The shortlist
Brian Bevan: Bandaged from head to toe and playing almost all his career away from Australian eyes, the Bondi born winger achieved try-scoring feats (796) for Warrington and Blackpool (1945-64) unequalled by anyone in the game.
Dave Brown: Like Messenger, he was far ahead of his contemporaries and some of his records stand today. The Eastern Suburbs centre ((1930-36; 1939-41) who also played for Warrington (1936-39), still holds the record for most points in a game (45) and most number of tries in a season (38 in 1945).
Frank Burge: “Chunky” played 17 seasons, mainly for the now-defunct Glebe club, averaging almost a try per game, a strike rate for a forward that exceeds the best of the modern players, Manly’s Steve Menzies. He also represented Australia 1914 and 1919-22.
Ron Coote: A classic cover defending lock forward for Souths and Easts who played in eight grand finals, winning six. He represented Australia 1967-70 and 1974-75.
Duncan Hall: At a time international football was the pinnacle of achievement and Great Britain dominated Australia for 30 years, this cornerstone of the Queensland and Australian packs won back the Ashes in 1950 and again in 1954.
Ken Irvine: A perennial try scorer for NSW (31 tries) and Australia (103), while representing North Sydney (1958-70) at a time the club was rarely in contention for the semi-finals, he was a phenomenal scoring machine. In 432 games, he scored 385 tries and 101 goals.
Darren Lockyer: He has won the Golden Boot award in two positions, as a fullback and a five-eighth, meaning he has been the best in the world in two positions. A one-club player (Broncos), he has played 472 first class games, captaining his club, state and country to trophies, scoring 1,597 points.
Mal Meninga: “Big Mal” made four Ashes-winning Kangaroo tours, a feat unique in the code and captained Australia in two of them. He was a pillar of Canberra and Queensland, winning premierships and State of Origin titles for both. He played 517 first class games, scoring 3255 points.
Dally Messenger: It can be argued there would be no rugby league in Australia if this player with freakish ability had not transferred from rugby union. In a day where newspapers didn’t put people or pictures on the front page, Dally was a constant star on page one.
Norm Provan: “Sticks” is the sentimental favourite for selection. This towering second rower, along with Wests’ Arthur Summons, is one half (or two thirds if size is considered) of the premiership trophy. He played in ten of the Dragons 11 successive premierships, being captain-coach in four.
https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/10...s-stand-the-test-of-time-20180620-p4zmon.html