Sack Barrett

[damiennp90]

I'm gonna play devils advocate.

He has had a lot of reason.

Injuries
Match fixing
Salary Cap
Green not turning up to training.
Close friend Hastings rubbing everyone up the wrong way.
Suli issues.
Our highest played player playing like a drongo.

Al least he's being disciplined and tough.

 

[BOZO]

I'm gonna play devils advocate.

He has had a lot of reason.

Injuries
Match fixing
Salary Cap
Green not turning up to training.
Close friend Hastings rubbing everyone up the wrong way.
Suli issues.
Our highest played player playing like a drongo.

Al least he's being disciplined and tough.

He still has a roster that should be performing better than what they have .

 

[Cameron]

I'm gonna play devils advocate.

He has had a lot of reason.

Injuries
Match fixing
Salary Cap
Green not turning up to training.
Close friend Hastings rubbing everyone up the wrong way.
Suli issues.
Our highest played player playing like a drongo.

Al least he's being disciplined and tough.

And what about the players he let go
Gutho
Jamie b
Snake
Matai

The guy is a hopeless **** who doesn’t get our clubs culture.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Barrett is in his third year and enough is enough. He must go!

 

[Stevo]

****ing negative tactics. Kick it in the air and attack the ****ing thing for ****s sake. Why are we rolling it into touch when we are chasing points???,

 

[Stevo]

Im just interested to see how many fans believe we need a new coach. Please vote.

 

[Harvies elbow]

At years end.
Who we going to replace him with at this stage of the year?
Who's out there for next year??
But whatever he's done.
This team has no idea, no structure, no desire.
I didn't mention Des or Tooves because they won't be there while the Penn's are in charge.

 

[hozza]

Barret fuc$ing out!!!!!!

Maguire is an option.
Walters with Ballin and kite as assistants.
Des and don’t let him negotiate contracts.

3 much much better options right there. And they are all proven winners, winners find a way to win. Losers (Barret) find ways to lose.

 

[Technical Coach]

Im just interested to see how many fans believe we need a new coach. Please vote.

Right now the club needs stability and patience, i understand this might be hard in such times especially with the performances being dished up but the damage will be far greater for a small club with not much financial capacity churning through coaches hoping for a quick fix----big clubs with big financial resources can do this.

Others here think the total opposite thinking a small club like Manly doesn't have the time to wait.

Right now Manly should be focusing more on the off field stuff like getting the new stadium, improving the front office professionalism, managing the cap, improve the depth and give a young coach guidance and confidence.

Next year is TB's last year to show growth as a coach, hopefully less injuries and depth come his way also.

I still think deep down there is a good coach in TB even with some of the amateurish performance analysis and structures on offer----he has the perfect opportunity to develop this area and see what works and what doesn't the rest of this year since the season is already over.

 

[Harvies elbow]

@strone33 I'm ready to sign up to the sack Barrett club.
Name the fee.

#nomorelisteningtohippys.

 

[hozza]

Much much better options out there.
Maguire- already won a premiership
Walters- proven winner, give him manly assistants
Walker bros- proven track record in Q cup
Dessie- if he came back just don’t let him near any contract negotiations.

Ludicrous to give this monkey any more time. We are MANLY not the Knights ffs.

 

[BOZO]

One of the most important roles of a coach is to stamp his mark on a team and create a culture
Will Trents culture get us anywhere ?

 

[MadMarcus]

Will never happen I know but the right thing for the Penns to do is to put their egos aside, admit they were wrong and beg Toovey to come back.

 

[Harvies elbow]

Right now the club needs stability and patience, i understand this might be hard in such times especially with the performances being dished up but the damage will be far greater for a small club with not much financial capacity churning through coaches hoping for a quick fix----big clubs with big financial resources can do this.

Others here think the total opposite thinking a small club like Manly doesn't have the time to wait.

Right now Manly should be focusing more on the off field stuff like getting the new stadium, improving the front office professionalism, managing the cap, improve the depth and give a young coach guidance and confidence.

Next year is TB's last year to show growth as a coach, hopefully less injuries and depth come his way also.

I still think deep down there is a good coach in TB even with some of the amateurish performance analysis and structures on offer----he has the perfect opportunity to develop this area and see what works and what doesn't the rest of this year since the season is already over.

All good.
If we seemed to be playing like a team that had some idea tactically or with an appearance that they were 'on'.
But aside from a few times during this year, or in fact, his tenure, we have not.
The average roster argument is bs because other clubs like the tigers are no worse than ours.
And the riff smashed by injuries as well.
Souffs have 2 guys we sacked.
Trent was given four internationals to begin his time here.
We are Manly.
Success is an expectation.

 

[MadMarcus]

As a left field semi realistic suggestion for a replacement how about Trent Robinson? If the Roosters don’t go close to winning the comp this year (and I don’t think they will) he will be on the outer. I think he’s a good coach who needs a change of scenery.

 

[Harvies elbow]

One of the most important roles of a coach is to stamp his mark on a team and create a culture
Will Trents culture get us anywhere ?

I'd love to know what it is mate.
I'd like to see what our style is. Our brand of football....
Buggered if I can see it, and if it's what's been before our eyes the last few weeks then god help us.

 

[Harvies elbow]

As a left field semi realistic suggestion for a replacement how about Trent Robinson? If the Roosters don’t go close to winning the comp this year (and I don’t think they will) he will be on the outer. I think he’s a good coach who needs a change of scenery.

And he can bring our 2013 trophy with him...

 

[Technical Coach]

All good.
If we seemed to be playing like a team that had some idea tactically or with an appearance that they were 'on'.
But aside from a few times during this year, or in fact, his tenure, we have not.
The average roster argument is bs because other clubs like the tigers are no worse than ours.
And the riff smashed by injuries as well.
Souffs have 2 guys we sacked.
Trent was given four internationals to begin his time here.
We are Manly.
Success is an expectation.

I never said Manly have an average roster, Manly have a very good roster in the top 17 and should be doing much better.

Depth beyond that not so much, stability in the halves and outside backs has not been great this year also.

I get what you are saying but you don't always have a great year in line with expectations, great rosters with great coaches who have performed badly happens all the time.

 

[Clint]

I don't think we should flick Trent at the moment but I would if the option was to bring back Toovs.

 

[ManlyTragic]

Much much better options out there.
Maguire- already won a premiership
Walters- proven winner, give him manly assistants
Walker bros- proven track record in Q cup
Dessie- if he came back just don’t let him near any contract negotiations.

Ludicrous to give this monkey any more time. We are MANLY not the Knights ffs.

Hey Hozza you left out Cartwright .... just sayin