Broncos legend says Manly has been 'sucked in by Seibold's psycho-babble'.

[SeaEagleRock8]

Yep, ex manly players have coached 11 premierships since 1972. Willey, biscuits, bozo, Des, Cleary, Reilly.

Non-manly coaches win the rest, so that’s another perspective.

Not bad when you put it that way.
22% of premierships in the last 50 years coached by ex-Manly players.

 

[Rosko]

Got to say that article is hilarious. The amount of times they repeated the phrase psycho-babble is so funny.
Kind of states that all Broncos are thick. Didn't need to tell me this.
Hopefully Manly players are smarter. Maybe Manly can employ someone to hold up picture cards to match the psycho-babble.
Run.
Tackle.
Catch ball.
Don't drop ball.
Score try.
High five team mates.

Go Manly!

And never start a sentence with "Don't" to a footballer...

 

[nightster]

He didn't fit in at Brisbane because he is smart.

and he was seen by the Donk fans as shafting demigod Wayne ... but of course it was the Donkies board that shafted Wayne, Siebold was on a hiding to nothing walking into that.

 

[eaglebuzz]

Cool trick but that wasn't the question

Now please reveal the manly premiership coach who did not play for manly in his playing career

Pretty specious logic.

Can you point out the Manly pride jersey that wasn't a total cluster f#$k?

 

[BOZO]

Yep, ex manly players have coached 11 premierships since 1972. Willey, biscuits, bozo, Des, Cleary, Reilly.

Non-manly coaches win the rest, so that’s another perspective.

Well said

and those other clubs premiership winning coaches were not all former club players of their winning teams

 

[cherry_poppins]

Pretty specious logic.

Can you point out the Manly pride jersey that wasn't a total cluster f#$k?

Again someone who doesn't answer a simple question

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

Psycho babble was the original thread i stopped reading a quarter of the way.

 

[Red Pill]

Gee if psycho babble is a requirement to get a coaching gig at Manly well it’s on tap here!
No Need to pay big $ When you can get it for free.
LOL pyscho babble seems like a sophisticated way of saying talking rhetoric… / sh!t…
Seems like a sour grapes type statement to me.

 

[eaglebuzz]

Again someone who doesn't answer a simple question

You already know the answer to the question. The answer will remain the answer until it is no longer the answer.

The thing your question seems to be assuming is that it's only ever going to be a former Manly player that will ever coach the club to a premiership, which seems pretty absurd logic for the reasons that you've already been posed by others, with a dash of common sense thrown in.

 

[cherry_poppins]

You already know the answer to the question. The answer will remain the answer until it is no longer the answer.

The thing your question seems to be assuming is that it's only ever going to be a former Manly player that will ever coach the club to a premiership, which seems pretty absurd logic for the reasons that you've already been posed by others, with a dash of common sense thrown in.

Why do you think the answer is what the answer is? It's not like we haven't had outsiders take up the mantle

We aren't souffs,Wests or any other pathetic club people feel bad for, we are the outsiders, we are the club hated by nearly all, we don't have bandwagoners that aren't just lapsed fans of a game that's not recognisable

That's why we have success with our own, because outsiders don't understand the required mindset

If everyone supposedly knows the answer why not let it out?

 

[ManEagle]

and he was seen by the Donk fans as shafting demigod Wayne ... but of course it was the Donkies board that shafted Wayne, Siebold was on a hiding to nothing walking into that.

Guess it didnt help with mcguire at the same time saying he white anted him at souths.

 

[mickqld]

Meanwhile Pat Carrigan full of praise for Seibold and the way he coached. Always thought Pst was fairly intelligent guy wish he would follow Ant to Manly. Was only the dumbos in the team who couldn't understand reading or writing and chip on the shoulder old boys that caused the donkey disaster.

 

[Seagles68]

A Carrigan type player would certainly show the others the way.

 

[mickqld]

A Carrigan type player would certainly show the others the way.

Well I definitely take Pat's word who played under him over a disgruntled, grudge holding ex has been.

 

[Eagle 1]

Well I definitely take Pat's word who played under him over a disgruntled, grudge holding ex has been.

Yeah, Renouff was one of a handful of ex Broncs players secretly conspiring to undermine Seibold to pave the way clear for Kevvie to take over. And to date, what a disaster Kevvie has been.

 

[Cochrane]

You have to question one's mental health, stability etc, to feel they need to come out 2 years after the fact and publicly rubbish an individual.
People who are happy and confident with what they've got in life, don't have this level of hate, it's time wasting, and there are better things to do with their time.

My advice to Renouf is keep steering his own ship, enjoy what's ahead, and leave others to do what they will with their life.

The only person who looked poor and child-like with this article is Steve Renouf.

 

[Budgie]

Meanwhile Pat Carrigan full of praise for Seibold and the way he coached. Always thought Pst was fairly intelligent guy wish he would follow Ant to Manly. Was only the dumbos in the team who couldn't understand reading or writing and chip on the shoulder old boys that caused the donkey disaster.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1582675534299164672