THE CROKER POLL .. THE RESULT UPDATED!

[frank stokes]

He did go well last week too. His defence was a big reason we got the 2 points last week too. Agreed, let's not jump the gun but the last couple weeks we have seen a vast improvement and he is actually starting to take on the line. Hopefully he continues to improve!

That is the difference imo.
TBR... he is moving forward out of dummy half instead of sideways... the occasional run (picking his moment) has been great and his delivery is better... kid could always defend well...

I will say that the fact he is getting better momentum from his forwards has made it possible to do some of this...

 

[Woodsie]

Given this kids history .. I have always said I wouldn't bet against him ... got plenty of ticker for a broken down half everybody wants to play like an international hooker after a handful of games in the role ... Go Froggy, never give up on your dream ..

 

[Kevinward777]

Given this kids history .. I have always said I wouldn't bet against him ... got plenty of ticker for a broken down half everybody wants to play like an international hooker after a handful of games in the role ... Go Froggy, never give up on your dream ..

Good point, I feel the same about Des. We have a lot of history to fall back on here at Manly.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I’m certainly NOT changing my vote , he’s played pretty well in one game only.

In my view that’s performing poorly!!

If this Lawton is any good Id get him in there quick smart!

Froggy is a reserve grader , always was, always will be !!

 

[nightster]

I like his comment " anyone who says Dessie is mad have no idea .... coz he is crazy mad"
ease up a bit Mark there is a lot of playing before Lawton (or Fainu), are ready and the bloke, who is playing out of position is improving with most of the rest of the team .... 😉

 

[Kevinward777]

I’m certainly NOT changing my vote , he’s played pretty well in one game only.

In my view that’s performing poorly!!

If this Lawton is any good Id get him in there quick smart!

Froggy is a reserve grader , always was, always will be !!

That means he's going to have a breakout year then.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

I like his comment " anyone who says Dessie is mad have no idea .... coz he is crazy mad"
ease up a bit Mark there is a lot of playing before Lawton (or Fainu), are ready and the bloke, who is playing out of position is improving with most of the rest of the team .... 😉

Agree. He is still only 41 (40 at Manly) games into his NRL career. I think he could turn into a very handy player.

 

[Snake]

Just imagine for a second that we are playing in the finals this weekend against Parramatta and Croker is listed at 9...hardly gives one confidence.
All we need from Croker is to get us over a hump until the Fainu situation is sorted. His role is to stop us from getting the spoon, not win us a comp. We are not going to be a premiership contender while ever he is our first choice 9, but he can help us get some wins to keep us away from that dreaded spoon.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Agree. He is still only 41 (40 at Manly) games into his NRL career. I think he could turn into a very handy player.

Very handy, very valuable. A player who is unfashionable (putting it mildly) yet has guts determination and puts body on line at close to minimum dollars on salary cap. He's been shown patience and loyalty by Manly during his injuries and he's the kind of bloke who won't forget that.
Perfect squad member actually, and not a big head who will sulk if sent back to reserves when everyone is fit (lol, as if everyone will ever be fit)

 

[XV-1]

Interesting, since we have been going ok, there even have talk about Croker must be re-signed?

Croker is doing a good job, but nothing special. We have Fainu, Lawton and Cust all signed.

Once we are over our injuries in the 2nd row, surely Lawton is a better option if we want to go far at the back end of the season.

 

[Woodsie]

Food for thought ... if Croker has improved from horrible .. to good ... in just a dozen games at hooker ... how good will he be after another dozen games ??

 

[40 years an eagle]

Many put Cust's name up when we are discussing hookers. He is NOT a 9 defence-wise and is injury-prone and not tough at all.. Sure, the Frog isn't really one either but he is obviously a learner, tough as teak, a very solid defender, gives it all and has earned the right to see if he can progress further.
We NEED 3 hookers in the squad ...they are the Frog, Fainu and Lawton. If Fainu doesn't get cleared we need to find one more, and Cust isn't it. The Rorters have used 5 hookers this year.
We extended Cust when we were in a bind and is contracted for next year so he hangs around if he can't find a start elsewhere, that's fine, but that's all as I don't believe he is a FGer, let alone one in a premiership-winning squad. Unfortunately for him Lawton has proved all that.

 

[ManlyTragic]

Just seeing my vote! Yep I was right again!
Just sayin’

 

[Kevinward777]

Couldn’t agree more , happy to eat my words if the improvements continue.

Plate, cutlery, words - eat away MFB.

 

[Kevinward777]

Another thread which has aged like a monkeys asshole.

 

[Highflier]

Just seeing my vote! Yep I was right again!
Just sayin’

So was I
Just sayin’

 

[ManlyTragic]

Another thread which has aged like a monkeys asshole.

And how’s that? ….. please explain!

 

[BOZO]

Perspective time

Great Hookers with all the skills take the game to another level

 

[Ryan]

Another thread which has aged like a monkeys asshole.

For once a thread where my comments don't make me look like a complete pork chop !! hahaha

Knew he had it in him. And he'll keep getting better. I bet there are teams talking to him

 

[Kevinward777]

And how’s that? ….. please explain!

You can't figure it out?
Just sayin'.