Question ..... Who is the worst footballer to play first grade ?

[mosto]

Ian "Chook" Herron

 

[Mals]

Paul Kent - 1 1st grade game for Parra

 

[the mauler]

Craig Bellamy.

 

[HoldenV8]

The sad thing about Garrick Morgan is that he is Jim "Pogo" Morgan's son. Pogo had some talent, playing 111 games for Souffs and the Rorters between 1965 and 1972 and only missed a place in the Easts team that we beat in the 1972 GF through injury. He also played 4 tests for Australia, 8 games for NSW and 3 games for Country. You'd have thought that some of that would have rubbed off on his son.........

Would that sprinter who played for the Rorters in the mid-90's, Shane Whereat count? One of the fastest players I've seen, but other than that he was next to useless. While former Olympic and Commonwealth games 400 metre sprinter Darren Clarke had the good sense to go back to running after having a go at Balmain.

Jeff Fenech when he had a stint as the Speels reserve grade hooker. Like Clarke 2 years later, Fenech quickly realised that his talent was in another field, or ring in his case.

Former Cronulla and Souffs winger Eion Crosson comes to mind. Lucky he could kick goals......

What about Lee Oudenryn? His only claim to fame was beating Martin Offiah in that sprint race at Parramatta Stadium back in 1992. And even then there were rumours (started I believe by Benny Elias) that Offiah had tanked so his Lions team mates could collect big money from the bookies.

 

[HoldenV8]

Ian "Chook" Herron

Chook wasn't all that bad. Bit slow for a winger, but not bad. I've seen a lot worse.

Here are two words that most here would probably agree with.....

Craig Field.

 

[Fluffy]

Having read this forum for the last few months it is a dead heat between every manly player who has played first grade this year

 

[HoldenV8]

Having read this forum for the last few months it is a dead heat between every manly player who has played first grade this year

Wash your mouth out with soap young man. We have not once criticised Jake Trbojevic.

 

[Fluffy]

Wash your mouth out with soap young man. We have not once criticised Jake Trbojevic.

He copped it for passing too much back around April. Somewhat rightfully too as it became the norm not the step up, since then he has returned to running hard as a prop should.

 

[lsz]

CHris White had one good game for us (that Canberra semi in 91)

My favorite was when clubs in the 90's starting bringing in players with either speed (darren clarke) or could kick (remember Eion Crossen (?) ) from soufs) and dump them on the wing

 

[cherry_poppins]

Scott Donald

 

[pjayz]

Paul Kent - 1 1st grade game for Parra

Beat me to it!

 

[BOZO]

Brayden Wiliame

 

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

Scott (2 drop ball a game Fulton).

 

[Shoe1]

Brayden Wiliame

He certainly had some unfortunate games for us this year. Hopefully he is young enough to bounce back.

I thought Copley at Brisbane was the worst I'd seen, terrible hands, no peripheral vision, two left feet, but he came back with some solid efforts last year.

 

[Shoe1]

Scott (2 drop ball a game Fulton).

The worst incident of his I recall was against knights or dogs when he did his block after being tackled a few metres out from our own line. He threw the ball at the tackler's head in rage, conceding possession, a penalty and points.

 

[Prez]

Dragan Durdevic and Gary Winter were crackers.

Grant 'The Squasher' Wooden...

 

[Prez]

Micheal Bani
Peta Hiku
Tony Williams
Luke Williamson
Chris Bailey
Jye Mullane
James Hasson
Carl Webb
Chris Sandow
Akuila Uate

Michael Bani's career was injury ravaged. He was a decent player and definitely doesn't deserve to be on this list.

 

[brad]

Don price.

 

[eggson]

Paul Carige for 'that' game

 

[Stuey Davis’s Socks]

Andy Goodway - remember this pommie failure from the mid-80s?