The Daly Cherrygraph

[Disco]

We need to fill a NSW cup team as well, remember we do have a second tier cap and guys like Williame, Berryman and Rudolph would be on that this year

 

[bob dylan]

Robert Lui is coming to Sydney next year.

It better not be ........ no i wont even think about it.

 

[HappilyManly]

Sharks were interested in him, so lets not lynch Kels just yet

 

[Loobs]

No team in their right mind would combine Lui and Barba unless they want no female and female respecting male fans (so basically no fans period)...

 

[NYEagle]

If right, we'd have a completely loaded team, and would need to offload some players. 36 players are listed below. Who gets the chop (top 25 are in a squad, so cut 11)?

01. Brett Stewart, Tom Trbojevic
02. Jorge Taufua, David Williams, Cheyse Blair
03. Steve Matai, Brayden Wiliame
04. Peta Hiku, Delroy Berryman
05. Clinton Gutherson
06. Jamie Lyon, Manaia Rudolph
07. Daly Cherry-Evans, Riley Travers, Jack Littlejohn
08. Darcy Lussick, Willie Mason
09. Matt Ballin,
10. Nate Myles, Josh Starling
11. Feleti Mateo, Jesse Sene-Lefeo
12. Tom Symonds, Blake Leary
13. Jamie Buhrer, Justin Horo

14. Jayden Hodges
15. Brenton Lawrence, James Hasson
16. Jake Trbojevic, Ligi Sao, Uiti Baker, Michael Chee-Kam
17. Dunamis Lui, Tyson Andrews, Siosaia Vave

then a couple of NYC call ups? If we are after DCE, Myles and Lussick, maybe we have to rationalise guys, and lose maybe a Brenton Lawrence for a Ligi Sao. Lose a Justin Horo for a Dunamis Lui to get a certain top 17 start? Maybe no - we would need to shed 11 or more.

To start with, the players I'd look at moving on:-

01. David Williams (love him, but want him to get 1st grade time on the park)
02. Cheyse Blair (Tom Trbojevic & Brayden Wiliame make him somewhat surplus)
03. Delroy Berryman (Had his shot, and we have depth/utility already in the centers)
04. Jack Littlejohn (If DCE stays, Travers should be his under study)
05. Manaia Rudolph (HATE giving up a 5/8, but Buhrer, Lyon, Bullet can all play 5/8 worst case)
06. Siosaia Vave (By all reports, has looked ordinary in Premier League)
07. Michael Chee-Kam (Has not lived up to expectation unfortunately)
08. Uiti Baker (Same goes for Uiti - just needed to find that next level - and our depth kills him)
09. Willie Mason (I watched an old Dogs game yesterday - and he's a shadow of that player - retires)
10. James Hasson (Out with Hasson, in with Lussick - I love Lussick tbh as a player)
11. Jesse Sene-Lefeo (Killed me this one, but he has really dropped off in form and impact)

Therefore, my top 25 are: Brett Stewart, Tom Trbojevic, Jorge Taufua, Steve Matai, Brayden Wiliame, Peta Hiku, Clinton Gutherson, Jamie Lyon, Daly Cherry-Evans, Riley Travers, Darcy Lussick, Matt Ballin, Nate Myles, Josh Starling, Feleti Mateo, Tom Symonds, Blake Leary, Jamie Buhrer, Juston Horo, Jayden Hodges, Brenton Lawrence, Jake Trbojevic, Ligi Sao, Tyson Andrews & Dunamis Lui.

That has quality written all over it, and I also think one of the best rosters on paper. I also think this team would do really well for Toovey. I feel bad for the other players, but this IS a business after all these days.

Thought's?

I agree with all except JSL in Williame out. I would prefer Manly win an NRL game next year.
NYEagle

 

[manlyseaeaglesyeew]

I agree with all except JSL in Williame out. I would prefer Manly win an NRL game next year.
NYEagle

Same here, and also Jake T needs to be a starting prop, too good for the bench

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

Apparently there's some new twitter that a backflipp is in place.Where are the ironstones on here who can confirm this.I can't handle the suspense anymore.

 

[The Wheel]

Apparently there's some new twitter that a backflipp is in place.Where are the ironstones on here who can confirm this.I can't handle the suspense anymore.[/QUOTE


Berkeley Eagle where are you!

 

[brad]

Apparently there's some new twitter that a backflipp is in place.Where are the ironstones on here who can confirm this.I can't handle the suspense anymore.

DCE to manly mate .

 

[pjayz]

Apparently there's some new twitter that a backflipp is in place.Where are the ironstones on here who can confirm this.I can't handle the suspense anymore.

What!? Where, how , when, something, don't leave me hanging?? Links, sauce, Desert Boot Kid confirm it please...something - come on damn it, I can't take this........

I need a bex and a lie down.

 

[Loobs]

Not buying any stock in this until there is an official announcement.

 

[pjayz]

Well come on Pontian, I have been patiently waiting a whole 10 minutes and still no update damn it.....get to it!

 

[HappilyManly]

Its not a backflip - its an extension - if Santa got my letter

 

[pjayz]

Its not a backflip - its an extension - if Santa got my letter

I asked Santa for an extension...he wrote a letter back saying 12inches was plenty....BOOM.

 

[HappilyManly]

I asked Santa for an extension...he wrote a letter back saying 12inches was plenty....BOOM.

Lucky for you he didn't go for the backflip then

 

[bob dylan]

What's your preferred option.

A. Carney and Sandow.

B. Carney and Lui.

C. Lui and Sandow.

cos that's what we're getting. @bones

 

[pjayz]

What's your preferred option.

A. Carney and Sandow.

B. Carney and Lui.

C. Lui and Sandow.

D. Hemorrhoids

 

[lurker]

What's your preferred option.

A. Carney and Sandow.

B. Carney and Lui.

C. Lui and Sandow.

cos that's what we're getting. @bones

Option d) throw myself off a bridge

 

[JenEagle]

It's an absolute travesty that the above could be our halves pairings next year. I thought penn scenario planned for both to leave cause the options above are scenario planning to get the spoon.

 

[eaglebuzz]

Apparently there's some new twitter that a backflipp is in place.Where are the ironstones on here who can confirm this.I can't handle the suspense anymore.

If true it's better for us if it stays quiet until set in stone, so I take the lack of definitives as a positive sign.