Ballin

[silver]

Didn't Ballin coach one of our pathways teams a few years ago and was punted after poor results?

 

[The Who]

Didn't Ballin coach one of our pathways teams a few years ago and was punted after poor results?

Yep, from my memory he had as much success as an Air B&B host is currently having in Iran.

 

[Nordburg]

Didn't Ballin coach one of our pathways teams a few years ago and was punted after poor results?

There were poor results but I believe the fact his now ex wife and kids were still living in Brisbane and he was commuting every week to Sydney,played a part

 

[MissKate]

Didn't Ballin coach one of our pathways teams a few years ago and was punted after poor results?

But who was he learning to be a coach from. Maybe he wasn’t getting the right training, hopefully that has been remedied working at the donkeys

 

[Nordburg]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches. Ennis is the being pushed by the media and Ballin is just Silvertailers fixated by the need to have a former Manly player be the coach. In the NRL era,only Bellamy,Ricky,Des and Flanagan(which doesn’t count), have won premierships without being a head coach elsewhere at either a NRL,NSW/QLD Cup or Super League. Assistants are always loved by the players because they don’t make the big decisions and play the “good guy” at the club.Head coaching experience is valuable

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches. Ennis is the being pushed by the media and Ballin is just Silvertailers fixated by the need to have a former Manly player be the coach. In the NRL era,only Bellamy,Ricky,Des and Flanagan(which doesn’t count), have won premierships without being a head coach elsewhere at either a NRL,NSW/QLD Cup or Super League. Assistants are always loved by the players because they don’t make the big decisions and play the “good guy” at the club.Head coaching experience is valuable

Maybe it's like the obsession with young players.
Pick the young guy, he could be anything (because we don't know yet). Pick the shiny untried assistant coach, he might be the next Bellamy/Bennett (you just never know!)

 

[eaglebuzz]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches. Ennis is the being pushed by the media and Ballin is just Silvertailers fixated by the need to have a former Manly player be the coach. In the NRL era,only Bellamy,Ricky,Des and Flanagan(which doesn’t count), have won premierships without being a head coach elsewhere at either a NRL,NSW/QLD Cup or Super League. Assistants are always loved by the players because they don’t make the big decisions and play the “good guy” at the club.Head coaching experience is valuable

My concern with Siebold is that the players don't seem willing to do the tough stuff under him, and it is costing us winnable matches.

It's either a reflection or poor man management, or bad game plans. Either way we need someone at the helm who can address this glaring issue. To be fair that person could be Siebold, but he needs to get his act together if it is to be him.

Ballin or Ennis might not be the answer either, but Ballin strikes me as the kind of guy who could command respect as a head coach.

 

[Frogz]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches. Ennis is the being pushed by the media and Ballin is just Silvertailers fixated by the need to have a former Manly player be the coach. In the NRL era,only Bellamy,Ricky,Des and Flanagan(which doesn’t count), have won premierships without being a head coach elsewhere at either a NRL,NSW/QLD Cup or Super League. Assistants are always loved by the players because they don’t make the big decisions and play the “good guy” at the club.Head coaching experience is valuable

It's a huge call. You would think that all the good coaches are coaching. Look at Perth, they even had to settle with Meninga. There just isn't an outstanding list of candidates. Which is why, I guess, it has to be an assistant. All coaches were assistants at one stage. Just like Ciraldo and Webster, for example.

 

[Ohgeez]

I seen rumours a while ago that Ballin was not liked by players when he was assistant. No idea if it’s true but when you see he has already been sacked for failing in the younger grades I doubt he will be a option.

 

[Nordburg]

My concern with Siebold is that the players don't seem willing to do the tough stuff under him, and it is costing us winnable matches.

It's either a reflection or poor man management, or bad game plans. Either way we need someone at the helm who can address this glaring issue. To be fair that person could be Siebold, but he needs to get his act together if it is to be him.

Ballin or Ennis might not be the answer either, but Ballin strikes me as the kind of guy who could command respect as a head coach.

I certainly wasn’t defending Seibold,I never wanted him there from day 1

 

[Nordburg]

Maybe it's like the obsession with young players.
Pick the young guy, he could be anything (because we don't know yet). Pick the shiny untried assistant coach, he might be the next Bellamy/Bennett (you just never know!)

I suppose the argument to that is if the young player isn’t what he turned out to be,you can always drop him down to reserve grade and the fact that they’re young,a sensible club wouldnt have spent big $$ on them originally,obviously Manly don’t fall into that category(Schuster and Latu Fainu for eg)A rookie first grade coach would be on more coin than a young up and coming player and more expensive to offload. At least with the player,there’s more exposed form to judge on their abilities than a coach who has only ever been an assistant

 

[Darknstormy]

He won’t solve our problems

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches.

I think it's the hope of finding someone outside the very shallow "talent" pool of NRL head coaches. A lot of the time it does feel like a merry go round: the same old blokes (Des, Wayne, Flanno, etc) going from club to club because nobody else has the experience.

I'm always wary of the next "best young coach in the game" hype (primarily because of Barrett), but there are a bunch of newer, younger coaches who appear to know what they're doing: Ciraldo, Fitzy at the Sharks, Woolfe at the Dolphins, Webster at the Warriors, and even Ryles at the Eels.

Mind you, Seibs was once considered the best young coach in the game (and has the 2018 Dally M Coach of the Year award to prove it)…

 

[Nordburg]

I think it's the hope of finding someone outside the very shallow "talent" pool of NRL head coaches. A lot of the time it does feel like a merry go round: the same old blokes (Des, Wayne, Flanno, etc) going from club to club because nobody else has the experience.

I'm always wary of the next "best young coach in the game" hype (primarily because of Barrett), but there are a bunch of newer, younger coaches who appear to know what they're doing: Ciraldo, Fitzy at the Sharks, Woolfe at the Dolphins, Webster at the Warriors, and even Ryles at the Eels.

Mind you, Seibs was once considered the best young coach in the game (and has the 2018 Dally M Coach of the Year award to prove it)…

True,but the examples you’ve given Woolfe was a successful head coach in SL and the other 3 were highly rated by a lot of people,not just Gus trying to stuff Manly over by praising Barrett.Not sure I’ve heard the same praise for Ballin as those other guys

 

[Nike]

Seibold fronts DCE as details of Roosters deal revealed; four-club race to sign Tiger NOW — Hoops

Seibold fronts DCE as details of Roosters deal revealed; four-club race to sign Tiger NOW — Hoops

www.foxsports.com.au

"There’s a big push amongst the Manly old boys for either Chad Randall or Matt Balin to be brought back to the club to try and re-build a broken roster."

Not totally against the idea but wouldn't pull the trigger just yet (unless someone else has their eye on him), DCE's bull**** has really distorted Siebold's results this year. Ballin is going to need a competent bunch of assistants surrounding him - preferably blokes like Snake, Monas and others from that era.

I've been banging on about it for ages but how the hell has Jim Dymock avoided criticism all this time?

 

[MW66]

Chad Randall is actually a good shout. He is with the Dogs and has been a part of the rebuild from the inside. I like this.

 

[Nordburg]

Seibold fronts DCE as details of Roosters deal revealed; four-club race to sign Tiger NOW — Hoops

Seibold fronts DCE as details of Roosters deal revealed; four-club race to sign Tiger NOW — Hoops

www.foxsports.com.au

"There’s a big push amongst the Manly old boys for either Chad Randall or Matt Balin to be brought back to the club to try and re-build a broken roster."

Not totally against the idea but wouldn't pull the trigger just yet (unless someone else has their eye on him), DCE's bull**** has really distorted Siebold's results this year. Ballin is going to need a competent bunch of assistants surrounding him - preferably blokes like Snake, Monas and others from that era.

I've been banging on about it for ages but how the hell has Jim Dymock avoided criticism all this time?

The story also said JakeT was currently not a fan of Seibold at the moment,so that only enhances the rumours that this situation began early last year when DCE first asked for a release.DCE’s contract saga has contributed to the shambles but the problems lie deeper and it’s squarely at Seibold’s feet

 

[The better Robbo]

I have heard the club has looked at Ballin, Ennis and Brad Arthur as options IF Siebold can't turn it around quickly! I'd be concerned going an untried coach. Arthur has been at Manly before and coached Parra to a GF. Could/ would he be a good option? I'm not sure.

 

[Brookie1973]

Not sure what the fascination is with bringing in assistant coaches. Ennis is the being pushed by the media and Ballin is just Silvertailers fixated by the need to have a former Manly player be the coach. In the NRL era,only Bellamy,Ricky,Des and Flanagan(which doesn’t count), have won premierships without being a head coach elsewhere at either a NRL,NSW/QLD Cup or Super League. Assistants are always loved by the players because they don’t make the big decisions and play the “good guy” at the club.Head coaching experience is valuable

True, but Seibold had head coaching experience.

 

[master blaster]

Chad Randall is actually a good shout. He is with the Dogs and has been a part of the rebuild from the inside. I like this.

BY all accounts he is very good and very smart