different rules for different teams?

[castle eagle]

how was the high shot on buhrer nearing the end of the game not worth a penalty when 1st impact was across the nose while he was standing up? yet matai's hit on locke when he(matai) raised his arm no higher than his ribs? i know matai hit him high but locke fell prior to impact.
i also understand that by the rules they follow today matai should be penalised but i can't understand why nothing was done when ferris was hit.

 

[castle eagle]

how was the high shot on buhrer nearing the end of the game not worth a penalty when 1st impact was across the nose while he was standing up? yet matai's hit on locke when he(matai) raised his arm no higher than his ribs? i know matai hit him high but locke fell prior to impact.
i also understand that by the rules they follow today matai should be penalised but i can't understand why nothing was done when ferris was hit.

 

[Brissie Kid]

Correct.

 

[Brissie Kid]

Correct.

 

[Central Coast Eagle]

The buhrer one annoyed me, the ref told him to keep it down after the video ref saw the replay, therefore it should have been a penalty.

 

[Central Coast Eagle]

The buhrer one annoyed me, the ref told him to keep it down after the video ref saw the replay, therefore it should have been a penalty.

 

[caspersparks]

i agree.. the matai one angered me soooooooo much.. he fell!!

 

[caspersparks]

i agree.. the matai one angered me soooooooo much.. he fell!!

 

[Dan]

What about the punch to the back of the head on Chez as he scored the last try

 

[Dan]

What about the punch to the back of the head on Chez as he scored the last try

 

[Rex]

The incident that best showed the ref had no idea was when he prematurely called a penalty before checking whether Wolfie had scored.

Then he changed his mind and called for a video decision on the try.

Then he changed his mind again and said no video referral.

Dump the hopeless two ref system and get some accountability back into refereeing.

 

[Rex]

The incident that best showed the ref had no idea was when he prematurely called a penalty before checking whether Wolfie had scored.

Then he changed his mind and called for a video decision on the try.

Then he changed his mind again and said no video referral.

Dump the hopeless two ref system and get some accountability back into refereeing.

 

[Dan]

The incident that best showed the ref had no idea was when he prematurely called a penalty before checking whether Wolfie had scored.

Then he changed his mind and called for a video decision on the try.

Then he changed his mind again and said no video referral.

Dump the hopeless two ref system and get some accountability back into refereeing.

He didn't change his mind on going upstairs, it was pointed out to him that he could not go to the video ref. once he had blown penalty the play after is moot

 

[Dan]

The incident that best showed the ref had no idea was when he prematurely called a penalty before checking whether Wolfie had scored.

Then he changed his mind and called for a video decision on the try.

Then he changed his mind again and said no video referral.

Dump the hopeless two ref system and get some accountability back into refereeing.

He didn't change his mind on going upstairs, it was pointed out to him that he could not go to the video ref. once he had blown penalty the play after is moot

 

[Top End Eagle]

Some of us suffered a further injustice listening to warren 'which way does the ref point for a penalty' smith shouting 'Penalty to the Warriors!' and then listening to him try and cover his massive gaff.

A joke all round 'Mr Adjudicator' and one befitting your biased over -hyped disservice to this great game.

 

[Top End Eagle]

Some of us suffered a further injustice listening to warren 'which way does the ref point for a penalty' smith shouting 'Penalty to the Warriors!' and then listening to him try and cover his massive gaff.

A joke all round 'Mr Adjudicator' and one befitting your biased over -hyped disservice to this great game.

 

[Brookvale]

Refs are dumb, blind and drunk

 

[Brookvale]

Refs are dumb, blind and drunk

 

[sharx]

during the time off whilst ferris was getting treated,there should have been a penalty given but you can hear the ref tell the warrior's player
'..you can't do that..'

wtf??

 

[sharx]

during the time off whilst ferris was getting treated,there should have been a penalty given but you can hear the ref tell the warrior's player
'..you can't do that..'

wtf??