Pre-Game Manly V Cowboys [Round 1, 2025]

[Phobia]

Waddell , Sipley on bench, TKO starting. That is not a top 4 pack. Brown looked unfit in trials , Aloiai at #22. Looks like some have been holidaying too much. No confidence in our forwards. Cows by 10.

The last two times we had both Waddell and Sipley on the bench, we played the Panthers. We beat them the first time, and were goalkicking away from beating them the second time.

It isn't about the cattle, it's the attitude and fitness. Would prefer a fit Waddell over an unfit Aloiai every day of the week.

 

[Mitch]

No Brown, Aloiai named in reserves... Surely both are injured. I don't think we are seeing out strongest possible 17 here.

I'm keen to see how Tevaga goes at 9. He surely must be better than Croker.

Both would be in the 17 if fit for Sipley and Waddell.

 

[Heckenberg]

Honestly how the hell does Duck waddle get a run? Kills me….

Clearly, coach is a mug. 😜

Much rather Navale get a crack…

He’s probably our best second row cover and can play prop too. Not any others that are really proven backrowers. I’m most surprised that aloiai isn’t getting a run over Toff. Wonder if he’s on the outer.

 

[madmax]

agree, but strange that you are so complimentary about our players and yet do not rate the Broncos roster?! Bit of one-eyed supporter stuff happening, me thinks.

I dunno mate I just don’t think the Broncos are as good as what they’re made out to be. Of course I’m one eyed Lolol…..if somehow our forwards played to their real potential our backs could carve up. To be honest mate there’s not one of the Broncos backs I’d swap for ours & apart from Carrigan & Hetherington I’m not interested in the rest.

 

[madmax]

He’s probably our best second row cover and can play prop too. Not any others that are really proven backrowers. I’m most surprised that aloiai isn’t getting a run over Toff. Wonder if he’s on the outer.

Olakau’atu is our only real back rower! For mine I’d be happy with Waddell partnering him. He’s solid, fairly quick, defense is sound & has a good offload.

 

[Ohgeez]

Waddell , Sipley on bench, TKO starting. That is not a top 4 pack. Brown looked unfit in trials , Aloiai at #22. Looks like some have been holidaying too much. No confidence in our forwards. Cows by 10.

What are you talking about?? Aloia had a shoulder injury & has always been in doubt for round 1. As for Brown he didn’t play much of that trial so he probably picked up a small injury too.

 

[Kalvin]

Lol i love that a ball hasn't even been kicked this season and people are complaining about how bad are pack is!

 

[deanm]

Lol i love that a ball hasn't even been kicked this season and people are complaining about how bad are pack is!

Yeah , because the supporters on here Know Rugby League. What would Seibold and his lot know...................

 

[LeonardCohen]

I dunno mate I just don’t think the Broncos are as good as what they’re made out to be. Of course I’m one eyed Lolol…..if somehow our forwards played to their real potential our backs could carve up. To be honest mate there’s not one of the Broncos backs I’d swap for ours & apart from Carrigan & Hetherington I’m not interested in the rest.

Yeah, definitely food for thought...I'd take Haas (over any of our props), Piakura (over Ben T), Riki (over Waddell), Staggs (over Garrick in the centres), Mariner or Cobbo (over Saab or Talau), Paix or Mozer (over any of our hookers). Then of course you've mentioned Carrigan and Hetherington.

It's a fast team with plenty of power. Their Achilles heel seems to be themselves, more so than a lack of talent. It's basically the same squad that were in front of Penrith with 20 minutes to go in the 23' GF. Then they went to sleep.

Anyway, I admire your passion and loyalty for our roster. I agree, a number of players are unfairly maligned...one mistake and their head is on the chopping block around here.

 

[Sea Eagle 4 Life]

We've got Zorro / the dad from Lost in Space as a coach? Should be a swashbuckling, out of this world performance!

Guy Williams (actor) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Yes, he is a good man as I know him well from our adventures in outerspace.

 

[double hoops]

Gee no JT named for the Cows. And there forward back is looking extra small and mobile. Looking at the opposition team named, makes the Duck and even better inclusion. Our Big men can smash em, but it's our speed and mobility in defence that is going to be tested.

 

[Dion Johnson]

Gee no JT named for the Cows. And there forward back is looking extra small and mobile. Looking at the opposition team named, makes the Duck and even better inclusion. Our Big men can smash em, but it's our speed and mobility in defence that is going to be tested.

Named on the extended bench JT, had that injury from the Tonga game last season.

 

[double hoops]

Named on the extended bench JT, had that injury from the Tonga game last season.

Ahh righto. Ahh Let the cows worry about if he's a late inclusion or not. Our forwards just need to worry about our game and SMASH EM.

 

[Nambawan]

Olakau’atu is our only real back rower! For mine I’d be happy with Waddell partnering him. He’s solid, fairly quick, defense is sound & has a good offload.

Wadell completely without ball skills. Any centre outside him will not see any ball.

 

[BOZO]

It's that time again ... our sovereign right to tell the coach he's a mug.
Seems straight forward this week ... BUT ... then I consider our pack .. who starts .. who misses out ?..
Is Ben T a lock in at 2nd row?
Will Saab start s expected or will Clayton be a smokey ?

It is that time again and when the Winning Starts the Praising Also Starts
because at Manly we love Winners .
Good Luck to all Representing the Great Manly Club in 2025
I hope we all Rise to the Top Like Great Soaring Sea eagles