NRL predicted 2018 Manly line up

[MadMarcus]

Does everyone else see Lussick as having a starting prop spot alongside Marty wrapped up?

I see him more as a bench prop, but the problem is I see AFB and Perrett as bench props too. One of them has to start. I'm just not sure which one...

 

[manly al]

Frank does not seem to lack some attacking power running ability . Remember clearly those two busts he made against the Raiders and Roosters respectively to set up Tom for two important tries . Like most of the back rowers vying for a starting spot , a big mobile unit who if used effectively could play a valuable role .

 

[manly al]

Does everyone else see Lussick as having a starting prop spot alongside Marty wrapped up?

I see him more as a bench prop, but the problem is I see AFB and Perrett as bench props too. One of them has to start. I'm just not sure which one...

If he can get back to and produce his late 2016 form , he can be easily a starting prop. Agree that A F B and Perrett probably still seem more suited to bench spots but have a feeling that A F B in particular is capable of stepping up to a starting role at some stage soon if required .

 

[ricardo]

1. Turbo
2. Taufua
3. Walker
4. Kelly
5. Uate
6. Hastings
7. DCE
8. AFB
9. Koroisau
10. Taupau
11. Thompson
12. Sironen
13. Jake
14. Frankenstein
15. Lane (remember him?)
16. Perrett
17. Lussick
18. Lane Paseka Wright Croker Sipley

 

[madmax]

Bench looks weak as piss apart from AFB.
Can anyone answer is Thompson still quick and Agile enough to play centre? If so we don't need Brown on the bench and could go with an impact player instead

Bench looks pretty good actually, although Sipley for Brown would be ideal!!

 

[manly al]

Certainly appealing to have a big strong bench , For cover , Siro has played some 5 /8 previously, Thomo can play centre if needed . Just the issue of giving A P I a rest if he needs one .

 

[Clay]

Frank does not seem to lack some attacking power running ability . Remember clearly those two busts he made against the Raiders and Roosters respectively to set up Tom for two important tries . Like most of the back rowers vying for a starting spot , a big mobile unit who if used effectively could play a valuable role .

He had a couple of really powerful damaging runs. The problem being it was a small handfull over 26 rounds. He has shown he can't do it consistently which must be frustrating for the coaching staff

 

[Woodsie]

He had a couple of really powerful damaging runs. The problem being it was a small handfull over 26 rounds. He has shown he can't do it consistently which must be frustrating for the coaching staff

No, the coaching staff re-signed him for another 2 years, even at his advanced age, which indicates they are very happy with him, and the role he was asked to play.

Both 2nd rowers last year (I believe) were restricted by a very specific game plan.

We don't know what Frank is capable of, given a different role .... Siro was used more often by DCE on the right ... but still less than most 2nd rowers, and he also, will benefit from a different game strategy.

Thommo is obviously going to be a starting 2nd rower ... but don't discount Frankie, given more freedom he may just surprise.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Thank **** it’s Lewie Browns last year, if they resign him beyond that I’m cancelling my membership.

 

[Woodsie]

Thank **** it’s Lewie Browns last year, if they resign him beyond that I’m cancelling my membership.

Not as down on Louie as some ... but agree ... for the coin he is on we can certainly upgrade next season. If some of these newbies and young'uns perform to expectation, we may see little of him this year.

 

[Budgie]

While all the chat is about the forwards and 5/8, anyone have any thoughts as to what happens if Walker isn't right by season start?

 

[The Wheel]

While all the chat is about the forwards and 5/8, anyone have any thoughts as to what happens if Walker isn't right by season start?

My guess would be Wright with an M given Jorge is back or Parker would be the first choices

 

[winnyason]

Yeah darcy needs to have a dig. I beleive perrett and afb better days are ahead. Sipley also got plenty of raps.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

While all the chat is about the forwards and 5/8, anyone have any thoughts as to what happens if Walker isn't right by season start?

Tom Wright I’m thinking!

 

[winnyason]

Okay I have a crack also
Tommy, Jorge, Kelly, walker, uate, Hastings, dce, tapau ,api, lussick, thompson, sironen, Jake t.
Bench - perrett, sipley, afb, Shaun Lane. Others to be in mix Croker, tom wright, Parker, jack g, Lewis Brown, Frank w.
The 5 prop rotation did help us get go forward, it’s a waste of bench spot having poo there for injury cover Thompson can cover, back row and centre.

 

[The Wheel]

I would like to see Hastings get a run - the kid has heaps of potential and he is a 85% goal kicker. The rest basically picks themselves for Round 1 unless Walker is still on the sidelines.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I would like to see Hastings get a run - the kid has heaps of potential and he is a 85% goal kicker. The rest basically picks themselves for Round 1 unless Walker is still on the sidelines.

I’m with you there , if he can just do a basic job on the left side AND kick the goals I think we’d win more than we will lose.

Does Croker kick as well ( as in goal kicks), anyone know???

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Okay I have a crack also
Tommy, Jorge, Kelly, walker, uate, Hastings, dce, tapau ,api, lussick, thompson, sironen, Jake t.
Bench - perrett, sipley, afb, Shaun Lane. Others to be in mix Croker, tom wright, Parker, jack g, Lewis Brown, Frank w.
The 5 prop rotation did help us get go forward, it’s a waste of bench spot having poo there for injury cover Thompson can cover, back row and centre.

Won’t be far off in my opinion!

 

[The Wheel]

I’m with you there , if he can just do a basic job on the left side AND kick the goals I think we’d win more than we will lose.

Does Croker kick as well ( as in goal kicks), anyone know???

Not sure but apparently Brian Kelly can kick so he maybe an option as well

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Not sure but apparently Brian Kelly can kick so he maybe an option as well

Yeah I’ve seen a YouTube clip on that , he was t bad either!