The No-Look News (Schuster Chronicles)

Seagles68

Bencher
Premium Member
Tipping Member
Agree with your points that he looked better and more confident in that game, but Foran was out that week and Schu was actually playing 6 there. In fact before this year I'd always thought his best games had been in the halves.

Unfortunately even as one of the few fans of him left I do think he's probably outgrown the 5/8 spot but we've really done him no favours. The moment we signed Brooks and Tommy went down is when we should've moved him back to the forwards, but instead he's been out there playing a position we don't want him in, and being asked to create opportunities with Tuilagi, Parker & Tui/Vaega outside him. We saw how we looked when he at least had Koula & Tommy to link with, but there is no half in the game that would succeed when being rushed on every time they get the ball, and having no genuine attacking threat outside of them. That's what we saw on Thursday night with Schu

I'm glad we are apparently making the change this week if only just to see some sort of change within the team, but I wish a) we'd decided to do this earlier and not with 3 weeks left, and b) also addressed some other positions like our outside backs, weak forward pack, lack of threat at hooker. This is what I don't understand with Seibold being the tactical innovator he tries to be, surely he is watching the same games we are
Yep that's fair and once Brooks was signed his 5/8 days were over. I take your point about him playing 5/8 that day (I didn't realise Foz was out). But I think he will be playing as a ball playing loose forward, so he may find himself in a similar position in attack at times anyway.

Just for a more relevant comparison, I've also attached the Tigers game from that same period. Foz is playing this game and I just note the footwork and leg speed he had back then when he sets up Chez. We just need him back at that level and he'll do well for us in the forwards.

 

JenEagle

Bencher
Yep that's fair and once Brooks was signed his 5/8 days were over. I take your point about him playing 5/8 that day (I didn't realise Foz was out). But I think he will be playing as a ball playing loose forward, so he may find himself in a similar position in attack at times anyway.

Just for a more relevant comparison, I've also attached the Tigers game from that same period. Foz is playing this game and I just note the footwork and leg speed he had back then when he sets up Chez. We just need him back at that level and he'll do well for us in the forwards.

Yeah that was an amazing game on
Anzac say. Dce, schuster foz and Turbo were in sublime form. If only we could get back to playing like that again
 

Chunky

Member
The guy doesn't have a smart footballing brain. Evidence of this was last game when he kicked for Parker from the intercept. He'd already looked and saw it was Parker - if it were Saab the pass would have happened 20m downfield. Instead he kicks it. Do you think Munster does that? Of course not. No game awareness.

The guy is all flash with no substance. Every play has to try and be the no look pass, or the miracle ball, or the hero play.

I have no confidence at all that he is going to make even a half decent back rower. I don't see him running onto the ball into gaps like good back rowers do (look at Carrigan now he's been put that bit wider at the Broncos). Maybe he might set up the odd try for his centre or winger, but I don't see it being a regular occurrence.

Bryce Cartwright, Kane Elgey, Ash Taylor, Jayden Brailey, Jake Clifford. What do these 5 have in common? They were the last 5 Holden Cup players of the year. Can't really say any of them have gone on to be superstars now have they? A lot easier to dominate against boys than men.

For me, he is at best a bench player, maybe a potential impact player. But I'm not sure he even has that. Reece Walsh is everything Schuster wishes he could be, and 10x more.
 

mickqld

Sea Eagle forever
Tipping Member
The guy is 22 years old. Unless he's still hampered by injury then there's no reason why he has lost that pace and elusiveness. He needs to find that form next year or it'll need to be cya later. He's as slow as Woods at the moment. Just embarrassing for him really.
 

southsideeagle

Reserve Grader
Premium Member
The guy doesn't have a smart footballing brain. Evidence of this was last game when he kicked for Parker from the intercept. He'd already looked and saw it was Parker - if it were Saab the pass would have happened 20m downfield. Instead he kicks it. Do you think Munster does that? Of course not. No game awareness.

The guy is all flash with no substance. Every play has to try and be the no look pass, or the miracle ball, or the hero play.

I have no confidence at all that he is going to make even a half decent back rower. I don't see him running onto the ball into gaps like good back rowers do (look at Carrigan now he's been put that bit wider at the Broncos). Maybe he might set up the odd try for his centre or winger, but I don't see it being a regular occurrence.

Bryce Cartwright, Kane Elgey, Ash Taylor, Jayden Brailey, Jake Clifford. What do these 5 have in common? They were the last 5 Holden Cup players of the year. Can't really say any of them have gone on to be superstars now have they? A lot easier to dominate against boys than men.

For me, he is at best a bench player, maybe a potential impact player. But I'm not sure he even has that. Reece Walsh is everything Schuster wishes he could be, and 10x more.
It seemed such a dumb play. Schuster did not have the pace and had Parker beside him. From memory there were 3 penriths players to cover. He had 2 sensible options 1. take the tackle and have Parker as dummy half 2. pass to Parker and he would have made 5 - 10 metres more and go to dummy half. or his option ie kick it. Just dumb play!!
 

Stewbojevic

Reserve Grader
Yep that's fair and once Brooks was signed his 5/8 days were over. I take your point about him playing 5/8 that day (I didn't realise Foz was out). But I think he will be playing as a ball playing loose forward, so he may find himself in a similar position in attack at times anyway.

Just for a more relevant comparison, I've also attached the Tigers game from that same period. Foz is playing this game and I just note the footwork and leg speed he had back then when he sets up Chez. We just need him back at that level and he'll do well for us in the forwards.

Wow I miss watching this!!
 

Scorpio

Armchair Expert
I worry that he's not going to have a long NRL career if he doesn't apply himself a bit more.

Played at second row in his first stint tonight, 27 minutes, 8 tackles, 0 runs and 1 knock-on.

Edit: There wasn't a second stint so those were his final match stats.
 
Last edited:

manlyfan76

There is no A.I. Just better computers
Costume Party Clown GIF by Halloween Party
 

davohan123

First Grader
Premium Member
Tipping Member
He was shocking tonight
Just so poor
He cost us when we were up by 6 in the second half early then his crazy pass and from there we gave warriors all the momentum that for me was where we said we lost the match.
He is so lost as a player right now.
 

mickqld

Sea Eagle forever
Tipping Member
He was shocking tonight
Just so poor
He cost us when we were up by 6 in the second half early then his crazy pass and from there we gave warriors all the momentum that for me was where we said we lost the match.
He is so lost as a player right now.
There's no doubt the guy is an immense talent. He's lost all confidence at the moment. The injuries, the contract bullsht, the pressure he's been put under , mostly by his ar*eclown manager, looks to me like it's cracked him.
 

Jerry1

First Grader
There's no doubt the guy is an immense talent. He's lost all confidence at the moment. The injuries, the contract bullsht, the pressure he's been put under , mostly by his ar*eclown manager, looks to me like it's cracked him.
Hasler dropped him last season because he was fat & slow but was up early every morning personal training him to get him into shape. Schu just needs to work very hard on fitness. He's not first grade fit at the moment.
 

Members online

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
24 18 6 333 42
24 18 6 214 42
24 16 8 168 38
24 16 8 124 38
24 14 9 175 35
24 14 10 122 34
24 13 11 -24 32
24 13 11 -137 32
24 12 12 59 30
24 12 12 13 30
24 12 12 4 30
24 11 12 6 29
24 9 15 -111 24
24 9 15 -126 24
24 7 17 -331 20
24 5 19 -199 16
24 4 20 -290 14
Back
Top Bottom