Who's your go to hero ...

[Woodsie]

Whilst we patiently await the inaugural team list Tuesday from our born again leader ... I thought an old fashioned footy debate will help pass the time ..

My son .. who got it from some podcast ... posed the following question to me ..

There is one minute to go on the clock ... you are down by 3 points, a try is needed. You get a turnover 40m out and 6 tackles to win the game. Who is the one player you want in your team ....

For further controversy ... 2 answers are req'd ...

1) Any player from any era from any club ...

2) Which player in our current squad must get his hands on the ball ...

My answers are .. 1) Alfie Langer 2) DCE

 

[Will on the hill.]

1 Andrew Johns 2 Turbo

 

[Brookie Bob]

1. Bob Fulton

2. Turbo - just ahead of Tolu Koula

 

[jimmymcgov]

1. Killer
2. Turbo

 

[Pete W]

Whilst we patiently await the inaugural team list Tuesday from our born again leader ... I thought an old fashioned footy debate will help pass the time ..

My son .. who got it from some podcast ... posed the following question to me ..

There is one minute to go on the clock ... you are down by 3 points, a try is needed. You get a turnover 40m out and 6 tackles to win the game. Who is the one player you want in your team ....

For further controversy ... 2 answers are req'd ...

1) Any player from any era from any club ...

2) Which player in our current squad must get his hands on the ball ...

My answers are .. 1) Alfie Langer 2) DCE

Great Sunday morning footy chat @Woodsie

My one-eyed bias says
1) Jamie 'Fkn Killer' Lyon
2) Big Gaucamole

 

[Rafferty]

1) Slater love him or hate him, he was of one of the best competitors and finishers I’ve watched, followed the ball everywhere, with every skill in the book, speed, smarts and an insane determination to win, he scores the try!
2) Turbo playing as a free roving centre three quarter as in Origin, (only because Bill is wearing the 1) with the smarts, the size, the will and the ability to set his shadow off for the try line and most likely back him up just in case.
Those 2 would give you a pretty good shot at steeling the victory.
Could easily replace Slater with Snake to keep it all Manly and still believe we steel the victory.

 

[Kalvin]

Brett Stewart

 

[swoop]

BEAVER! AND JAMIE KILLER LYON.

When we needed something special in a game these 2 generally delivered.

How good was it to see beaver score his last try for us in the 40-nil GF demolishing of the scum.

Current player Turbo.

 

[Under the Sticks]

1) Krillich
2) Wombat

 

[Ranga]

Joey or Cam Smith (easily the two best footballers I have seen).

Tolu wins it for us everyday!

 

[Shoe1]

Penguin Bradley
Josh aloia

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Thurston
DCE

 

[EaglesDontTweet]

1. Killer
2. These blokes...

 

[Budgie]

Killer
Gordie

 

[G-land Express]

Cliffy on to Beaver

 

[John Nicholson]

No doubt - Rob Fulton. He won many games in such circumstances

Not so enthused about current day players but with a big IF (he's fit) - Turbo

 

[jbb/james]

johns, bozo, jamie lyon or Tommy. fittler in his later years was pretty good.
ricky stuart had the give it to me now .

current players munster is that man

also, not terry lamb, he would kick a field goal

 

[jbb/james]

Joey or Cam Smith (easily the two best footballers I have seen).

Tolu wins it for us everyday!

forgot about smith. no doubt he would get the team in the best spot to clutch a win

 

[Jonduke]

Ellery Hanley
Johnny Gibbs

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I’m disgusted in myself for saying it but if there’s two minutes to go and you’re attacking the line.

Cam Smith

The greatest game manager that’s existed , to date.