Galvin

Dunno why comparisons with Luai leaving Penrith are being made here?

Penrith tabled him an offer (as much as they could afford I believe) knowing it wasn't as much as he could get elsewhere, & he decided to go elsewhere with the club's blessing.

Can't see any similarity to the Galvin situation here.
 
Dunno why comparisons with Luai leaving Penrith are being made here?

Penrith tabled him an offer (as much as they could afford I believe) knowing it wasn't as much as he could get elsewhere, & he decided to go elsewhere with the club's blessing.

Can't see any similarity to the Galvin situation here.
Not to mention he informed them he was leaving that year. Not 18 months down the track.
 
I do think Api trying to claim any kind of moral high ground and have someone stood down when he's played for 4 clubs and after what he did to his wife during origin is pretty laughable. Probably hasn't earnt the right to the moral high ground here.
 
Last edited:
According to Kent in his podcast last night, he is absolutely going to the Eels. Done deal.
If that's correct and the reason he wants to leave is to be better (or differently) coached, why would he think Ryles is that coach? Sure, he's been assistant coach with well established systems but he is a fledgling coach with no track record. What would make him think his coaching is well suited to his development??
 
I do think Api trying to claim any kind of moral high ground and have someone stood dowb when he's played for 4 clubs and after what he did to his wife during origin is pretty laughable. Probably hasn't learnt the right to the moral high ground here.
Why can't he play for different clubs? All loved him. We let him for for Mr Stabby Stabby aka McStabby
 
According to Kent in his podcast last night, he is absolutely going to the Eels. Done deal.
Dce to rorters
Galvin to eels or dogs
Fogarty to manly

Once again we get the worst of the lot haha

Hopefully now we have some money we can sign a real hooker prop and or 2nd rower
 
Dce to rorters
Galvin to eels or dogs
Fogarty to manly

Once again we get the worst of the lot haha

Hopefully now we have some money we can sign a real hooker prop and or 2nd rower
It would be a shame if we don't or can't land some big name forwards. Then not having a play at galvin may be silly. As he probably ends up there in a few years. Even with large and walsh, they could be the best halves in the comp. But without a good pack in front of them, we go nowhere
 
I doubt the club would undermine Walsh with the Galvin signing.

As for comparisons with other players leaving clubs to sign elsewhere; it happens all the time without issue, which suggests there’s more to it in this context. Galvin is not being lambasted for testing the market, he is being lambasted for his attitude towards the Tigers.
  • He was heard to say he ‘wanted out’ in the sheds last year.
  • He was given an opportunity to play FG at 18.
  • He hasn’t really done enough to warrant 5-6mil contact.
  • He told the club not to bother with an offer.

So, what’s disappointed fans, is a young player that does not feel any sense of loyalty to a club that has (a) already given so much, and (b) is prepared to give more.

All they’re received in return is subtext about what an ordinary club it must be, that Benji is an ordinary coach, and some decent performances in a year where they won the spoon regardless.

That’s not comparable with Luai being forced out by a salary cap that cannot accomodate a four time premiership winning 5/8.

Personally, I have no emotion about what Galvin has done and/or what the Tigers (and senior players) have done in response. I just don’t see how comparisons are being drawn when it’s obvious the issue is more than just his desire to test the market. It’s very much DCE’s situation where no one can understand why the incumbent club are frozen out of negotiations and the domino effect that has on public perception of the club.
 
Alternatively, we're finally rid of the lot 🤣🤣
just need Spoon to exit as well....we will never attract quality players if the general consensus amongst players is that Spoonie cant coach. Players want to play for a coach they respect and can improve their game.
 
just need Spoon to exit as well....we will never attract quality players if the general consensus amongst players is that Spoonie cant coach. Players want to play for a coach they respect and can improve their game.
You know you say this a lot but until you say who you are and your connection to the NRL, you just seem like a disgruntled fan.

That's the thing about forums, apart from a few who state and confirm they're credentials with some evidence, they're pretty much full of The Hopefuls, The Disgruntled, and ... The Bozos
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 5 5 0 0 66 12
2 Storm 5 4 0 1 90 10
3 Broncos 6 4 0 2 56 8
4 Raiders 6 4 0 2 36 8
5 Rabbitohs 6 4 0 2 -4 8
6 Warriors 5 3 0 2 -20 8
7 Tigers 6 3 0 3 28 6
8 Sea Eagles 6 3 0 3 22 6
9 Sharks 6 3 0 3 21 6
10 Dragons 5 2 0 3 18 6
11 Titans 5 2 0 3 -26 6
12 Knights 5 2 0 3 -40 6
13 Cowboys 6 3 0 3 -42 6
14 Dolphins 6 2 0 4 8 4
15 Roosters 6 2 0 4 -52 4
16 Panthers 6 1 0 5 -38 2
17 Eels 6 1 0 5 -123 2
Back
Top Bottom