Luke Garner

[maxta]

Garner is a decent signing, hits the edges well and could see him attacking the left edge and adding an option we didn't have much of in 2020.

 

[The better Robbo]

I like the Garner and Davey signings. Both are quality players and will add a lot to our team. People saying they are average must not have seen too much of them.

 

[manly al]

So Garner and Davey in for Thommo and Waddell , Garner has certainly improved and has shown more aggression and line breaking ability in recent times , Davey looks like a solid and tradesman like forward . Haumole played at 13 for the 20 "s , no doubt better as an edge 2 nd r ower but could also play prop and played a bit of fill in centre at Black Town . Should really be in the game day 17 somewhere for next season , all things normal .

 

[Shoe1]

So has garner been released and has manly signed him?

 

[Ned]

So has garner been released and has manly signed him?

Reading this forum you'd think so but I haven't seen anything official.

 

[manly al]

So has garner been released and has manly signed him?

Maybe time to phone a friend . Actually i am sure that Snake would know or have a pretty fair idea .

 

[Woodsie]

Like both Garner and Davey ... but concerned where this leaves Guacamole in Dessie's plans ... either left right out ... or middle forward ... much prefer him on an edge ... ??

 

[tookey]

they are all pretty good players... have you watched the latter two? garner has been extremely dominant in wests this year.

So dominant they are prepared to release him from his contract?

 

[BOZO]

So dominant they are prepared to release him from his contract?

Sometimes a coach and a player dont see eye to eye
Just like Lane and Des

 

[Shoe1]

Sometimes a coach and a player dont see eye to eye
Just like Lane and Des

“Lifestyle” issues, Des wouldn’t be a fan of that

 

[KNUCKLES]

Madge wants to reshape his roster.. garner may just be collateral of just that..

 

[BOZO]

“Lifestyle” issues, Des wouldn’t be a fan of that

Yep , no one can please everyone

 

[master blaster]

Sometimes a coach and a player dont see eye to eye
Just like Lane and Des

Didn't lane want out when Barrett was here or do you mean when he was at the Dogs

 

[Woodsie]

Didn't lane want out when Barrett was here or do you mean when he was at the Dogs

No .. Dessie was the one that cut Lane from the doggies ...

 

[Peter C]

Sometimes a coach and a player dont see eye to eye
Just like Lane and Des

Lane was leaving when Barrett was in charge, he signed halfway through 2018

 

[double hoops]

Like both Garner and Davey ... but concerned where this leaves Guacamole in Dessie's plans ... either left right out ... or middle forward ... much prefer him on an edge ... ??
[/QUOTE]
Hopefully they are all part of the bigger picture. We do need a squad of 30. 17 just doesn't fit into 30 that well. Until of course you get injury after injury.

Considering Davey is currently starting at the Eels Infront of some rather reasonable players.

Hes a lot better signing then the club is getting credit for.

 

[master blaster]

No .. Dessie was the one that cut Lane from the doggies ...

Ok gotcha . Thanks Woodsie

 

[Budgie]

Sometimes a coach and a player dont see eye to eye
Just like Lane and Des

We're having a go at Dessie's height now?

 

[Ryan]

Lane should be an Eagle. Amazing player. One Trent let go. He's killing it at Parramatta damn it,

 

[bSw]

Garner hits really well. Real solid player