Will we lose points for the sin bin?

[Eagles2nv]

So I remembered this happening after last night's events. I had totally forgotten that the Broncos had their points reinstated though. Go figure...

The article below came out before the points were reinstated weeks later

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2004-04-14/broncos-stripped-of-competition-points/170672

Difference was the donkeys went against the NRL official that's why they were docked (and then not).

 

[KNUCKLES]

Evidence has come out via social media that proves that Trent Merrin was allowed back on the field a min under the ten min sin binning. Yet nothing was made of it. Another manly media bashing

 

[Woodsie]

Not just that. They couldn't even find the line. We found the line with 11 on the field.

To be fair, we had the same advantage for 20 mins. We just capitalised on ours

There you go .... bringing facts in just to spoil a good argument .....

 

[Fluffy]

nrl fark up, no points loss

 

[yokahontas]

When she came out with "But why should the Storm be penalized?" I thought WTF, was she thinking that Melbourne should be given the 2 competition points? She was obviously flustered/annoyed when saying this, she couldnt hide the expression on her face. Does she support Melbourne?

Ummm, they should be penalised because they’re grubby cheating scumbags? Duh!

 

[Woodsie]

And another 10 for Jake...

Jake 10 min + Api/Walker 8min20sec ... = 18min 20sc

But as that killjoy @Eagles2nv pointed out .... after Api and Walker came back on Melb were one short for the rest of the game and then two short with about 3 min to go ...

 

[Fluffy]

Evidence has come out via social media that proves that Trent Merrin was allowed back on the field a min under the ten min sin binning. Yet nothing was made of it. Another manly media bashing

media are just trying to find the manly link

 

[HappilyManly]

Basically the Scumos lost because sCam was off for 80 minutes

Changing of the old guard like Manly had in 2015

 

[ALinda]

The NRL has apologised to the Manly club

In our dreams!

 

[mickqld]

Have to admit I'm going off her a little bit. Not saying I'd knock her back if she asked me nicely, but she has the wrong type of maroon blood flowing through her veins. Starting to grate a bit.

Yeah it's a real dilema. Oh wait I'm married and simply will have no chance at taping that. So I don't like her cause of her maroon Scam lovefest. But I wouldn't look away if she was naked.

 

[Sue]

Are you guys serious. Seen her live?

Would frighten a bulldog out of a butcher shop.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

I'm not sure if anyone else has raised this, but I have gone back to the game clock and compared it to the fox clock and also Greenwich mean time, and I may have missed something, but I am fairly confident josh addo-Carr was off the field for less than 4 minutes.

It’s ok.

He won’t join the fray in their next Manly game until about the 6min 30sec mark.

 

[davohan123]

Here is the evidence pretty clear cut
Won't get a mention anywhere

 

[Cameron]

Wait for it at midday on triple m. That flog Hooper will say we should lose points. Any bets
Saying he will say otherwise.

 

[Eagles2nv]

Lockyer on Sunday footy show said that the NRL said to him that:

1. A replacement official was used and the regular one was away

2. He was on the phone getting clarity around sin bins and HIA as manly wanted clarity about getting Wright on as a free interchange

3. Whilst on the phone he forgot to stop the clock when the game clock was stopped during play (uate try review), resulting in an error.

 

[Harvies elbow]

Lockyer on Sunday footy show said that the NRL said to him that:

1. A replacement official was used and the regular one was away

2. He was on the phone getting clarity around sin bins and HIA as manky wanted clarity about getting Wright on as a free interchange

3. Whilst on the phone he forgot to stop the clock when the game clock was stopped during play, resulting in an error.

Probably also selling bacon and egg rolls and raffle tickets as well...

 

[Cameron]

Wait for it at midday on triple m. That flog Hooper will say we should lose points. Any bets
Saying he will say otherwise.

I know we aren’t supposed to use this word on silvertails but Hooper is a ****

 

[Deleted member 24974]

When does the 10 minutes start to be timed? If two players are sin binned at the same time does the 10 minutes start when the first player is binned or the second player. Seems they can not be timed individually as it would favour team of the player binned first as they are being timed while the second player is being cautioned not in actual game time.

 

[Cameron]

Wow I was wrong flog Hooper and Kenty both not blaming manly blaming the nrl. Wow just wow

 

[HappilyManly]

Why doesn't the 2 million dollar Bunker keep the game clock.

After all, they are the ones with the technology and the direct line to the Refs