Dylan walker is a flop

[MadMarcus]

Is that why Walker arm grabs and runs across field - no Manly forwards to follow down the field ?

Never mind his great goal kicking percentage

You can hardly expect him to kick goals if the forwards don't lay the platform.

 

[Mataiforever]

this kid gets bagged for any wrongdoings, its almost cherry evans level. agreed he didn't play well but to single him out as the biggest flop is a joke.. just look at our other players, half of them dont even have any spark or talent... kennedy, brown, myles, taufua just to name a few.

 

[Dinga]

When Dylan got penalised for the shepherd run when the score was 20-18 the game was over.. It was a school boy error.. The sad part about it was Turbo miraculously got us out of our own in goal area to avoid a repeat set and 1 tackle later Dylan does that..

Simply not good enough from our so called BIG recruit !!

 

[pjayz]

Walkers not a flop, he is one of the best young centres in the game. Barrett needs to stop trying to make him a second fullback with stupid set plays. He wasn't amazing at all but he was tough.

Turbo, his defensive misses led to their first three tries (the third being the the line break that set it up).

 

[Mac Man]

Your a flop too with a comment like that! So it's the forwards fault he played like a nuffy???

Actually for all you keyboard warriors out there shall we put Lewis brown at centre?
A timely reminder we are about 1mil under the cap in the backs and had 4 prop towards out against a full strenth bunnies pack

Also starting props of myles and Lawrence....

 

[Kalvin]

Actually for all you keyboard warriors out there shall we put Lewis brown at centre?
A timely reminder we are about 1mil under the cap in the backs and had 4 prop towards out against a full strenth bunnies pack

Also starting props of myles and Lawrence....

No your right mate.. it's the "forwards" fault walker missed 3-4 tackles that led to trys against us and consistently ran sideways... this guy is getting paid top dollar. .. sorry but arm grabbing defense can't be blamed on others

 

[Holmsey]

Turbo, his defensive misses led to their first three tries (the third being the the line break that set it up).

Yeah his defence was awful but uate outside him was not much better. Need more communication.

 

[winnyason]

Yeap and it won't change when the forwards come back

 

[eagleron]

He may be constantly referred to as 'one of the best young centres in the game', but let's be honest - he got his Australian and NSW jumpers the same way Wolfman and Jamie Buhrer did.

He is capable of doing good things, but it's becoming increasingly clear he has a fair bit of Jarryd Hayne about him. Happy to be the superstar when the game's going his way, not the slightest interest in doing the hard yards.

My young bloke told me last week that he read somewhere that Walker had made enquiries about going back to Souffs, I hope he's right ffs.

 

[yokahontas]

My young bloke told me last week that he read somewhere that Walker had made enquiries about going back to Souffs, I hope he's right ffs.

I read that rumour as well, can't remember where though.

 

[HoldenV8]

I read that rumour as well, can't remember where though.

The Jerker.....sorry......The Lurker

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

He may be constantly referred to as 'one of the best young centres in the game', but let's be honest - he got his Australian and NSW jumpers the same way Wolfman and Jamie Buhrer did.

Good thing he's being coached by "one of the best young coaches in the game". Talk about a match made in heaven.
(Too easy, I know, but I couldn't resist.)

 

[KaZa]

Walkers not a flop, he is one of the best young centres in the game. Barrett needs to stop trying to make him a second fullback with stupid set plays. He wasn't amazing at all but he was tough.

Cant tell if your serious. His defence is the main issue. Has nothing to do with Barrett. He got ripped a new one as he couldnt even go near a player let alone completing a tackle without assistance.

 

[Johnno74]

Wether we were down on forwards or not in regards to Dylan Walker today his defence was **** .No sugar coating it,u cant defend by moving backwards,bye the time u commit to make the tackle the attacker is already on ur inside an half thru the line ,we all saw it ,ud expect that from a rookie. Ps wonder u didnt hear me scream from down there ☺

 

[Waz13]

Walker's performance today was the worst I have seen from a first grade player in a decade.

He was so bad i was yelling at the tv to hook him and put Lewis brown at centre!! No joke he should have been pulled today it was that bad. IMO the jury is still out on this guy in a big way.

 

[Snake]

I've never bagged Walker before, but honestly that defence today was as bad as it gets.

 

[JenEagle]

Why we signed this guy and let Hiku and Gutherson go I will never understand.

 

[BirdMan4ever]

IMO - i smell a rat today, watch that game again and tell me walker wasn't a paid operative for his former soufs mates, i think a lot of money was made on our loss today and walker had something to do with it.

 

[maxta]

At 12-0....we turn it over and not get to a kick for field position....from there down 16 - 12.
From there we need DCE to lead us.
Or Green.
Maybe Hastings would be handy at this time as the side lacked incentive and guidance....
Agree some crap defence from Walker along with plenty of others but really just a scapegoat based on that game.

 

[robbiea]

If only walker would run !