The Kieran Forum

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

If he’s that good why isn’t his current club and other clubs throwing money at him?

He reminds me of watmough when he left manly...he also played one or two years too many!

Like i said above still one of the best players in the game. I dont know who is or who isnt offering him a contract. He will end up somewhere i hope its with us. Because cust and dce combo wont win us a premiership imho. Cust needs to become our hooker because levi and croker are garbage. Not a footballers asshole between them

 

[40 years an eagle]

Like i said above still one of the best players in the game.

Maybe one of the best players at the Dogs. Maybe.

 

[BOZO]

The reality is feathered friends
When Foz is on the field he is more dominant than any player we have had playing 5/8 this year

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

Maybe one of the best players at the Dogs. Maybe.

You dont watch much footy do you? His stats are better than dces and he plays for the team coming last. He does his best but his team mates always let him down. He is great to watch.
@manlyfan76 i see you buddy dont worry, hopping on anything against foran. Its quite sad especially for a grown man who is 50 plus... and quite weird.
Cant wait for the announcement ooooo weeeee ill make sure i tag you both

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

The reality is feathered friends
When Foz is on the field he is more dominant than any player we have had playing 5/8 this year

Bingo.. and some might say better than any 7 we played this year.

 

[40 years an eagle]

You dont watch much footy do you?

I watched all the games he has played this season.

He is a career-ending injury just waiting to happen. I'm sure he won't be coming to Manly. We'll see I guess.

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

I watched all the games he has played this season.

He is a career-ending injury just waiting to happen. I'm sure he won't be coming to Manly. We'll see I guess.

And you think he might he the dogs best player? Who is better? This will be good

So you dont rate him?
Please answer this for me..
do you think foran will make us better?
Do you think we can win a premiership with cust and dce ?
Cheers

 

[ManlyTragic]

Like i said above still one of the best players in the game. I dont know who is or who isnt offering him a contract. He will end up somewhere i hope its with us. Because cust and dce combo wont win us a premiership imho. Cust needs to become our hooker because levi and croker are garbage. Not a footballers asshole between them

Maybe so but Forans time has come and gone!

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

Maybe so but Forans time has come and gone!

He still performs at a high level consistently.. if only our new falcon million dollar man could do the same.

Let me ask you this who is better in your opinion?

Ash Taylor
Nikorima
chanel harris tavita
Jamal fogerty
Cust
Brooks
Benji
Josh Reynolds
Adam Reynolds
Drinkwater
Hampton
Milford
Brodie croft
Moylan
Townsend

Or Foran (for 350-400k)
Because to me and im sure most league fans he is better than all of those players and his numbers prove it. You add cherry evans who he will free up to play his natural game. Walker outside him and turbo out back and we could have one of the best attacking edges in the comp.

Sincerely yours.
Biff.

 

[40 years an eagle]

And you think he might he the dogs best player? Who is better? This will be good

1 So you dont rate him?
Please answer this for me..
2 do you think foran will make us better?
3 Do you think we can win a premiership with cust and dce ?
Cheers

1 Rocks and diamonds. A basket case.
2 Maybe for 131 minutes per season.
3 Nope. Or with DCE and Foran either.

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

1 Rocks and diamonds. A basket case.
2 Maybe for 131 minutes per season.
3 Nope. Or with DCE and Foran either.

What the heck... are you messing around or are you serious? A basket case LOL
131 minutes per season... so in other words yes! You agree he will make us better thank you!

So you dont think a backline of..
Turbo
Garrick
Suli
Walker
Hoppa
Foran
Dce

Is capable of challenging? I strongly disagree... perhaps you have forgotten how dangerous turbo and walker are!

Anyways thanks for agreeing the Foz will make us better. #Foran2021Eagle

 

[frank stokes]

The reality is feathered friends
When Foz is on the field he is more dominant than any player we have had playing 5/8 this year

...well actually @BOZO you could probably extend that to 'since he left'...

 

[ManlyTragic]

He still performs at a high level consistently.. if only our new falcon million dollar man could do the same.

Let me ask you this who is better in your opinion?

Ash Taylor
Nikorima
chanel harris tavita
Jamal fogerty
Cust
Brooks
Benji
Josh Reynolds
Adam Reynolds
Drinkwater
Hampton
Milford
Brodie croft
Moylan
Townsend

Or Foran (for 350-400k)
Because to me and im sure most league fans he is better than all of those players and his numbers prove it. You add cherry evans who he will free up to play his natural game. Walker outside him and turbo out back and we could have one of the best attacking edges in the comp.

Sincerely yours.
Biff.

Biff! Why do you need to go to the trouble of list the worst halves....why don’t you prepare a fair list including some of the better ones!

 

[Damien2812]

Foz would be a good pickup to join Turbo on the sideline.. 😛

 

[KNUCKLES]

Biff! Why do you need to go to the trouble of list the worst halves....why don’t you prepare a fair list including some of the better ones!

There's probably not to many better than foran when he is on the park.. here's a list of so called elite..
Sean Johnson - NO
Luke Keary - NO
Adam Reynolds - NO
Cameron Munster - NO
Michael Morgan - YES
Mitchell Pearce - PAR
Mitchell Moses - NO
Nathan Cleary - NO
Anthony Milford - YES
Ben Hunt - YES
Nikorima - YES
Ashley Taylor - YES
Dylan Brown - NO
Luke Brooks - YES
Benji Marshall - YES
Corey Norman- YES
Chad Townsend- YES
Jahrome Hughes - YES

The players that are better we have zero chance of getting and some of them may not reach the heights foran has in his career previously and some are only better because of their individual athleticity but aren't a genuine half like foran. For eg. Johnson can step his way through a team and is a star because of it but his game management is lacking. Foran is the best option available to us if we are seeking a half unless we have a loose mil to splurge

 

[eaglebuzz]

I'd have Foran but only at a bargain basement price. He's way too injury prone.

 

[Disco]

If thats all you have im sorry but that is nothing.. he was owed money so he wanted what he was owed. We would all do the same if we left an employer and they owed us money.

The 2nd article is also nothing... alleged fixing of the game which they didn't do.

Also this has nothing to do with the original post. I asked if foran strung the club along etc not after he left he sued the club. I think he loved manly but was on the fence, twatmough in his ear. Des gone... the slimy dalai in his other ear.

To me des left in way worse circumstances and i was calling for his return for years.. foran and des are Manly men and i believe with foran for such a cheap price he will absolutely be an asset for the club... can anyone disagree?

I did answer, it was the whole cafegate situation.

A prominent forum member here claimed he overheard Foran in a cafe saying he had agreed to go to Parra but was holding out to screw Manly (paraphrased).
This forum member was a Foran fan, had no reason or form to make such a thing up and turned on him instantly and out of the blue. They then copped ridicule and derision for a month or two before it played out exactly how he stated.
Furphy....perhaps but an awfully strange coincidence or sheer pot luck that the stars aligned.

Anyway to your question, as I said previously, I personally don't think it is a slam dunk. I think Foran on 350k is a 50/50 chance to be a success or absolute failure.

I think their are much better options in a footballing sense

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

I did answer, it was the whole cafegate situation.

A prominent forum member here claimed he overheard Foran in a cafe saying he had agreed to go to Parra but was holding out to screw Manly (paraphrased).
This forum member was a Foran fan, had no reason or form to make such a thing up and turned on him instantly and out of the blue. They then copped ridicule and derision for a month or two before it played out exactly how he stated.
Furphy....perhaps but an awfully strange coincidence or sheer pot luck that the stars aligned.

Anyway to your question, as I said previously, I personally don't think it is a slam dunk. I think Foran on 350k is a 50/50 chance to be a success or absolute failure.

I think their are much better options in a footballing sense

Cafegate ah i see.... so no proof whatsoever then. Can you tell me these better options and how you would like the team to look moving forward ie what do we do with walker and now fainu will be out next year as well. Would you keep Levi and croker? Im keen to know. Cheers

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

Biff! Why do you need to go to the trouble of list the worst halves....why don’t you prepare a fair list including some of the better ones!

You said he was done im pointing out all the current players he is better than. Think i made a great point and he's willing to take 350-400k. Best price for a great player. You wont get a player of his calibre for cheaper. Well worth the risk imho

 

[Bring back the.... Biff?]

There's probably not to many better than foran when he is on the park.. here's a list of so called elite..
Sean Johnson - NO
Luke Keary - NO
Adam Reynolds - NO
Cameron Munster - NO
Michael Morgan - YES
Mitchell Pearce - PAR
Mitchell Moses - NO
Nathan Cleary - NO
Anthony Milford - YES
Ben Hunt - YES
Nikorima - YES
Ashley Taylor - YES
Dylan Brown - NO
Luke Brooks - YES
Benji Marshall - YES
Corey Norman- YES
Chad Townsend- YES
Jahrome Hughes - YES

The players that are better we have zero chance of getting and some of them may not reach the heights foran has in his career previously and some are only better because of their individual athleticity but aren't a genuine half like foran. For eg. Johnson can step his way through a team and is a star because of it but his game management is lacking. Foran is the best option available to us if we are seeking a half unless we have a loose mil to splurge

Pretty fair list.. Reynolds has a good kicking game but he is nowhere near foran with ball in hand. Foran is better than moses and Brown. Lol brown... and pearce as well. His problem is injury which we all know.

Moses has 3 try assists and brown has 5... hah!