb footy side I'm afraid

I'm guessing the halfback is the guy who set up Tippy toes with a wonderful 30m pass. same bloke that went short to hamole when he should have gone out the back for a possible try. nobody's perfect I guess but other than perhaps Cleary or Hughes I probably wouldn't swap him. whos a better option?

 

[Captain Moondog]

The Tui head high was a joke. The bloke slips over. Penalty Eels, game over.

 

[globaleagle]

~sigh~

 

[globaleagle]

‘I don’t want to hear it’: Manly enforcer rips into ref who Hasler told to ‘review his game’

‘I don’t want to hear it’: Manly enforcer rips into ref who Hasler told to ‘review his game’

www.foxsports.com.au

Sea Eagles coach Des Hasler has taken aim at referee Ben Cummins following his side’s 22-20 loss to the Eels on Friday night.

Manly were on the wrong side of a 9-2 penalty count and Hasler took particular issue with a late penalty for a high shot while his men were defending their own line.

Christian Tuipulotu looked to have made a try-saving tackle on Hayze Perham in the dying minutes.

Perham was slipping when he was hit but Parramatta were awarded the penalty.

But Eels coach Brad Arthur said the rules were clear and it was an obvious penalty.

“Hayze might have slipped, but at the end of the day, if you make contact with someone in the head, you get penalised,” he said.

“We have, all year. You make contact with someone in the head, and you get penalised.

“Simple as that.”

 

[StuBoot]

Set Restarts x 2

05:07 - Set Restart - Eels - 05:07 - Ruck Infringement - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
25:09 - Set Restart - Eels - 25:09 - Ruck Infringement - Jake Trbojevic - Sea Eagles

Harper: 1
Jake: 1


Penalties x 9

11:56 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Toafofoa Sipley - Sea Eagles
16:07 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Jake Trbojevic - Sea Eagles

17.00 Parra try

24:10 - Penalty - Slow Peel - Dylan Walker - Sea Eagles
58:05 - Penalty - Offside Inside 10m - Sean Keppie - Sea Eagles

59.00 Parra try

61:47 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Haumole Olakau'atu - Sea Eagles - 62:20 - On Report
68:45 - Penalty - 2nd Effort - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
72:09 - Penalty - Late Tackle - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
72:52 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Sean Keppie - Sea Eagles - 72:58 - Sin Bin
73:12 - Penalty - Dangerous Tackle - Christian Tuipulotu - Sea Eagles - 74:00 - On Report

Harper: 2
Keppie: 2
Jake: 1
Olakau'atu: 1
Sipley: 1
Tuipulotu: 1
Walker: 1


Errors x 8

11:18 - Error - Tom Trbojevic - Sea Eagles
28:25 - Error - Martin Taupau - Sea Eagles

29.00 Parra try

34:20 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
39:50 - Error - Haumole Olakau'atu - Sea Eagles
48:13 - Error - Tolutau Koula - Sea Eagles
70:29 - Error - Kieran Foran - Sea Eagles
71:17 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles
76:30 - Error - Morgan Harper - Sea Eagles

77.00 Parra try (to be fair, it was a Parra forward pass)

Harper: 3
Foz: 1
Koula: 1
Olakau'atu: 1
Taupau: 1
Tom: 1

 

[JakeyB789]

We can put the best defenders at second row, centre and wing on our right side and it will still leak points. DCE is the problem. He needs to fix up the way he defends, because every player who plays outside him is a casualty to that and is put in such a vulnerable position. I really believe Koula and Tui can become sensational defensive outside backs but they are victims to DCE's poor defensive choices that compromises them. It's been happening for years, teams expose it, they know it. SO WHY DON'T WE NOTICE IT AND FIX IT FFS!!!! DCE needs to learn and fix these mistakes.

Defence wins premierships and whilst that edge continues to be a glaring problem that teams can target effectively, we cannot touch the Provan Summons trophy.

Thank you. I don’t know how DCE continues to get a free pass from fans and commentators for his performances. Harper copped so much **** after the Sharks game (deservedly) but that right edge is still leaking points so easily, even after he’s been dropped/moved. There’s a common denominator there!!

His attacking play is probably even worse at the moment too. Yes he’ll pull off a nice play like the pass to Tui last night, or kick a 40/20 or field goal every now and then but most of the time he’s running around in circles with no idea what to do. We’ve got 2 potential weapons in Haumole and Koula on that edge and yet they get absolutely ZERO good ball because DCE would rather take a tackle (without actually taking it into the line like Foz does) or chuck in a grubber and hope someone is chasing. I’m looking forward to round 13 when DCE is off on origin duty - don’t be surprised if we look at our best with Schuster and Foz as halves.

 

[Rocky]

Re taking the shot at goal before half time. We were attacking against 12 men.

Better judges can tell me otherwise, but i'm guessing the play every time takes is to go for the try in that situation.

Always looks questionable when you lose by 2...but not like it was with 5 minutes to go in the game and it was clear we needed the 2 points.

My 2 cents anyway.

 

[mike walker]

‘I don’t want to hear it’: Manly enforcer rips into ref who Hasler told to ‘review his game’

‘I don’t want to hear it’: Manly enforcer rips into ref who Hasler told to ‘review his game’

www.foxsports.com.au

Sea Eagles coach Des Hasler has taken aim at referee Ben Cummins following his side’s 22-20 loss to the Eels on Friday night.

Manly were on the wrong side of a 9-2 penalty count and Hasler took particular issue with a late penalty for a high shot while his men were defending their own line.

Christian Tuipulotu looked to have made a try-saving tackle on Hayze Perham in the dying minutes.

Perham was slipping when he was hit but Parramatta were awarded the penalty.

But Eels coach Brad Arthur said the rules were clear and it was an obvious penalty.

“Hayze might have slipped, but at the end of the day, if you make contact with someone in the head, you get penalised,” he said.

“We have, all year. You make contact with someone in the head, and you get penalised.

“Simple as that.”

G'day all, Until 3 tackles later when Taupau clearly smacks a bloke flush in the mouth,who stays down for the penalty and play on. Or when Jake picks up a loose ball,cops a smack to the head,hesitates looks at ref then realises nothing coming so play on.
cheers mike

 

[ManEagle]

Re taking the shot at goal before half time. We were attacking against 12 men.

Better judges can tell me otherwise, but i'm guessing the play every time takes is to go for the try in that situation.

Always looks questionable when you lose by 2...but not like it was with 5 minutes to go in the game and it was clear we needed the 2 points.

My 2 cents anyway.

Given the time left in the first half I thought we would go for goal. Not going to criticise that decision though as I can see why with 12 they wanted to try to score. Hindsight and all that.
Besides Garrick missed 2 conversions, difficult ones but missed, so no use thinking of ifs and maybes'.

 

[Brisbane Tragic]

Wow...the doomsdayers need to take note of that whole hearted spirited performance last night. What a fabulous performance. Was it perfect - nope - did Harper and Keppie's stupidity and errors cost us absolutely. Should we have won with any decent sort of refereeing - without a doubt. Des has really lost the dressing room, the players can't play... the game plan/structures are wrong bla bla bla. When the PLAYERS control the ball like they did last night except for maybe that last 10 mins we can challenge all sides. Losing Tom will make it really tough BUT if we can keep everyone on the field relatively injury free, get Parker, Paseka and Lawton back we still have a very very good side. Garrick is no Tom but gee he is a quality quality player. Schu will help with that creativity. Haumole will be gone for say two weeks so Davey and Schu in the backrow and that aint a bad backrow at all with at least 10 sides wishing they had that backrow. It is front row where we have a huge issue..... while Lodge is a grub or was and he isn't the next messiah... gee IF we did pick him up now that would be massive. Keppie is plain ordinary, Sipley the same, Marty has his moments, Aloiai - great quality - Paseka CAN be great quality... Lodge would add massively for us this year and we will need some grunt now with Tom gone as we will need to play a pretty different grind it out type of game. But yes those doomsdayers howling about all manner of garbage again need to give themselves a dozen uppercuts. We should all be very proud of that effort... considering the quality players we have out, we lost Tom, Keppie gone for the last 10 minutes AND that abomination of a refereeing display gee we played strong done good... just plain robbed in the end!