Gutherson & Knight

[Disco]

These Parra and Roosters rumours seem absurb

Both are contracted next year from what I understand and we shouldn't entertain the thought of releasing either

 

[ManlyArmy]

Gutherson is contracted until the end of 17.

 

[tookey]

What about Gutherson for 5/8 next year?

 

[manlyfan76]

What about Gutherson for 5/8 next year?

He goes alright, no way he should go to doesntmatta.

 

[IQofalimabean]

Knight would be in nsw cup wasting his time in line behind numerous players in the roosters forward pack doesn't make sense going there. The gutherson rumor makes sense though given the log jam of backs at manly.

 

[bones]

Surely Manly wouldn't extend a players contract only to change their minds a couple of months later. That's not the Penn way.

 

[Moops]

Knight would be in nsw cup wasting his time in line behind numerous players in the roosters forward pack doesn't make sense going there. The gutherson rumor makes sense though given the log jam of backs at manly.

LOL! The log jam of 30+ year old backs. In my mind there would be only one decision to make.

 

[Loobs]

What are the rumours? Zorba himself said Knight is in the top 25 next year. Gutho resigned with the Turbos till 2017.

 

[Loobs]

I'd say the ONLY way his is true is if Bozo has got Bird. Otherwise why help Parra out by giving them Gutho..?

 

[bones]

I'd say the ONLY way his is true is if Bozo has got Bird. Otherwise why help Parra out by giving them Gutho..?

The rumour I hear is not Bird, but Will Hopoate. Hope not. Would much prefer Gutherson over Hopoate.

 

[sheridanstand78]

If the club allow either player to leave we have serious problems, we must make sure all of our promising juniors are retained, failure to do this is even worse than losing Foran!

 

[sheridanstand78]

The rumour I hear is not Bird, but Will Hopoate. Hope not. Would much prefer Gutherson over Hopoate.

I cant blame Hoppa for taking the worm coin back in 11. I am annoyed though after what the club did for his family. I would prefer Gutho to stay and I hope that weedkiller has it all wrong.

 

[Brothers manly]

Sunday Telegraph p53 ......Phil Rothfield "Rooster's Knight move"

 

[Red Pill]

Suppose it is a good sign if other clubs are sniffing around at our juniors ( as long as we keep them, come on! Bozo) seems we are not a team on the decline as many out there in media land would like.
PS. How accurate has Roth tool being!

 

[mike walker]

G'day all,Even though they have all been champion players for us I think at least one of Brett,Jamie and Steve are going to have to face their Nathan Merritt moment where even though you are a club legend the claims of the youngster snapping at your heels becomes undeniable.It would be a far better outcome to stagger their departures rather than having to replace the quality and experience all at once.
cheers mike

 

[Loobs]

The rumour I hear is not Bird, but Will Hopoate. Hope not. Would much prefer Gutherson over Hopoate.

Yeah I saw that too but I don't get it. Gutho would surely be cheaper and probably offers more. Getting Hoppa back doesn't help the log jam in the back line which is why I thought losing an outside back and getting a 6 helps a lot more. Killer and Matai play till 2017 in the centres and then there is a lot more clarity around roles.

 

[tookey]

The rumour I hear is not Bird, but Will Hopoate. Hope not. Would much prefer Gutherson over Hopoate.

If that happens then it will be fulton's cronyism again. He is still living in a different era

 

[mike walker]

G'day all,I can recall a couple of seasons ago Gutherson playing 5/8 in NSW cup,even though he was still eligible for NYC.
cheers mike

 

[eagleron]

I cant blame Hoppa for taking the worm coin back in 11. I am annoyed though after what the club did for his family. I would prefer Gutho to stay and I hope that weedkiller has it all wrong.

I don't want that grub back in maroon and white, he's getting what he asked for and the slugs are getting what they deserve.

 

[sheridanstand78]

Liam Knight has to be retained, he was the stand out in the final yesterday, gosh do we want another JWH episode, sick of the rorters pinching our kids, comeone on Penns dont let this happen!!