Pre-Game Knights v Manly [Round 13, 2023]

[Ron E. Gibbs]

So is the general consensus “ not a chance in hell “ with this game ??

The bookies have us as underdogs for a reason. Those Origin "outs" are massive. But I reckon it will all depend on how our replacements perform. Newcastle are a bit like us in that the difference between their best game and their worst game is massive. So if we can stick with them, there's always a chance. Would I bet on it? No, I would not

 

[maxta]

The bookies have us as underdogs for a reason. Those Origin "outs" are massive. But I reckon it will all depend on how our replacements perform. Newcastle are a bit like us in that the difference between their best game and their worst game is massive. So if we can stick with them, there's always a chance. Would I bet on it? No, I would not

Agree exactly with this summart - apart from taking Manky with 10.5 start in Sundays game

 

[JenEagle]

Yeah absolute joke that as soon as we hit some form we lose our players to origin. Surely the nrl has to re look at this again.

If we win it will be a great effort

 

[globaleagle]

Agree exactly with this summart - apart from taking Manky with 10.5 start in Sundays game

I haven't seen Manky typed in ages!

go Manky!

 

[Bearfax]

Great post @Bearfax . Puts things in Perspective
Sorry to hear about the passing of your friend
May their soul rest in peace

Thanks Bozo. he was a talented and very likable guy, even if he was a Kiwi ...snicker snicker

 

[Bearfax]

Will be interesting to see what sort of combo Schuster and Weeks will bring. With Ponga playing FB, we definitely have the edge in the half's.

Will be interesting to see Schuster, Weekes and Koula in combination. Three very talented young bucks.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

If our pack turns up and lay a foundation we have plenty of points in our backs. Sadly we are like a box of chocolates you never know what your are going to get. We really need some creativity at dummy half I hope GCKT gets a spot on the bench and Arthur gets a start at 7. I am concerned that Newcastle will spot Johns again and run their big forwards at him especially close to our line.

 

[DSM5]

From memory, at Mudgee, Seibold tried to hide Johns out on a wing when defending. Didn't work.

 

[maxta]

I haven't seen Manky typed in ages!

go Manky!

Made ya look

 

[Eagle 1]

If our pack turns up and lay a foundation we have plenty of points in our backs. Sadly we are like a box of chocolates you never know what your are going to get. We really need some creativity at dummy half I hope GCKT gets a spot on the bench and Arthur gets a start at 7. I am concerned that Newcastle will spot Johns again and run their big forwards at him especially close to our line.

Seib's could be throwing up a sneaky smoke screen in front of AOB and wont know till match day. Hoping that this is the case.

 

[Eagle 1]

Will be interesting to see Schuster, Weekes and Koula in combination. Three very talented young bucks.

The best part of this, Shuster will be going either side in attack since theirs no DCE..mmm.

 

[Cliffy's Jockstrap]

Looks like a tough game, we're loading up on as many Hard Nut forwards as possible.

Has anyone seen much of Cooper's long kicking game? Daly tends to like doing the kicking, in his absence I'm not sure who is taking that on.

Tui at 14 is a headscratcher. I am guessing we might try using him in a Dylan Walker-style "running forward" role?

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I haven't seen Manky typed in ages!

go Manky!

See not just me !!!

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Looks like a tough game, we're loading up on as many Hard Nut forwards as possible.

Has anyone seen much of Cooper's long kicking game? Daly tends to like doing the kicking, in his absence I'm not sure who is taking that on.

Tui at 14 is a headscratcher. I am guessing we might try using him in a Dylan Walker-style "running forward" role?

That selection is bewildering.

I know we are down in troops BUT surely Gordie 3 names is a better option there

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Tui at 14 is a headscratcher. I am guessing we might try using him in a Dylan Walker-style "running forward" role?

You're right it's outta left field. But I doubt it would be a Dylan Walker role, more likely a Bullemor role. Just take many hitups running hard each time, and tackle anything that comes near.
The fact he has jersey 14 is a further anomaly of course. Is there still doubt about Lawton? Or Johns?

No idea actually!

 

[stoodamire]

I'm expecting a lose this game. Too many key players out. I think our ruck will be a bit loose.

Just want to see effort for the whole 80 mins.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I'm expecting a lose this game. Too many key players out. I think our ruck will be a bit loose.

Just want to see effort for the whole 80 mins.

Zero expectations from me , if we win I’ll be over the moon ,but think we’ll be trounced.

They are virtually unchanged.

 

[KaZa]

That selection is bewildering.

I know we are down in troops BUT surely Gordie 3 names is a better option there

If we have an injury in the halves..and also to cover to the backs. Garrick to fullback Tui to wing and Weekes the halves.

Thats the idea i guess. Likely we wont see him come on if there are no injuries.

Still would prefer Gordy.. but can understand it.

 

[TheSoaringEagle2023]

That selection is bewildering.

I know we are down in troops BUT surely Gordie 3 names is a better option there

Would have been a good game to at least bring in Gordie on the bench, especially with Phoenix Crossland as an easier assignment in the ruck area.

 

[TheSoaringEagle2023]

If our pack turns up and lay a foundation we have plenty of points in our backs. Sadly we are like a box of chocolates you never know what your are going to get. We really need some creativity at dummy half I hope GCKT gets a spot on the bench and Arthur gets a start at 7. I am concerned that Newcastle will spot Johns again and run their big forwards at him especially close to our line.

If Johns has another average game, that should be his last game for a while. He needs to spend time in Reggies.