why has nobody mentioned.........


First Grader
.....the fact that the pass from Stewart to hicks to score our last try was a long way forward.

For a site that is supposed to be "real" and not just follow the party line methinks a little unbiased observation may not go astray.


First Grader
we arent talking about origin 1 will, and 2 wrongs dont make a right.

P.S. great game SOO 1, my first time at Suncorp, well worth the trip :)


Kim Jong Dan
Staff member
Tipping Member
I thought it was forward to but I didnt really see it that clearly i wa too excited


First Grader
mate it was well and truly forward, I wasnt complaining mind you.

thats the problem with complaining about the refs, yes he got a heap wrong, which just makes him a sh!it ref, but not that he cost us the game.


First Grader
Careful Daniel, I know where you live............. well actually I dont but I thought it sounded suitably threatening ;)
Reserve Grader
Because it wasnt Forward , its all to do with the Hands if its Thrown back form the hands , and floats forward its ok
i was just going to say what Six said, its called inertia, it happens often when a bloke as fast as stewart throws a past, he passes it backwards, and remember backwards is only 1 degree beyond sideways, then because of inertia it floats forward.

needless to say niether the touchy or the ref could keep up with hicks so **** them!

the issue re the kick off is simply a rule issue, not open to interpretation.


First Grader
Sorry Pepsi, I know what you are saying but it doesnt apply in this case, it was a relatively short pass and was going nowhere but forward.

Your second comment was a lot closer to the mark, they were too slow to keep up :)

As I said earlier, he is just a crap ref. much like the majority of them, but there is nothing more sinister to it than that
UFO Hunter
It is hard to tell. I actually skipped back on the recording to see it a couple of times and to be honest I don't think I could have said unless I was in line with the pass at the ground.

Looks forward but is hard to tell wether it was momentum or deliberate.
First Grader
I have watched that pass on the telly and it was not forward. It was passed behind Stewart. Even Graham Murray didn't call it forward and said it was okay.
Team P W L PD Pts
4 4 0 41 8
4 3 1 8 8
4 2 2 45 6
3 2 1 28 6
4 3 1 26 6
4 3 1 16 6
5 3 2 6 6
4 2 2 -10 6
4 2 2 23 4
5 2 3 -6 4
4 2 2 -9 4
4 2 2 -12 4
4 2 2 -13 4
3 1 2 -40 4
5 1 4 -19 2
5 1 4 -54 2
4 0 4 -30 0
Top Bottom