Nothing is my favour, I'm still undecided...both excellent players.I disagree, because your saying an average isn't an average. How about looking at the results over the entirety of their respective careers ? Not just at Manly?.Or how is that unfair because the numbers won't work in your favour ?
Also, are you suggesting a teams marquee chief okay maker doesn't have a significant affect on the success or failures of a team ?
Chief playmakers certainly influence a team but they aren't solely responsible for the results.
Likewise 4 years to 12 makes it an inadequate comparison.
If thats the measure you want run with go for it but I just think its too simplistic.
Like the rep games measure.....there is more to it than just that