The No-Look News (Schuster Chronicles)

[double hoops]

The initial contract was fine. It was the upgraded contract that was a joke.

Whoever the player manager was deserves double commission.

I wonder if player managers are too concerned about their own self interest when it comes to $$$. Especially for younger players. When the number is big, it can and has killed many a career.

The concept of owing a fiduciary duty to a client, especially in the case of a younger player, their best interests, it should never be viewed through a purely financial lense.

The bigger that number, the greater the pressure to perform, the less patience and time a club can give to find form, the less attractive that player is for other clubs to take that player on.

Shoes contract was a big number. But where is that great young talent right now.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

If he is being paid $200 in 2026 bring him back on a train and trial basis. Not much to loose really.

 

[JenEagle]

He will never play NRL again. He’s been out of the game two years now.

 

[Eagle 1]

If he is being paid $200 in 2026 bring him back on a train and trial basis. Not much to loose really.

I think having the Shoe around our juniors that are coming through would be a perfect fit for him. Put him into a coaching role, attack wise, the kids would be awestruck.

 

[jbb/james]

If he is being paid $200 in 2026 bring him back on a train and trial basis. Not much to loose really.

Ot sure we want to devote a roster spot , even a train and trial

 

[The '47ers]

How about we just close the book and let it be.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

How about we just close the book and let it be.

That’s where we are at right now , except the book is still open at the last page

 

[Pete W]

I think having the Shoe around our juniors that are coming through would be a perfect fit for him. Put him into a coaching role, attack wise, the kids would be awestruck.

He can teach our juniors about hard training, discipline, mental fortitude, teamwork, off-the-ball effort, and doing all the 1%ers - all the things he is known for.

(Sorry, couldn't help myself. I genuinely wish him well)

 

[LeonardCohen]

I think having the Shoe around our juniors that are coming through would be a perfect fit for him. Put him into a coaching role, attack wise, the kids would be awestruck.

You’ve got to be kidding…the last thing you want around juniors is a guy that’s struggling for motivation and discipline.

 

[Eagle 1]

You’ve got to be kidding…the last thing you want around juniors is a guy that’s struggling for motivation and discipline.

Obviously I've hit a nerve with the Shoe, thought it might have been a good idea. Maybe further down the track could be a possibility perhaps.

 

[LeonardCohen]

Obviously I've hit a nerve with the Shoe, thought it might have been a good idea. Maybe further down the track could be a possibility perhaps.

You can never say never; Foran probably never thought he’d be mentoring others in a coaching role when he hit rock bottom. I guess I don’t really like Schu though. I think he was arrogant about his talent and played for himself.

 

[mave]

You can never say never; Foran probably never thought he’d be mentoring others in a coaching role when he hit rock bottom. I guess I don’t really like Schu though. I think he was arrogant about his talent and played for himself.

Common theme around these parts, for the last decade at least.

 

[Bearfax]

Needs to step away from the game for a year. He's young enough. Maybe a little park football. Take time out and work out if he has the desire to put in the commitment for full time week after week football. He has the talent but seems to lack the resolve. He's got to want it hard enough. Many very talented people don't make it in their chosen field because they lack the drive. Self belief, drive and commitment. Talent alone gets you nowhere. And its a long way back to the top.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

How about we just close the book and let it be.

You’re speaking words of wisdom, No.47.

 

[WiseyEagle]

Someone else in the group as already closed the book. But can the NRL or whoever closes books, make this official?

Some things were never meant to be.

Joshua 1:9: Have I not commanded you? Be strong and courageous. Do not be frightened, and do not be dismayed, for the Lord your God is with you wherever you go.

 

[JenEagle]

I thought he was one of the most talented players I’ve ever seen.

He should have stuck to being a backrower and he could have been anything.

In 2021 he was on the verge of origin at one point and he had only played 10 first grade games. His defence was awesome as well in the early part of that year.

If he had have kicked on and turbo hadn’t got injured so much we may have won a comp. He was that good

Absolute travesty for us and him.

 

[Phobia]

I thought he was one of the most talented players I’ve ever seen.

He should have stuck to being a backrower and he could have been anything.

In 2021 he was on the verge of origin at one point and he had only played 10 first grade games. His defence was awesome as well in the early part of that year.

If he had have kicked on and turbo hadn’t go let injured so much we may have won a comp. He was that good

Absolute travesty for us and him.

I think Tartak should have a lot of blame placed upon him. He set unrealistic expectations on Schuster and that ruined his career, and undoubtedly played into his mental health problems.

Tartak may have gotten him $200k per year for nothing until 2027... But his overzealous deals and hype prior to then, may have prevented Josh from ultimately earning millions.

I hope Schuster is doing well mentally.

 

[XV-1]

I think Tartak should have a lot of blame placed upon him. He set unrealistic expectations on Schuster and that ruined his career, and undoubtedly played into his mental health problems.

Tartak may have gotten him $200k per year for nothing until 2027... But his overzealous deals and hype prior to then, may have prevented Josh from ultimately earning millions.

I hope Schuster is doing well mentally.

Agree

If anyone would have known what Josh was going thru, it would have been his manager Tartak.

He is supposed to look after his financial deals as well as supporting his mental health off the field. He would have well known Josh's state of mind, but seemingly kept pushing only the financial aspects.

 

[The Wheel]

Agree

If anyone would have known what Josh was going thru, it would have been his manager Tartak.

He is supposed to look after his financial deals as well as supporting his mental health off the field. He would have well known Josh's state of mind, but seemingly kept pushing only the financial aspects.

And a move to 5/8, he clearly wasn’t suited to

 

[XV-1]

And a move to 5/8, he clearly wasn’t suited to

IMO Schu should have been groomed and coached to be our ball playing lock. He would have been able to play both sides of the field and used as a 2nd 5/8th.

You see how valuable Yeo is to Penrith with his ball playing ,as was Glen Stewart back in the days.

Des and Seibold really missed an opportunity there, sticking to Jake - who is not a ball playing lock whatsoever.

I would luv him to get himself right and play with Manly on a train & trial deal. He is only young and ball players like Cliffy and Cody were older b4 they became established first graders.

We need to see those silky hands again. I still vividly remember the games again Parra and Canberra where he was magical.