Nice Beaver
Bencher
Some interesting insights people have;
What does it mean to be defensively poor and does being defensively poor make you not tough? Well we need to find a half a new team. I think the way defence is taught today contributes to this. The need to stop 2nd phase, to tackle ball and all, requires an upright defensive style. Physics will tell you when you stand tall in an unathletic position like that and your opposite, who weighs up to 20kg more is running straight at you while you slide sideways that isnt a battle you often win.
Then, what is someone who cant tackle? Is it missed tackles? ineffective tackles? Does a look at the season Tackle effectiveness of our backs tells a story. There were 440 players who played first grade this year and this is how ours ranked:
436. J Wright 60%
428. Uate 65%
408. Kelly 72%
391. Taufua 74%
384. T Trbojevic 75%
367. D Walker 77%
356. Hodkinson/Parker/T Wright 78%
279. Cherry 83%
228. Suli 86%
J Wright, Uate and Kelly were all in the bottom 10% defensively with Taufua scrapping just above the cut. Taking it down to the bottom 15% brings in Taufua and Tommy Turbo. Does this mean they aren't tough or we should get rid of them or they cant tackle?
Im not sure I see how the argument has come to questioning T Wright's toughness or that he cant tackle, he was far from the worst offender in our team. His tackle technique needed work, definitely. I guess when you are 2 and 1/2 years into learning the game vs many who probably start as 6 year olds you are a little behind in the learning curve not to mention his first year of development was destroyed through injuries.
Then again the recruitment team have found us and maybe not surprisingly the following replacements:
418. B Elliot 64%
390. K Elgey 74%
Its been well documented that both kids Wright and Anderson have x factor there seems many reasons why it wasn't development an nurtured properly or long enough, shame either way to lose promising kids like this. Im just thankful the likes of Cliffy and Phil Blake played in an era when structure wasnt paramount before all else, where creativity and x-factor weren't a liability and I got to enjoy watching them.
J Wright played what? 1 game of 1st grade this season? I'll choose to disregard him from a sample group.
Every player who plays first grade is tough. Its the toughness in attitude to apply yourself.
Wright got an offer to go back to 2 tackles a game Union, or stick it out with league.
Toughness to apply yourself. Lacking.