Great effort from the lads tonight against a pretty good side. That is the best performance from Souths I have seen in quite some time. But the way we fought back on numerous occasions was commendable. Whilst no one could ever question his loyalty, commitment and dedication, I feel that Manly might be better served with a different winger than Robbo. Not sure about you guys, but every time the ball was spread to the left, I knew that nothing special was going to happen at the end of it. However on the other side, Oldfield is an absolute gun the way he hits the holes at speed, which sadly is what poor old Robbo is lacking these days. Oldfield has something special. Everytime he gets the ball, there is a feeling of anticipation. Robbo has been a great servant to our club, but he offers very little in attack and defensive positioning. Yes he scored 3 tries in the grand final, and no one will forget that. Anyway there is probably little point in raising this thread, for Des will NEVER drop him.