Harper's been so bad he needs to go

[deanm]

Classic silvertails. See what you want to see. I thought Harper was almost best on park. His D was punishing and he put in 100%

Well most on here are Seasoned NRL players with many seasons and Premierships under their belts, so our opinions are always accurate. I thought he had a great game , but he is 2022's whipping boy due to the Talakai debacle.

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

Well most on here are Seasoned NRL players with many seasons and Premierships under their belts, so our opinions are always accurate. I thought he had a great game , but he is 2022's whipping boy due to the Talakai debacle.

And there is the issue. Last year he went really well apart from that finals game. He then has covid and gets destroyed first game back and so many want his head chopped off.
He's got mongral and goes well for what he is.

 

[eagleron]

Well most on here are Seasoned NRL players with many seasons and Premierships under their belts, so our opinions are always accurate. I thought he had a great game , but he is 2022's whipping boy due to the Talakai debacle.

And as we've since learned, there were extenuating circumstances that caused his form against Talakai, he really never should have been selected to play

 

[Pittwater Legend]

Gotta given Harper a wrap. Lately he has been looking like a worthy first grade centre. Definitely a feel good comeback after getting hooked in that Sharks match. He was probably brought back too soon from covid in that match

 

[Rocky]

Lionel is a guy that you want to get behind. Always give it 100% and seems to really care about the team.

That's refreshing given the week that was.

 

[jbb/james]

Anyone who thinks that Harper hasn't been in our top 5 players weekly since his switch to the left side are kidding themselves. His yardage runs are numerous and effective, and he has also become our go to man close to the line. His defence is good, manu had to go infield to be effective last night. And personally, I loved that he was the 1st bloke in to stick up for Zac Fulton last night.

I love how everytime someone mentions harpers improvement outside foran as opposed to DCE, straight through to the keeper .

Parker had finally become silvertail accepted outside foran as well

 

[conanu]

Still feel this way?

He has been excellent in the past 6 weeks or so.

Excellent is a stretch, he has been competent at best. He isn’t a game changer he just plugs a hole sometimes.