The Guthersation

[manlywarringah]

I’d love to have Gutherson back but I was a little worried about him coming back to play centre. If one of the reasons he left us in the first place was to play fullback, it didn’t sit well with me he coming back to a position he’d rather not play in.

Maybe we were used to get his price up at parra, good on them if it worked out that way. The slime paying overs to keep him was a win in the end.

It still irks me to see him in that slimey jumper but we can spend our money on signing our young guns coming through.

As for Roberts, he may be fast but that is all he has going for him. I think that signing will end badly. I’d stick with Walker, better the devil you know...

 

[The Wheel]

Time to lock this and move on - we were always a porn in a bigger game for his Manager!

 

[Supreme Leader]

The same sources that had jorge taufua being converted to a second rower, or the official on the plane to new york to sign mitchell pearce. Your a muppet, talk about walter mitty like visions of grandeur

Well thanks for that Mutley, have a nice day, didn't realise you knew me.

 

[Coops manly]

I would rather sign Walker on a cheaper deal if he comes back and plays well and spend the leftover money on Schuster young trobojevic etc

 

[Budgie]

Heart wanted him back. Head said no.
Good result.

 

[Woodsie]

What halfbacks and fullbacks ( for the same money) are on the market?

maloney ? Don't Parra have a new Peter Sterling coming through every year ?

Where there is money there is a way ....

 

[Harmless27]

Great outcome for him.

And lets be honest, all of this has likely cost Parra extra $$$, and perhaps de-stabilised their season too. What a ripper! Good man Gutho - playing for manly even whilst playing for the Eels.

Onwards and upwards. Gotta finish above them this year.

 

[Nice Beaver]

For the love if God, do NOT go after Roberts.

If they want a fast moron who taints the club's reputation ......we have one in Walker. Just re-sign him.

At least he knows the systems, offers more ball playing options than Roberts...and would hopefully have some sense of loyalty to Des and the club after his recent trial.

Roberts is fast. That's it.

He is a far greater risk to team culture than Walker.

Would prefer both away from Brookvale, but if its one or the other....I'll take Walker every time.

 

[brad]

Exciting times ahead . Do we keep Walker or go on the market ? Great to be a Manly supporter.

 

[MANLY4LIFE]

Good let it go !!! keep walker cheaper if he plays good rest of the season if not im sure des has a plan C ,as for roberts a big FAT N-O

 

[joeboy]

Happy for gutho.. now, please for the love of whatever’s holy, manly- do not chase Roberts, would rather keep what we have than sign him.

Speed kills!!! (literally)

Do. Not. Want

 

[KOMORI]

Well... that’s that it would seem...

As for Roberts.. as was alluded to by a few posters, apparently there’s a few serious issues that have been swept under the carpet by Brisbane: what odds that he signs with us and those issues are all suddenly aired, and Toddles does his famous “eyeball” test and suspends him?

Not worth the risk..

 

[Deleted member 26876]

Disappointing but ultimately that scenario was a win win for us. Gutho either leaves to manly, hurting the eels, or Gutho forces the eels to re-sign Brad Arthur so that he can make them pay overs for him to stay, hurting the eels 🙂

 

[yokahontas]

Time to lock this and move on - we were always a porn in a bigger game for his Manager!

Or a pawn, even!

(Sorry to do it, but that typo/word substitution is gold...the mental image, perhaps not so much!)

 

[yokahontas]

Well... that’s that it would seem...

As for Roberts.. as was alluded to by a few posters, apparently there’s a few serious issues that have been swept under the carpet by Brisbane: what odds that he signs with us and those issues are all suddenly aired, and Toddles does his famous “eyeball” test and suspends him?

Not worth the risk..

I think there’s a good chance those issues will start to see the light of day just by him coming back to any Sydney club, let alone Manly!

 

[Woodsie]

Or a pawn, even!

(Sorry to do it, but that typo/word substitution is gold...the mental image, perhaps not so much!)

Then there is the Fruedian angle ....

 

[The Wheel]

Then there is the Fruedian angle ....

Ever heard of being ****ed over?

 

[yokahontas]

Then there is the Fruedian angle ....

Freud...that mother$&@!er?

 

[Waz13]

Good, manly jnr or otherwise we don’t need him.

 

[KNUCKLES]

Or a pawn, even!

(Sorry to do it, but that typo/word substitution is gold...the mental image, perhaps not so much!)

No.. what's wrong with porn? 😉