The Kieran Forum

[tookey]

It worked out well for Foran last time he left Manly

Played crap and always injured at the eels, warriors and dogs

As if any respectable player would want to go the the knights or tigers these days

 

[pjayz]

Let's see what size Schu is when he comes back after the festive season. He's still a growing lad remember!

What does Foz’s Schu size have to do with anything?

 

[Sheikheagle]

I would free up a back row spot for the bull or davey

 

[Karshy]

I imagine when Foran finishes he will become part of Des Haslers coaching team. So I simply cant see him jeopardising his longer term future by going to play at the Tigers or Knights for a few extra bucks for a very short period of time.

 

[Shoe1]

Is he on a modest contract? I believe so. The other clubs might double his pay and give an extra year.

It would leave us with no halves depth though. Has cust got a cooling off period?

 

[alafua8]

I wouldn’t be starting Foran before Schuster in 2022 however I still see value in Him in our top 30. It would have to be a quality player swap. Could be click bait.

If Foran plays at 6 this year we will have the same result as 2021 .Schuster will bring us a whole different ball game and we'll definitely be a grand final contender in 2022 .

 

[Sheikheagle]

Is he on a modest contract? I believe so. The other clubs might double his pay and give an extra year.

It would leave us with no halves depth though. Has cust got a cooling off period?

Croker, Walker, DCE, shuster, Lawton and Humphries can all play in the halves.

 

[Shoe1]

Croker, Walker, DCE, shuster, Lawton and Humphries can all play in the halves.

fair enough. Righto trade him.

 

[OneEyedEagle]

What does Foz’s Schu size have to do with anything?

Well if the Schu fits (wear it) - deja vous Has to be fake news

 

[Budgie]

Find it hard to believe , but money is money of course

And he does seem to have 70 gazillion kids.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

And he does seem to have 70 gazillion kids.

Well she has anyway

 

[Cioran]

Click bait based on nothing more than speculation about what the Knights MIGHT do. I think the Shoe has found his natural role and I expect him to become the best ball-playing back rower in the comp. Sometimes he looks like a cross between Cliffy and Gifty. He's going to terrify centres and set up a lot of tries over the next decade. And He's ours

 

[Shoe1]

Richie gets his info from Zorba, and Zorba is close with Foran.

 

[Mitch]

Richie gets his info from Zorba, and Zorba is close with Foran.

Not anymore he isn't. Was very vocal about not bringing Foran back to the club in 2021, their relationship broke down some time ago I believe mate.

 

[Shoe1]

Not anymore he isn't. Was very vocal about not bringing Foran back to the club in 2021, their relationship broke down some time ago I believe mate.

Ah, ok no worries, makes sense.

 

[globaleagle]

In an August interview with News Corp, Foran said of Hasler: “If you think about the amount of times I have been written off, the amount of times people have thought I was gone, I didn’t have anything to give or I couldn’t offer anything, Des Hasler has always believed I can bring something.”

 

[jbb/james]

do you think we could be considering a move for josh hodgson. he is a dominant dummy half and would give a story like this some sense

hodgson loves to control the game which would be great for cherry and jake in particular

he would be about the best we could get if looking to improve on last year

the hodgson deal just seems clouded everywhere

 

[MightyEagles]

do you think we could be considering a move for josh hodgson. he is a dominant dummy half and would give a story like this some sense

hodgson loves to control the game which would be great for cherry and jake in particular

he would be about the best we could get if looking to improve on last year

the hodgson deal just seems clouded everywhere

I like your thinking. I was wondering if we would go after Api. There was talk a little while ago that he may come back. How's this scenario, Api doesn't get the jab so Penrith say we don't want you. He then leaves, gets the jab and signs elsewhere.

 

[Shoe1]

It does seem like there is something in the works behind the scenes - a few spare spots, a few moved on, now this rumour.

 

[The Who]

If there is any truth to the rumour all I can think of is a possible swap of players, Foran for Tex Hoy who is a fullback where we don't have a ready-made reserve. Foran would have to be paid an increased salary by Newcastle and given a further year on his contract.
It sound illogical, but strange things happen in RL.
While I'm a fan of Foran I do think that if he remains our No. 1 five-eight next season we won't improve our position in the premiership. To go to the top I believe we need The Shoe as 5/8 and getting his hands on the ball as much as possible.