Schuster or Foran for 5/8th 2022

[Brisbane Tragic]

Then have Davey and Big O as your backrowers instead of Big O and Schu

 

[double hoops]

Shoe to lock. Which is now more than ever a third half.

 

[40 nil]

6. Schuster
7. Foran
9. Cherry-Evans

 

[JakeyB789]

Unlike his halves partner Foran plays at the line and doesn’t look lost every possession but unfortunately he’s also far slower than he used to be and is a defensive liability. It’s not 2011 anymore so not sure how so many here could think keeping our most talented player out of position is the right move, especially when he’s killed it every time he’s played in the halves.

 

[Rocky]

Shoe to lock. Which is now more than ever a third half.

Can the Schu handle the defensive workload at lock? Cant imagine that's something that would excite him and would perhaps blunt his attacking flair.

 

[Kaufusi's Elbow]

6. Schuster
7. Foran
9. Cherry-Evans

Wish I could "like" this twice. You have cracked the dilemma

 

[KNUCKLES]

Wish I could "like" this twice. You have cracked the dilemma

I dont know if DCE could handle the workload in the middle. He is built like a string bean

 

[jbb/james]

I dont know if DCE could handle the workload in the middle. He is built like a string bean

hasnt used the shoulder in a long while either. the hip toss is his go. I see 14 in the future when the heat is out of it

I think this hip toss technique is partly why our right side falls to ****

he races up out of the line to position himself to be almost cover tackling and can use the alfie throw. he runs up/past and gets em on the way back in.Like he is body surfing almost , its much more subtle of course but hard to put wordy explain. but watch

 

[alafua8]

If you think Foran is our problem and that Schuster is going to miraculously solve all these problems then you’ve seriously got no clue mate. Why is this even a thread?

This debate will only be solved if Schuster is given 10 games at 6 or 7 when he comes back .It will be interesting to see what he can do with the ball at first receiver . We definitely need something new after watching the finals last year and the first 2 games this year .The opposition are reading our game so easily that they only have to cover Tom and our attack is dead .They won't be fanning out to cover Tom when Schuster gets the ball .

 

[Woodsie]

I will reserve my judgment until I see Tupoloopa play against Olam.

 

[Eagle 1]

This debate will only be solved if Schuster is given 10 games at 6 or 7 when he comes back .It will be interesting to see what he can do with the ball at first receiver . We definitely need something new after watching the finals last year and the first 2 games this year .The opposition are reading our game so easily that they only have to cover Tom and our attack is dead .They won't be fanning out to cover Tom when Schuster gets the ball .

Schuster doesn't help his cause by being injured again, and they usually last 4 weeks or more.

 

[alafua8]

Schuster doesn't help his cause by being injured again, and they usually last 4 weeks or more.

His injuries seems to be always at training , so I'm guessing that maybe we are training the house down but not translating it to game day .Still be very interesting to watch him play when he is back .Hope he brings something new because at the moment we need it .

 

[double hoops]

Can the Schu handle the defensive workload at lock? Cant imagine that's something that would excite him and would perhaps blunt his attacking flair.

Walkz copes.

 

[Eagle 1]

His injuries seems to be always at training , so I'm guessing that maybe we are training the house down but not translating it to game day .Still be very interesting to watch him play when he is back .Hope he brings something new because at the moment we need it .

or maybe it's a young guys thing, where your still growing inside your body. Tommy went through that stage, and knock on wood, it's over for him now.

 

[XV-1]

Now DCE has signed for 2 more years, will Manly offer Foran 2 more years. He is 2 years younger than DCE.

What will Schuster do if this happens?

I wonder what the half planning is in the Manly club.

 

[KNUCKLES]

Now DCE has signed for 2 more years, will Manly offer Foran 2 more years. He is 2 years younger than DCE.

What will Schuster do if this happens?

I wonder what the half planning is in the Manly club.

Bye bye Humphreys

 

[JenEagle]

Bye bye Humphreys

And the younger Fainu

 

[Disco]

Foran won't get another 2 years, different player, different situation.

Fainu wont be going anywhere, he is the chosen one.

Humphrys....maybe, and maybe he'll be the next Nicho Hynes but maybe he'll be Will Pearsell or Aaron Groom.

 

[XV-1]

Foran won't get another 2 years, different player, different situation.

Fainu wont be going anywhere, he is the chosen one.

Humphrys....maybe, and maybe he'll be the next Nicho Hynes but maybe he'll be Will Pearsell or Aaron Groom.

Foran wants to play next year. He father Des has always looked after him.

Could be some issues coming.

 

[KNUCKLES]

Foran won't get another 2 years, different player, different situation.

Fainu wont be going anywhere, he is the chosen one.

Humphrys....maybe, and maybe he'll be the next Nicho Hynes but maybe he'll be Will Pearsell or Aaron Groom.

True.. but I don't recall 6 clubs chasing either three of these players mentioned above at the time.