I'm not getting into who is right and who wrong. I'm just saying from an outsider's perspective (and that is very important for the health of the club) its a very bad look. Point is Penn and his group have put themselves into a corner here. They sacked a successful coach in Toovey, brought in a novice in Barrett, stuffed up the salary cap, blamed Hasler for Manly's failure this year, despite his success the year before and now claim this is a premiership winning side. I would hate to be in Siebold's or Penn's shoes by season's end 2023 if Manly flounder. Had the chance of allowing a face saving solution without litigation and probable extra heavy costs, and instead decided to renege on the offer made. My impression about how this club is being run is not too favourable. I know there were problems especially regarding recruitment and strategies bringing young players through, and as an amateur I thought Des too conservative, but a year with Siebold as assistant leading to the full coaching role, seemed a sensible way out.