40 nil
It's only a game ...
I agree with your summation. Nearly all the Sea Eagles who returned were at the end of their careers & not in much demand by other clubs. I mentioned that two had successful returns. Ian Thomson played in the 1982 GF side & was part of the 1983 campaign. After his return, Stuart Davis became a premiership winner in 1987.Got to give you a plus. Well researched. But I went through each of them and what I found was many were not regular first graders, many came back only at the end of their career, not at their peak, some were away only for 1-2 years.
Yes a worthy effort but I think its not the same as someone like Gutherson at the peak of their game returning. Weekes may come back, I'm not denying that. But if he establishes himself as a valued member of another club, I cant see him returning, especially with the salary cap issue. Vast majority of those names were pre 1998 when salary cap was introduced and several not regular first graders. . Others like Hill, Cunningham etc came back at very end of their career for one year and would have been on cheaper salaries. Only perhaps Hopoate, Hodkinson, maybe Haumono, since salary cap came into play, were still top first grader standard. But I'll concede you did a good job.
I think some other clubs have been more successful in bringing back top line players. For example, Justin Hodges had stints at the Broncos and the Roosters before playing 11 further seasons with the Broncos. Darius Boyd played the last 6 years of his career with the Broncos, including the 2015 GF.
Last edited: