Credit to you Ryan for several thought-provoking comments.
On Johns/Cliffy – one of the best things about our game is that it encapsulates such a wide spectrum of human characteristics. Both positive (courage, teamwork, etc etc) and negative. A positive is the inclination to give people a second (third etc) chance, on the basis that perfection is not a human quality, and it is the willingness to learn & take responsibility that is valued, rather than the (non-existent) complete absence of wrongdoing. Having said that, any perceived link with racism would be inexcusable & damaging, so if Johns were involved it would ideally be in conjunction with Cliffy himself! Or at least in collaboration with him, or someone else (Andrew Walker?) or otherwise in some way such that the racism issue was not just swept under the carpet for the sake of getting Johns’s footy nous.
Other points – I like WAMF’s idea of surveying members. I like jbb/james’s concerns about making profits out of third world nations (ouch).
The chief issue for me is always the tension between the perceived need to get fans involved and contributing, versus the continuing need for funding by the private owners and their expectation of commensurate control.
The objects and purpose of the Football Club include propagating the game of rugby league by acquiring and holding shares in Manly Sea Eagles. But the FC has bugger all money with which to acquire shares, and what money it does raise is raised in effect in competition with Sea Eagles.
Then there is the Leagues Club, long-time funder of the mighty Sea Eagles teams, which in recent times was talking about wanting some equity in return for future funding (which was an interesting concept, I always thought there must have been some legal reason why leagues clubs needed to be separate from the actual football clubs?).
Bottom line is that the ownership structure of Manly Sea Eagles is relatively new and evolving, and the agendas of the 2 private owners will determine how things move forward. Having said that, I think the Football Club ought to be seriously studying successful private/public ownership models in major sporting teams, with a view to developing a future model that all stakeholders might agree to work towards.
As well as practising catching bombs