Kane Elgey -->Manly√

[Stevo]

Haha no he did not. You make **** up to suit your argument. You get all angry at people that disagree with you but they are only pedalling opinions. You ride a bike of lies.

 

[40 years an eagle]

Haha no he did not. You make **** up to suit your argument. You get all angry at people that disagree with you but they are only pedalling opinions. You ride a bike of lies.

Do some research dude. Anyways, I agree to disagree with you on Kelly trailing in the off season as 5/8.

 

[Stevo]

Played Fullback early on in U/20's before they quickly realised it wasnt his position and he played the last 3/4 games of the season between the wing and centre. Then he played Centre for NSW and for the junior Kangaroos.

Maybe he played 5/8 for Ballina 11's???

 

[40 years an eagle]

Maybe he played 5/8 for Ballina 11's???

Yes juniors, Ballina and Lennox Head.

 

[Fluffy]

What are the choices facing the decision makers?

(1) Safe all pennies and buy an established 5/8 for say $800k-$1mil if any are available ...

(2) Pay say $300k for a player like Elgey who has shown good potential but has "stalled"

(3) Make do hoping T.Wright, Cust or Metcalf step up ....

PSS ... I haven't heard that Croker is leaving yet

Croker is not contracted next year

 

[HappilyManly]

I saw Brian Kelly force a goal line drop out with a neat little grubber kick this year but have only seen him do it once

Almost as good as AFBs against the Rorters

 

[Stevo]

Yes juniors, Ballina and Lennox Head.

Obviously has the skills to play 5/8 at NRL level then. I stand corrected. 8=====|) - -

 

[40 years an eagle]

Obviously has the skills to play 5/8 at NRL level then. I stand corrected. 8=====|) - -

You're not here for the footy talk are you. I'm done.

 

[Woodsie]

I find the Croker situation interesting ..... why we didn't just pay him out when we needed to elevate a player into the top 30 has always intrigued me ...

..... but then again I have no knowledge of the facts . .... and being a Maverick, I will buck the usual numb-nutt Silvertails procedure ..... and refrain from going off half-cocked and abusing everybody .....

Croker is not contracted next year

I know that ... but it doesn't change my statement .... I find it interesting ... we paid Hastings/Lussick out to make room in the 30 .... why didn't we just pay Croker out if he was leaving anyway ... cheaper ..... ???

 

[Stevo]

You're not here for the footy talk are you. I'm done.

I've been here for about 8 years for the footy talk. I've just spent most of it calling out bull****ters.

 

[HappilyManly]

I know that ... but it doesn't change my statement .... I find it interesting ... we paid Hastings/Lussick out to make room in the 30 .... why didn't we just pay Croker out if he was leaving anyway ... cheaper ..... ???

Croker didn't have another NRL contract or ESL one.

Can't 'retire' the player that will be playing next year. Otherwise the injured players would not have access to rehab etc

 

[40 years an eagle]

I've been here for about 8 years for the footy talk. I've just spent most of it calling out bull****ters.

You're my new hero. Now there's 2 that idolise you, you and me.

 

[Woodsie]

Croker didn't have another NRL contract or ESL one.

Can't 'retire' the player that will be playing next year. Otherwise the injured players would not have access to rehab etc

.... Thanks for the 936th time Happily .... that now makes sense to me ...

 

[HappilyManly]

If Baz stays I reckon Croker will be extended.
He and LG don't make sense in our roster makeup though.

Interesting times

 

[HappilyManly]

.... Thanks for the 936th time Happily .... that now makes sense to me ...

https://www.instagram.com/p/BkeGtcpgP72/

 

[Woodsie]

If Baz stays I reckon Croker will be extended.
He and LG don't make sense in our roster makeup though.

Interesting times

not so sure ... I think Baz would baulk at a kid after what 3/4 knee reconstructions .... sad ....... I liked the kid .... not sure if he was going to make it .... but liked him ..

 

[HappilyManly]

not so sure ... I think Baz would baulk at a kid after what 3/4 knee reconstructions .... sad ....... I liked the kid .... not sure if he was going to make it .... but liked him ..

I liked Croker but his duties were too limiting and didn't show his range

 

[Bearfax]

I wonder if Elgey signed with Manly and then at the last minute decided to return to the Titans. Would he cop the garbage DCE copped? No, the hypocritical journos and others would commend him for loyalty. Such are the double standards of journos these days.

 

[Ryan]

Elgey and Kelly played on the same team as juniors didn't they and lit it up? They'll be on the same side of the field yeah?

Hmmmm.

 

[Simonmyers11]

He will go alright elegy. At least the centres will get a lot of early ball. Has a nice pass on both sides of the field