Dylan Walker

[Snake]

I really think some of you guys should go and watch highlights of Dylan Walker on youtube...he is a seriously talented footballer. He is a much better commodity than Gutherson. Word is he is a really handy goal kicker too. Walker's acceleration is Slater-like, he can run holes, tackles like demon, can read the play, and sniff out a try. I remember last year when he played that blinder with a broken wrist, he was one of the most talked about players in the game.

 

[lillchip]

If he's that good why would Souths even think about letting him go. Sorry it doesn't add up to me. Yes, yes, yes they have to pay for Sam B but you don't do that by losing your so called best. Souths know he's a time bomb. We'd be better off buying props.

 

[Ryan]

Sorry - if Walker is going to cost us Jamie Buhrer, who I had marked as Manly's next captain, then no thank you sir.

 

[Ryan]

Sorry - if Walker is going to cost us Jamie Buhrer, who I had marked as Manly's next captain, then no thank you sir.

Why you disagree @sean john ?

 

[Stevo]

No way Buhrer was ever going to be Manlys next captain

 

[double hoops]

We're a bit light on for hooker without Buhrer. Api just had shoulder op. The tried and tested be all gone.

 

[KNUCKLES]

Why you disagree @sean john ?

I don't think Buhrer was ever going to be in contention for captaincy

 

[eagleron]

I think for the future of the clubs up and coming stars and respect to the champions of the club.
Jorge should stand down !

He is the weakest link IMO

I disagree I think Jorge showed a lot of improvement this season, at his best he's one our strengths I think he's worked on his weaknesses and he's worth keeping, one of our strongest finishers IMO.

 

[Wombat Legacy]

Why you disagree @sean john ?

IF this is true.
Buhrer is a light weight, honest toiling bench playing forward, who has peaked and on the way down. Dylan Walker is a youthful superstar on the up. It's a no contest in terms of looking to the future.
Jamie would never have been captain...ever! In my opinion
But I will be very, very sad to see him go. He is a great Manly boy and that should never be understated.

 

[Brookvale2015]

We're a bit light on for hooker without Buhrer. Api just had shoulder op. The tried and tested be all gone.

So did DCE but he will be playing round 1. Koroisau will be ready he is first choice in my eyes for hooker same with baz

 

[double hoops]

True but I would still prefer to be a halfback then a hooker if I was playing after recovering from a recent shoulder reconstruction.

 

[double hoops]

What's this late news on Walker going to Union? May be he isn't a done deal at manly after all?

 

[double hoops]

 

[Mango]

I disagree I think Jorge showed a lot of improvement this season, at his best he's one our strengths I think he's worked on his weaknesses and he's worth keeping, one of our strongest finishers IMO.

Look, all due respect to Jorge, he had a strong year last year, far better than his injured self of 2014 but not as good as 2013! 'm just saying Tom Turbo is the next level! and we need to show him the love!

And I can see hiku moving into the centers next year, so we can't drop him.

 

[Wombat64]

Ok so if it's gonna happen does that mean they have to move Matai and if so, are we willing to take Walker, lose Matai and have Hiku in the centres? Would the fan base be OK with that series of events..?

Do you think after all that's happened that they give a **** about us? They want results fast and if they get them I'm not going to argue

 

[robbiea]

There was definitely talk of Buhrer being groomed for captain two seasons ago.There was on here atleast ,but many of you weren't here then.

 

[Ralphie]

There was definitely talk of Buhrer being groomed for captain two seasons ago.There was on here atleast ,but many of you weren't here then.

The talk since 2011 has been whether DCE or Foran would be the Captain after Killer. Making Buhrer captain would have been as sensible as NSW having Gidley as Captain. A bench player is never going to be captain.

 

[Wombat Legacy]

There was definitely talk of Buhrer being groomed for captain two seasons ago.There was on here atleast ,but many of you weren't here then.

Really, fans anoint team captains? Interesting lol.

 

[robbiea]

Really ,fans having opinions? Interesting smd.
Not that I would've wanted him captain ,but definitely people were suggesting he had what it takes to be a good leader.

 

[Mango]

Hi guys
I'm relatively new to this site..
Is the the ironstine symble, a positive or taking the piss?