Sea Eagles Elimination Game 2025 (pre-season forum game)

[Ryan]

Clayton Faulalo (3)
Daly Cherry-Evans (10)
Jake Arthur (7)
Jason Saab (3)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (9)
Luke Brooks (7)
Reuben Garrick (8)
Tolutau Koula (8)
Tom Trbojevic (12)
Tommy Talau (7)
Ben Trbojevic (3)
Ethan Bullemor (10)
Gordon Chan Kum Tong (0) - - - -
Haumole Olakau'atu (13)
Jake Simpkin (8) + + + +
Jake Trbojevic (10)
Lachlan Croker (2)
Nathan Brown (2)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (13)
Toff Sipley (6)

Eliminated:
1. Dean Matterson by @Ryanpost #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27
4. Aaron Schoupp by @stuey davis's socks post #40
5. Raymond Tuaimalo Vaega by @Disco post #49
6. Jazz Tevaga by @Stuey Davis’s Socks post #80
7. Corey Waddell by @Discopost #83
8. Michael Chee Kam by @Disco post #91

 

[Disco]

Got it. So we like 17 and don't like the other 13. Assuming we don't know the players personally, then can only rate like or dislike based on what we have seen on the football field or in the press. Still does not inspire confidence does it??.

You're essentially ordering players not rating them as liked or disliked, good or bad.

You could have a all time squad of Manly players. Loved by all and rated by all but someone would still have to come 30th and another 1st

 

[Wombat Junior]

Clayton Faulalo (3)
Daly Cherry-Evans (10)
Jake Arthur (7)
Jason Saab (3)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (10) ++++
Luke Brooks (7)
Reuben Garrick (8)
Tolutau Koula (8)
Tom Trbojevic (12)
Tommy Talau (7)
Ben Trbojevic (3)
Ethan Bullemor (10)
Gordon Chan Kum Tong (0)
Haumole Olakau'atu (13)
Jake Simpkin (8)
Jake Trbojevic (10)
Lachlan Croker (1) - - - -
Nathan Brown (2)
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (13)
Toff Sipley (6)

Eliminated:
1. Dean Matterson by @Ryanpost #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27
4. Aaron Schoupp by @stuey davis's socks post #40
5. Raymond Tuaimalo Vaega by @Disco post #49
6. Jazz Tevaga by @Stuey Davis’s Socks post #80
7. Corey Waddell by @Discopost #83
8. Michael Chee Kam by @Disco post #9

 

[Disco]

This would be interesting to do each pre season to see how each player popularity ebbs and flows.

 

[NREagle]

Clayton Faulalo (3)
Daly Cherry-Evans (10)
Jake Arthur (7)
Jason Saab (3)
Joey Walsh (5)
Lehi Hopoate (10)
Luke Brooks (8) + + + +
Reuben Garrick (8)
Tolutau Koula (8)
Tom Trbojevic (12)
Tommy Talau (7)
Ben Trbojevic (3)
Ethan Bullemor (10)
Haumole Olakau'atu (13)
Jake Simpkin (8)
Jake Trbojevic (10)
Lachlan Croker (1)
Nathan Brown (1) - - - -
Siosiua Taukeiaho (5)
Taniela Paseka (13)
Toff Sipley (6)

Eliminated:
1. Dean Matterson by @Ryanpost #8
2. Josh Aloiai by @Harmless27 post #19
3. Aitasi James by @deanm on post #27
4. Aaron Schoupp by @stuey davis's socks post #40
5. Raymond Tuaimalo Vaega by @Disco post #49
6. Jazz Tevaga by @Stuey Davis’s Socks post #80
7. Corey Waddell by @Discopost #83
8. Michael Chee Kam by @Disco post #9
9. Gordon Chan Kum Tong by @Ryan post #101