Realistic Premiership window opens 2022

  • We had an issue with background services between march 10th and 15th or there about. This meant the payment services were not linking to automatic upgrades. If you paid for premium membership and are still seeing ads please let me know and the email you used against PayPal and I cam manually verify and upgrade your account.

maxta

First Grader
Premium Member
This year showed some promise and there were even games and moments when as a Seaeagle supporter, you could feel a legitimate challenge was not far away, though deep down had that "1 year away" type voice....
Well 2022 is THAT year and with plenty of teams changing personel and maybe even losing some strike....this young Manly team has had minimal losses that would be classed as a negative and young pup Bullemore from Bronco's is an ideal middle man, to help momentum which is exactly what is needed.
The pack is good and maybe the hard edge may come in 2022 to ice the cake....the integral position is hooker and is the biggest concern going into next season with Fainu seemingly a show as Manly have kept the faith and support obviously believing this for good reason, but the fact remains he will not Start the year and Croker again, will be the 9 early on.
Croker played solid in 2021 - in fact lost his whipping boy tag and done well, but the importance of strike from here like a Cook, Grant or Cheese in the modern game - he is not.
The other concern in the outside backs was exposed in the finals, though I allow some lattitude here in the fact they are young and played super during the regular season...many great players have had a few ordinary performances in their early days, which is all forgotten once they become big name players.
Really feel 2022 is the time the stars allign and is the start of another dominent era and maybe a few premierships, the potential is definately open, so fasten up Silvertails - time for Manly to again take the thrown and dominate the NRL.
 
Froggy was a 5/8 when he came into the NRL so he had the step, speed and nous of a pivotal player.
Perhaps, when shifted to hooker, he was under instructions to pass not run. It's either that or his injuries have restricted his attack.
 
Froggy was a 5/8 when he came into the NRL so he had the step, speed and nous of a pivotal player.
Perhaps, when shifted to hooker, he was under instructions to pass not run. It's either that or his injuries have restricted his attack.
His teenage highlights show a very dynamic runner, with speed off the mark. I think the multiple knee injuries have restricted him, possibly he won't regain those talents.
 
I don’t believe in the phrase”Premiership window”in the NRL.It’s valid in the AFL given the fact they have a draft,clubs basically build from the bottom up so it takes many years to develop a side and players can’t break contracts mid year and if they want to leave still under contract at the end of the year,compensation is required to that team depending on the players status,whether restricted or unrestricted.In the NRL,it’s a free for all.Look at the signings the Dogs made.Not saying they can go anywhere near a premiership,nor the 8 for that matter,but it shows that teams can completely change their roster within 12 months to improve their position
 
The forward pack doesnt lay the platform against the top teams.
Very fair call based on 2021, just expecting a harder pack based on the youngsters gaining that hard love and experience this season...some youth that will come back stronger....the age of our pack is VERY young - Paseka, Schu, okalatu, Keppie and should improve both mentally and physically in 2022
 
Froggy was a 5/8 when he came into the NRL so he had the step, speed and nous of a pivotal player.
Perhaps, when shifted to hooker, he was under instructions to pass not run. It's either that or his injuries have restricted his attack.
I did not see any nous , step or speed when he played 5/8 for us

When he played 5/8 for us the 5/8 position was clearly out of his depth at NRL level
 
We haven’t changed enough to prove we can compete with the top teams. In fact we didn’t really beat the top teams when we needed to.

We need more changes to our squad to compete and win a premiership. Notably Our 6, 9, a decent centre and better depth for Turbo.

We are 1 decent Turbo injury away from finishing outside the 8.

No premiership window yet - not until we recruit better and/or utilise the players we have better eg changes like Schuster to 6…
I see from the same window you are looking through feathered friend

How affective is Hope without change ?

Change is hope and and there is no hope without change

We need to change from being a one Man Tommy team

Shut down Tommy and they shut down Manly

and in the Finals footy where the Tops teams step up a gear they showed us up

Who will be the change to step up when they shut down Tommy again

Parker , Crocker , Harper , ??? We need more from these players and the question is ....
Just how much more juice can you squeeze from an orange?

Foran was solid at six but could not keep up with the other sensational young halves

AFB was a massive go forward loss

Who will step up for this change of hope for the grand final window to open ???
 
His teenage highlights show a very dynamic runner, with speed off the mark. I think the multiple knee injuries have restricted him, possibly he won't regain those talents.
The moral of the you tube highlight reels .....

So many dynamic teenage highlights reels and so few NRL high flyers
 
We haven’t changed enough to prove we can compete with the top teams. In fact we didn’t really beat the top teams when we needed to.

We need more changes to our squad to compete and win a premiership. Notably Our 6, 9, a decent centre and better depth for Turbo.

We are 1 decent Turbo injury away from finishing outside the 8.

No premiership window yet - not until we recruit better and/or utilise the players we have better eg changes like Schuster to 6…
Bit harsh Batty, Foran consistently rated in our top 5 in the majority of games last season. He struck up a great combo with Tom on Forans side, resulting in Garrick cashing in and into the top 5 of try scorers. Things have a habit of working themselves out, and no doubt we will see him play some games at 6 next season. Eventually Schuster will be our next 5/8 in 23, in the meantime, if it's not broke why fix it.
 
Most of the games we lost we had a poor possession rate ,if we can get 50/50 ball we should be in the game against the top sides,need to grind a win out better
And our obvious errors, the Semi final against Sths was criminal. We made it all to easy for Sths, the ball we had in the later stages proved what we were capable of. Good learning curve for our guys, that should hold us in good stead for next season.
 
The reality is feathered friend it is broke

They broke us up big time and kicked us out of the finals
So you're zeroing in on Foran Bozo, he's your fall guy then, amazing !! Any other players you want to throw in there as well.
 
Most of the games we lost we had a poor possession rate ,if we can get 50/50 ball we should be in the game against the top sides,need to grind a win out better
So we get 50 /50

What happens when they shut down Nifty

Nifty is Tommy

Who will step up ???

Because the fact is we were a one Man Tommy points machine Manly team
 
So you're zeroing in on Foran Bozo, he's your fall guy then, amazing !! Any other players you want to throw in there as well.
We all have amazing views feathered friend
And I do not view the young Foran from a decade ago in our 2011 winning premiership grand final to the slower 2021 version

Perspective time ???
How good were you 10 years ago @Eagle 1 ???
 
Bit harsh Batty, Foran consistently rated in our top 5 in the majority of games last season. He struck up a great combo with Tom on Forans side, resulting in Garrick cashing in and into the top 5 of try scorers. Things have a habit of working themselves out, and no doubt we will see him play some games at 6 next season. Eventually Schuster will be our next 5/8 in 23, in the meantime, if it's not broke why fix it.
The better teams noticeably target Foz in defence. He was a weak link and I say that as someone who has a soft spot for the bloke.
 

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe
Team P W L PD Pts
7 6 1 54 14
6 5 1 59 12
6 4 2 53 10
6 4 2 30 10
7 4 2 25 9
8 4 4 73 8
7 4 3 40 8
7 4 3 24 8
7 3 4 17 8
7 4 3 -8 8
8 4 4 -60 8
8 3 4 17 7
6 2 4 -31 6
7 3 4 -41 6
7 2 5 -29 4
7 1 6 -87 4
7 1 6 -136 4
Back
Top Bottom