Game Day: Manly v Souths [Round 2, 2021]

[bob dylan]

Yes, but he had plenty of stuff ups as well last year - especially defensively but they kept him in anyway and he is coming good.

Let’s see how Schuster is with a season under his belt in his preferred position.

Yes, agree we need to persevere with him.

 

[The Royal Soup]

Walker - ****

Garrick - ****

Parker - meh

Suli - lazy in defence

Foran - try’s his guts out

DCE - lol

jake - plod plod plod

Davy - we just lost our best forward for the year

JetSki - overrated ****

marty - tries hard

croker - lol

Paskek - goes ok

Schuster - out of position, needs to be 5/8 or center

Cust - should be starting hooker

JA - gun

 

[Jigzkiller]

Was talking in the future you clown, geez there are some know all ****wits on here tonight.

Anyone who compares the players you did is the ****wit.

 

[Hibyemama]

Schuster is as dumb as a bucket.

I guess there is a reason why des dosnt bring the youngsters through. inexpereinced

 

[madmax]

I don’t expect him to be a champion first up - that’s silly. I think he will develop into one if people are patient and he gets a season under his belt.

Mate the pessimists in here need to vent on someone every week & bag them. Schuster played better than most but it’s obviously his turn to cop it. I don’t know what they expect!

 

[pjayz]

Agree but I think Walker played ok he is out position he is trying he had a go he needs to play centre he is a way better centre than Parker and I think Harper would be a better fullback than Walker

I agree. I don’t blame Walker at all. The thing is, where is he going to play when Tom comes back? Centre obviously. So why disrupt another position unnecessarily. It’s not the best thing for the team or Walker.

When Tom comes back Dylan has to readjust and effectively start over again. Des should have played Harper or Koula there from round one and put Walker in the centres with Suli.

 

[mickqld]

The only players that looked like 1st graders were Taupau, Paseka, Aloiai, Jake, Keppie

 

[pjayz]

I guess there is a reason why des dosnt bring the youngsters through. inexpereinced

And they will stay that way if they never get a run.

 

[simon64]

Look at the bright side.

We scored twice as many tries as we did last week.
And conceded half the number as well.

At least there were some positive signs this week. Last week was an absolute embarrassment.

 

[Little Grubber Kick]

Replace DCE with Cust

Cust at Half and Schuster at the eight and we win more than we lose

 

[mickqld]

South’s were gassed after the Melbourne game and played worse than us, still a lot better effort this week than last, but still any side carrying their no 7 is in trouble.

You mean carrying a $1mil #7

 

[madmax]

Well done mate, knock a 19 year old for a Hail Mary play with a minute on the clock.

If it paid off & we scored then he’d be a superstar to the same people bagging him.

 

[Little Grubber Kick]

We've got an out of form halfback, a centre bumbling and stumbling at fullback because our real fullback is re-tiling his bathroom to look like the Corso, and back rowers dropping like flies.

Going well.

how can you be 'out of form' after only 2 weeks

don't worry we'll get a $200K game out of him against an also ran soon enough

 

[Simonmyers11]

Schuster has looked great at times as an edge back rower and I honestly believe that he and Burbo could be the next kosef menzies. In our glory days we had Kosef Menzies backrow or Stewart Watmough now we have Gosiewski and Davey starting. not to mention our centres we had lyon matai now we have parker suli

He might have to play a lot more there. Davey, Siro and Quac all out for 4-6 weeks

 

[madmax]

I guess there is a reason why des dosnt bring the youngsters through. inexpereinced

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.......

 

[Jerry1]

Anyone who compares the players you did is the ****wit.

Settle down. It’s our job to call out dumb plays.

 

[conanu]

Anyone who compares the players you did is the ****wit.

****wits like you getting stuck into 19 year old playing out of position and in their second game of first grade are the reason that Des needs to shield players from first grade and numptys that bag them. The kosef menzies comparison was more to do with the fact that they are both mates coming through the system at the same time and are from our juniors, of course I am not comparing them to their success. But a clown like you who has been around for 5 minutes wouldn't understand that comparison. don't bother replying dickhead because you have shown us all that whatever comes out of your head isn't worth the read.

 

[hozza]

The only players that looked like 1st graders were Taupau, Paseka, Aloiai, Jake, Keppie

Our whole backline needs to be replaced. Don’t worry though Mick, we’ll sign 4 forwards for next year

 

[Fibro Eagle]

I agree. I don’t blame Walker at all. The thing is, where is he going to play when Tom comes back? Centre obviously. So why disrupt another position unnecessarily. It’s not the best thing for the team or Walker.

When Tom comes back Dylan has to readjust and effectively start over again. Des should have played Harper or Koula there from round one and put Walker in the centres with Suli.

Walker I believe can adjust he is a good player , I’d like to see Walker and Saab on the same side

 

[wombatgc]

Bull$hit decision by Sutton. Its up to the tackler to clear the ruck, not up to the ball carrier to walk off the mark.

It was Anastas comment of "you can clearly see DCE playing the ball back with force on purpose to get the penalty’’.......his time on Fox should go the same way as Gasniers...down the gurgler.