Do we need Walker

Dylan is in my opinion the best centre in the nrl. We shouldn't ship him around. There's no surprise uate has looked out of sorts without him this year. Next year it could be Anderson or funa or Parker (we really lack high ball on the line attack). It's injuries this year that have cruelled us and the green fiasco just ride this year out things will come good.
 
Uate, is off to Huddersfield for 3 years. If Suli trimmed right down, picked up some speed, he'd be great outside Walker.

01. Tom Trbojevic
02. Jorge Taufua
03. Brian Kelly
04. Dylan Walker
05. Moses Suli
06. Trent Hodkinson
07. Daly Cherry-Evans

Is outstanding if they can all remain on the field. I'd also have TOM Wright as our 14 to cover most of those positions.
 
Rather Sironen be let go. We have good depth in the second row. Walker needs to be made co captain with Jake. Plays with his heart on his sleeve rather than his wallet.
 
I’ts only $350k not a massive hit... and we will get Uate, Hastings, Brown, Lussick’s space as well. The only time we’ve looked like a decent side this season, was when Walker was playing direct... in fact the three weeks he was in the six, we looked real good and ready to go on a run. Rather than cut Walker, I’d be promoting some of the development squad in place of the players I’ve listed above. Kelly is only contracted for next season anyway... then what happens? We have to match the crazy money offered by the Tigers (around $450k-$500k) if we want to keep him in 2020. By then he might be asking for even more. Walker is a game changing international and he’s on $600k, locked in for the next four years... which is a much safer, value for money signing than getting one season out of Brian Kelly on the cheap. Who says he’s even going to sign another contract with us after next season? And you can bank the house on his manager asking for a pay rise if we were stupid enough to get rid of Dylan Walker. Or do you think he’ll be happy to play on a small contract when there are other clubs prepared to triple his salary? Look at Blake Green for an example. Shedding Walker would be completely absurd.
Common sense . I wish common sense was more common
 
Walker - Proven, rep quality standard NRL centre

Kelly - improving by the week and showing plenty of ability to be a long term NRL centre to an above average level

Suli - Plenty of potential, but is onto his 3rd club this year and amongst the promise still shows plenty of flaws

Parker - Walking injury whose ability gets over rated on here but is a good 4th stringer

Nothing amongst that tells me that we should be looking to move Walker on
 
Last edited:
Walker - Proven, rep quality standard NRL centre

Kelly - improving by the week and showing plenty of ability to be a long term NRL centre to an above average level

Suli - Plenty of potential, but is onto his 3rd club this year and amongst the promise still shows plenty of quality

Parker - Walking injury whose ability gets over rated on here but is a good 4th stringer

Nothing amongst that tells me that we should be looking to move Walker on


You're correct, but only because none of our problems are listed "amongst that".:rofl:
 
I don't think you get the point I was making . There is no such thing as an ugly person

Whatever you say Quasimodo.

I was making a joke, maybe you should save your philosophical correctness for your other forums buddy, this is a rugby league forum.[/QUOTE]
Its hard to tell if someone is joking or not behind a monitor but thanks for making it clear on what you meant. .
You are right this is a forum and we all have the right to have our say and express our views .
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Broncos 5 4 0 1 66 8
2 Bulldogs 4 4 0 0 46 8
3 Warriors 4 3 0 1 8 8
4 Rabbitohs 5 4 0 1 4 8
5 Sea Eagles 4 3 0 1 52 6
6 Storm 3 2 0 1 38 6
7 Raiders 5 3 0 2 -2 6
8 Knights 3 2 0 1 -4 6
9 Titans 4 2 0 2 -4 6
10 Sharks 5 2 0 3 15 4
11 Tigers 5 2 0 3 12 4
12 Dragons 4 1 0 3 -4 4
13 Cowboys 5 2 0 3 -50 4
14 Dolphins 5 1 0 4 -10 2
15 Panthers 5 1 0 4 -20 2
16 Roosters 5 1 0 4 -62 2
17 Eels 5 1 0 4 -85 2
Back
Top Bottom