How long will Cleary sit on the sidelines?

[Nordburg]

Worse than Lawton’s IMO.Second offence this season.All being equal,which we all know it isn’t,by rights he should get 5.I’d be surprised once they hand down their charge,if the Panthers don’t challenge it so they can get in front of the judiciary and kiss their collective bums and get it downgraded.The media hysteria over this will help his cause.The infamous Manly 7 should be thanking Nathan now for taking the spotlight off them

 

[Disco]

I think it was worse than Lawtons so should be 6 weeks.

I'll say 4 weeks so

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

It’s the golden child , normally 4 weeks but he’s “ special “ so it’ll be reduced to two weeks

 

[Andrew..]

Should get 4 weeks like the Lawman but I'm guessing 2.

 

[The '47ers]

Whatever the punishment, I hope he just cops it on the chin and moves on.

 

[Snake]

Lawton’s was a complete accident and largely caused by Murray’s tendency to bounce in and out of contact to get quick play the balls. Naden’s was awful the way he drove Jake’s head into the ground. They both got 4 so there is no consistency.

I didn’t think Nathan’s was as bad as it looked. It’s just that he drove his shoulder into Brown’s chest which made it look ferocious. Maybe he’ll just get the same four week blanket penalty as the other two.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

It's Cleary's second offence, and it should be a grade 3

 

[bones]

Send off was harsh. Ten minutes in the chin bin would have been enough.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Cant see how he gets any thing less than the Lawman got! Otherwise it’s blantant favouritism.

 

[castle eagle]

the review comittee will charge the attacker with 'putting himself in a dangerous position' & apologise to cleary

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Send off was harsh. Ten minutes in the chin bin would have been enough.

One of your best !!

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Cant see how he gets any thing less than the Lawman got! Otherwise it’s blantant favouritism.

Ah Que the “ No Real Leadership”

 

[rj90]

5 - 6 Weeks!! I’m sure they’ll challenge.

Cleary was charged with a Grade Three Dangerous Throw offence, which will see the halfback sidelined for five matches with an early guilty plea, or six weeks if he unsuccessfully challenges the charge at the judiciary.

The incident is Cleary's second charge for the season after he was fined $1,000 for a Dangerous Contact offence in round 6 against the Broncos.

 

[Nordburg]

Nelson Asofa-Solomona got nothing for his elbow to the end of Egan last night.It’s a dog’s breakfast at the moment.Cleary could get anything from a pay rise to a public stoning

 

[Nordburg]

5 weeks for Cleary.For the first time this week,the NRL have got something right

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

5 - 6 Weeks!! I’m sure they’ll challenge.

Cleary was charged with a Grade Three Dangerous Throw offence, which will see the halfback sidelined for five matches with an early guilty plea, or six weeks if he unsuccessfully challenges the charge at the judiciary.

The incident is Cleary's second charge for the season after he was fined $1,000 for a Dangerous Contact offence in round 6 against the Broncos.

As was an accidental slap across the face ( Smalley gets a week ) v a grind your elbow into a players face whilst he’s on the ground underneath you ( small fine )

 

[wombatgc]

As was an accidental slap across the face ( Smalley gets a week ) v a grind your elbow into a players face whilst he’s on the ground underneath you ( small fine )

Is Hargreaves the dog punishment $3000 plus two weeks or just one or the other?
Hope it’s both.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Is Hargreaves the dog punishment $3000 plus two weeks or just one or the other?
Hope it’s both.

$3k and “ play on “

 

[Rafferty]

Is Hargreaves the dog punishment $3000 plus two weeks or just one or the other?
Hope it’s both.

Early guilty plea is 3k, contest lose and get 2.

 

[Spartan Eagle]

He's going to challenge it and get it down graded. His legal team will argue that it was an emotional week. Cleary’s hands being between Brown’s legs was merely to demonstrate the spirit of inclusivity of the game.