[Resurrected] Marty's rumoured wanderings thread

  • We had an issue with background services between march 10th and 15th or there about. This meant the payment services were not linking to automatic upgrades. If you paid for premium membership and are still seeing ads please let me know and the email you used against PayPal and I cam manually verify and upgrade your account.
  • We have been getting regular requests for users who have been locked out of their accounts because they have changed email adresses over the lifetime of their accounts. Please make sure the email address under your account is your current and correct email address in order to avoid this in the future. You can set your email address at https://silvertails.net/account/account-details
So he's not getting renewed for 2023 as I read it ??
It's rd 3 2021.
I just don't get rugba leege anymore. Think I'm getting close to over it totally the way it's going.

I would think the thinking is that another club is more likely to pick him up now rather than when he is 2 years older ... and that Kapow also has a better chance of signing a longer contract than he would in 2 years time ... works for both parties to do it now ..
 
Imagine the culture of throwing a season away after TWO games.

Empty stands , fans pissed off , players but giving a **** !!

Honestly if this continues it wouldn’t surprise me if they ask us to hand our license in so they can appoint an area that actually gives a ****!!

Well, that's the danger, and we know there will be one happy man - Todd Greenberg!. For whatever reason he wanted this club to die, he will get his wish in the end.

NYEagle
 
Well, that's the danger, and we know there will be one happy man - Todd Greenberg!. For whatever reason he wanted this club to die, he will get his wish in the end.

NYEagle

If you think about the NRL as a business , and without any emotion for things in the past, that’s inevitable.

Where do you go to increase TV ratings and get new interest !!

There’s THREE strong contenders here in QLD.

There’s too many sides in Sydney.

Potentially they just don’t renew the contract, yes it makes no sense to leave the north side empty BUT if there’s little interest and we don’t rate then “ Seeya”.

Get rid of Manly / Cronulla

Two new sides in Brisbane , one plays out of Suncorp one plays out of Robina.

TV ratings climb

Everyone’s a winner !!

Except us and Sharkies fans who are lost to the game.
 
If you think about the NRL as a business , and without any emotion for things in the past, that’s inevitable.

Where do you go to increase TV ratings and get new interest !!

There’s THREE strong contenders here in QLD.

There’s too many sides in Sydney.

Potentially they just don’t renew the contract, yes it makes no sense to leave the north side empty BUT if there’s little interest and we don’t rate then “ Seeya”.

Get rid of Manly / Cronulla

Two new sides in Brisbane , one plays out of Suncorp one plays out of Robina.

TV ratings climb

Everyone’s a winner !!

Except us and Sharkies fans who are lost to the game.
In the end it is all about PEOPLE POWER

If the POWER OF SOUTHS PEOPLE CAN BRING BACK SOUTHS FROM THE DEAD

THE POWER OF THE MANLY PEOPLE CAN KEEP OUR CLUB ALIVE

This is why I keep reminding you all of this .....
PASSIONATE PEOPLE POWER ALWAYS PREVAILS !!!

2021 NRL Membership Tracker​

Club Name202120202020201920182017
13 Mar13 MarFinalFinalFinalFinal
Parramatta29,51026,80928,15625,25825,14524,501
South Sydney29,23328,54229,67029,62629,18930,220
Canberra18,82118,38819,03920,12120,05519,091
Newcastle18,77918,13918,86020,66518,01713,370
Wests Tigers17,46816,23517,91220,73920,79418,074
Sydney Roosters15,18215,15716,40716,38416,04416,001
St Geo Illa15,00015,03515,27221,02821,19719,181
Canterbury12,70815,17015,17018,34319,57018,833
Manly10,76912,52412,88712,44012,43013,163

EmG8ZOOVoAE4gM6 (1).jpg

 
If you think about the NRL as a business , and without any emotion for things in the past, that’s inevitable.

Where do you go to increase TV ratings and get new interest !!

There’s THREE strong contenders here in QLD.

There’s too many sides in Sydney.

Potentially they just don’t renew the contract, yes it makes no sense to leave the north side empty BUT if there’s little interest and we don’t rate then “ Seeya”.

Get rid of Manly / Cronulla

Two new sides in Brisbane , one plays out of Suncorp one plays out of Robina.

TV ratings climb

Everyone’s a winner !!

Except us and Sharkies fans who are lost to the game.
Can't argue with you Mark. I remember in 2007 I was in the Manly Corso and watched the grand final there. No vibe whatsoever. A majority of the general public in Manly don't give a stuff.
Bur then again, you look at Parramatta and it's a wasteland with a sewerage river running through it. Dreadful place, and as long as there is Parramatta, there must be Manly. Eat those cookies Todd.
Lean times indeed, let's hope we can get through it.
NYEagle
 
I haven’t seen Koula play, except for some highlight reels, but I wonder why he keeps playing in the centres in SG Ball if he is considered a fullback? Makes me question that thinking.
probably preparing him for back end of the season when Parker medically retires
 
If you go by our coaches' form in the past he'll sign a heap of players with back ended contracts and in 3 or 4 years we'll be in the same position. We need a roster where we only have 3 to 5 players coming off contract each year. We had the to best two props in the game, we've let one go and now we're letting the other go. These back ended contracts keep coming back to bite us in the arse.
 
In the end it is all about PEOPLE POWER

If the POWER OF SOUTHS PEOPLE CAN BRING BACK SOUTHS FROM THE DEAD

THE POWER OF THE MANLY PEOPLE CAN KEEP OUR CLUB ALIVE

This is why I keep reminding you all of this .....
PASSIONATE PEOPLE POWER ALWAYS PREVAILS !!!

2021 NRL Membership Tracker​

Club Name202120202020201920182017
13 Mar13 MarFinalFinalFinalFinal
Parramatta29,51026,80928,15625,25825,14524,501
South Sydney29,23328,54229,67029,62629,18930,220
Canberra18,82118,38819,03920,12120,05519,091
Newcastle18,77918,13918,86020,66518,01713,370
Wests Tigers17,46816,23517,91220,73920,79418,074
Sydney Roosters15,18215,15716,40716,38416,04416,001
St Geo Illa15,00015,03515,27221,02821,19719,181
Canterbury12,70815,17015,17018,34319,57018,833
Manly10,76912,52412,88712,44012,43013,163

Looking at these figures from 2018 to now, just two clubs have managed to increase their membership, Doesn'tmatta and Newcastle. That, of course, reflects their better on-field performances.
But all of the others have remained static or plunged alarmingly, with Illawarra and Canterbury dropping 6,000 to 7,000 members. It's not just Manly struggling for members it's rugby league in general not having as many passionate supporters willing to pay for a club membership.
 
Potential side for 2022 could be

T. Trbojevic
Saab
Walker
Suli
Funa/Tuipulotu
Shuster
DCE
Paseka
Faniu
J. Trbojecic
Su'A
Olakauatu
Brown

Lawton/Cust
Aloiai
Davey
Sipley/Saddler

id sack Suli bring in Koula, or try for niko hynes, the rest is a good side. I’d also promote Dylan Smith to 30 as back up fullback wing
 
Last edited:
Can't argue with you Mark. I remember in 2007 I was in the Manly Corso and watched the grand final there. No vibe whatsoever. A majority of the general public in Manly don't give a stuff.
Bur then again, you look at Parramatta and it's a wasteland with a sewerage river running through it. Dreadful place, and as long as there is Parramatta, there must be Manly. Eat those cookies Todd.
Lean times indeed, let's hope we can get through it.
NYEagle
Parramatta a wasteland? Seems the last time you travelled there it was the 90s
 
A rebuild is an absolute necessity and letting go Marty go and freeing up 800K of the cap makes sense. DCE to the Broncos would be a good outcome for our cap and the timing is right because the Broncos won't want to compete with the second Brisbane side for his services. Additionally they will not be resigning Milford so opportunity knocks. Of the remaining players coming off contract at the end of the season I expect few will be retained. The club needs to get it right and Su'a and Brown are the right type of tough and mobile forwards we need to acquire. Reynolds and Schuster would make an excellent haves pairing. Lets hope we can do this rebuild well as this is our window of opportunity before the 17th team is announced. We can't afford to get it wrong again.
Happy to swap Deardon for DCE
 
A rebuild is an absolute necessity and letting go Marty go and freeing up 800K of the cap makes sense. DCE to the Broncos would be a good outcome for our cap and the timing is right because the Broncos won't want to compete with the second Brisbane side for his services. Additionally they will not be resigning Milford so opportunity knocks. Of the remaining players coming off contract at the end of the season I expect few will be retained. The club needs to get it right and Su'a and Brown are the right type of tough and mobile forwards we need to acquire. Reynolds and Schuster would make an excellent haves pairing. Lets hope we can do this rebuild well as this is our window of opportunity before the 17th team is announced. We can't afford to get it wrong again.
If we could manage to let both taupau and Cherry go without paying freight.. we could truly be heavyweights again. We could get both sua and Brown on cherrys pay packet alone
 

Staff online

  • Jethro
    Star Trekkin' across the universe

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
8 7 1 56 16
7 6 1 99 14
8 6 2 66 14
8 5 3 51 12
9 5 3 37 11
9 5 4 95 10
9 5 4 42 10
8 4 4 25 10
9 5 4 -14 10
9 4 5 -16 8
8 3 5 -55 8
8 4 4 -60 8
8 3 4 17 7
8 3 5 -25 6
8 2 6 -63 6
8 1 7 -89 4
8 1 7 -166 4
Back
Top Bottom