The Anthony Seibold Grievances MEGA THREAD

[Thewestisbest]

Don’t be a smartarse mate.

That’s Eddie’s job.😉

How funny was that.

 

[conanu]

Can we make it 2023 please

This has all the hallmarks of Trent Barrett no 2

We let in easy tries and cannot score ourselves when Tommy is not around

Slow and lazy players like Tualagi, Shuster and Sipley need to be released from the club ASAP

You reckon those are the worst 3 players?? I could rattle off about 6 others that are far worse. Those 3 at least have improvement in them.

 

[Ryan]

You reckon those are the worst 3 players?? I could rattle off about 6 others that are far worse. Those 3 at least have improvement in them.

I often wonder how many of these players would make the 2008 team, and the answer is not many. Going forward, here is a core (in my view) you could stick with, but the rest need to be replaced in my view:

01. Tom Trbojevic (Weekes depth)
02. Jason Saab
03. Reuben Garrick
04. Tolu Koula
05. Jaxson Paulo
06. Luke Brooks
07. Daly Cherry-Evans (Fainu depth)
08. Jake Trbojevic
09.
10. Matt Lodge
11. Haumole Olakau'atu
12. Samuela Fainu
13. Josh Schuster

14.
15. Sean Keppie
16. Taniela Paseka
17.

We need to find our next Matt Ballin, Jamie Buhrer (possibly Matterson) & another marquee forward like Tino.

 

[tookey]

You reckon those are the worst 3 players?? I could rattle off about 6 others that are far worse. Those 3 at least have improvement in them.

The sad part is that we can add another couple more to the list in 2024

Jaxson Paulo has death threats made against him by souths supporters they hated him that much and Talau is rubbish

Lodge was told to/paid leave the storm, warriors and roosters so how good is he going to be next year? Another rubbish signing

 

[Eagle 1]

The sad part is that we can add another couple more to the list in 2024

Jaxson Paulo has death threats made against him by souths supporters they hated him that much and Talau is rubbish

Lodge was told to/paid leave the storm, warriors and roosters so how good is he going to be next year? Another rubbish signing

Bit premature, we haven't seen Lodge in Manly 1st's yet, maybe reserve your judgement till then.

 

[XV-1]

I often wonder how many of these players would make the 2008 team, and the answer is not many. Going forward, here is a core (in my view) you could stick with, but the rest need to be replaced in my view:

01. Tom Trbojevic (Weekes depth)
02. Jason Saab
03. Reuben Garrick
04. Tolu Koula
05. Jaxson Paulo
06. Luke Brooks
07. Daly Cherry-Evans (Fainu depth)
08. Jake Trbojevic
09.
10. Matt Lodge
11. Haumole Olakau'atu
12. Samuela Fainu
13. Josh Schuster

14.
15. Sean Keppie
16. Taniela Paseka
17.

We need to find our next Matt Ballin, Jamie Buhrer (possibly Matterson) & another marquee forward like Tino.

Is Keppie no longer being sold off?

 

[LeonardCohen]

if Lodge performs and the club decides to sign him up for next year, we’ll lose Keppie or Aloiai for certain. If Lodge crashes and fails to earn a deal beyond train and trial, it might be different

 

[Ryan]

Is Keppie no longer being sold off?

If the club has any brains whatsoever, no.

 

[BOZO]

If the club has any brains whatsoever, no.

Keppy maybe a satisfactory player but he is not the reason our team can not improve without him

 

[Ryan]

Keppy maybe a satisfactory player but he is not the reason our team can not improve without him

Bozo, he's better than 99% of the other plonkers we presently have pretending to be actual forwards.

 

[BOZO]

Bozo, he's better than 99% of the other plonkers we presently have pretending to be actual forwards.

Any pack spearheaded by Paseka , Jake , Olakautu and your man Keppie should go better than we have been going
In the beginning of the season Mestrov and Seibold were happy with the prospect of our pack

 

[Ryan]

Any pack spearheaded by Paseka , Jake , Olakautu and your man Keppie should go better than we have been going
In the beginning of the season Mestrov and Seibold were happy with the prospect of our pack

Well, Jake's been out and Keppies not getting picked. Paseka is going well, and Olakau'atu has regressed a bit this season..

 

[BOZO]

Well, Jake's been out and Keppies not getting picked. Paseka is going well, and Olakau'atu has regressed a bit this season..

This is Seibolds issue and he either finds a way to win or another excuse of how good we played for the first 15 minutes and then we lost .

The moral of the story ....
Any Mediocre person can find excuses for losing
It is the Great ones that find ways to win

 

[XV-1]

Bottom 6 side with a bullet and Seibs is saying he is proud.
Being proud of mediocrity breeds worse.

Who else is proud of being a bottom 6 side? Not me.

 

[The Who]

There won't be any Manly supporter proud of the performance of the team this year. They have underperformed. We are a team that relies too heavily on two players, DCE and Turbo, and we know why we have struggled.
But just how many of the 17 clubs' fans would be proud? I'd say not that many: Penrith, Worriers, Newcastle, 'Fins, possibly Melbourne . . . but I'd reckon the remainder would believe their clubs have underperformed.

 

[Hibyemama]

to be brutally honest, i am proud too. With the roster we have, we are doing ok at position 12.

 

[Ryan]

We'll end up 14th-15th in my opinion, and honestly, that exceeded expectations, because I'm pretty sure I said 15th-16th.

 

[silver]

We’ll get the same garbage next year. I thought Barrett was an oxygen thief of a coach but Seidud is right on par with him. We’ll be battling for the spoon next year. The fact he picks Woods and Ben Turbo is astonishing. Both are plodders and would struggle for Blacktown.

 

[Brocky]

If you are happy with this, you are part of the problem, we have DEFINITELY LOST OUR IDENTIT, no longer are we that force we used to be. Seibold is not the coach we need, we need a new owner maybe delete toovey ticket.
i see nothing Manly in this organization
how the mighty fall
four players on a nearly a million and more and we don’t play finals. Are clubs do just fine when they get injuries.
schuster and Jake and turbo well over paid. And DCE at least he is giving it all without him how bad could we be.????
joke is on us.

 

[Waz13]

We'll end up 14th-15th in my opinion, and honestly, that exceeded expectations, because I'm pretty sure I said 15th-16th.

Teams performances are really hard to pick. We’re as good s chance of winning all the remaining games as we are losing them.