The purge is on!!

[Ranga]

Older head with no experience

Nothing wrong with a late bloomer, but we will see.

 

[Simonmyers11]

Just because we have re-signed Faniu, doesn't mean Levi won't be either, unless they have another hooker in mind? Surely Crocker isn't the answer??

Disappointing news on Saab

 

[bSw]

Just because we have re-signed Faniu, doesn't mean Levi won't be either, unless they have another hooker in mind? Surely Crocker isn't the answer??

Disappointing news on Saab

And to let go metcalf (who could have possibly shared hooking role with cust)? maybe they'll be giving levi another year ffs
Was looking forward to saab too

 

[Jabuh]

So if Levi is out i reckon des will use cust and croker at hooker next year until fainu comes back. Then move croker on and keep cust as the 14/halves depth for 2022. If we sign foran then Schuster as 14/depth and croker in reserves where he belongs

 

[Ranga]

DESpicable never gave Metcalf a chance. Yet we've signed a Doesn'tmatta journeyman.
Got me beat!

Other than due to being part of the 30 man squad, did he deserve a chance? I guess where I differ to you is that I am pretty comfortable having not seen Metcalfe, Anderson, Miski (until last week) etc. They were never going to be the tonic from what I had seen of them and I don't believe in handing out first grade jerseys 'just because'.

Like 99.9% of us, the only one I reckon Des got wrong was Schuster. I am assuming there are 'other reasons' for Haumole's absence because nothing else explains it.

 

[Nordburg]

I see this as potentially more a shift in "minimum wage" strategy. Let's say you have 6 guys on the "minimum wage", it's a risk if all of them are kids with 'blue sky'. Sure, one or two might come off, but it doesn't help your overall depth. So I'm fine with having a few older heads fill squad positions 25-30.

Yep,perfect analysis.He’s not being signed to be a starting prop and they wouldn’t of had to break the bank for him.As many have said,Manly haven’t won anything with AFB and Taupau,so why not try a different tact and use the money elsewhere

 

[Ranga]

And to let go metcalf (who could have possibly shared hooking role with cust)? maybe they'll be giving levi another year ffs
Was looking forward to saab too

Metcalfe was never a hooking option imo - his tackling is suspect and we'd leak like a sieve.

 

[Disco]

Metcalf barely counts, I never really saw anything that screamed first grade

As for Davey....uninspiring

 

[bSw]

Metcalfe was never a hooking option imo - his tackling is suspect and we'd leak like a sieve.

Really thought des could have helped him there.. shame seems like a waste of speed

 

[bSw]

Yeah what's with releasing waddell and buying davey? I hope he's on 100k

 

[manlyfan76]

ZDC ready for grade?

 

[KNUCKLES]

Yep,perfect analysis.He’s not being signed to be a starting prop and they wouldn’t of had to break the bank for him.As many have said,Manly haven’t won anything with AFB and Taupau,so why not try a different tact and use the money elsewhere

We haven't had a full atrength team in how many years tho

 

[Nordburg]

We haven't had a full atrength team in how many years tho

Yes I was going to make the point that Elliott wasn’t signed to be a first grader either but I lost my train of thought and forgot

 

[Budgie]

So if Levi is out i reckon des will use cust and croker at hooker next year until fainu comes back.

As it is, earliest Fainu could be back is mid August.

 

[mutley]

I think you will find the nrl will relax the stand down policy for players awaiting trial, vlandys wasnt keen on it when he punted greenburg and im sure it will discussed come end of the season, there was too much interest in de belin and fainu from other clubs for that not to be the case

 

[Blake A]

DESpicable never gave Metcalf a chance. Yet we've signed a Doesn'tmatta journeyman.
Got me beat!

Des has seen Metcalfe at training for 2 years... that is more than giving someone a chance

 

[stoodamire]

Andrew Davey. Unreal signing.

Des ain’t pulling punches here. Straight off the top shelf.

 

[Nordburg]

Metcalf barely counts, I never really saw anything that screamed first grade

As for Davey....uninspiring

Not sure who you thought they’d sign at this stage of the proceedings.And if you’re sitting there in anticipation of a like for like deal to replace AFB,you’ll be sorely disappointed

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

I do wonder if we are thinking the Debelin case could blow up the no fault stand down policy apart?

 

[mickqld]

Not sure who you thought they’d sign at this stage of the proceedings.And if you’re sitting there in anticipation of a like for like deal to replace AFB,you’ll be sorely disappointed

Aiden Toleman would be a great replacement for AFB. Bryce Cartwright for Thommo. Problem solved at half the price.