Credit to coach

[eagle66]

Don't overlook that there were no hail Mary plays which often cost points let alone getting them.

 

[Dion Johnson]

Would Trent Robinson be in the top 4 if he didn’t have money bags at Easts?

Maybe not but those are the variables they get judged on, many things can go wrong with injuries, suspensions, sinbins and the refeering decisions.

 

[Dion Johnson]

Think you've sold Des a bit short there, if you're judging off his entire body of work. If your judging off recent performance only Des has more recent success than Bennett does (Although what Wayne has done with the Phins in the last 2 is very impressive).

Maybe, if it was Des in the first half of his career definitely would have it wrong, the second half I sit comfortably with.

Des was lucky the Titans threw him a gig, his stint at the Dogs ended poorly along with his second stint at Manly, it’s subjective of course.

 

[ManlyTragic]

Maybe not but those are the variables they get judged on, many things can go wrong with injuries, suspensions, sinbins and the refeering decisions.

Well Ricky Stuart hasn’t done much since leaving Easts! You could put him in the same category as Robinson then.

Just sayin’

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

In the immortal AI-induced words of Anthony Watmough:

Credit to the coach. Full credit to the boys.

 

[Under the Sticks]

Seibs - two club leaders lifting silverware for the past 3 years….what can you leverage from that?

 

[double hoops]

Maybe, if it was Des in the first half of his career definitely would have it wrong, the second half I sit comfortably with.

Des was lucky the Titans threw him a gig, his stint at the Dogs ended poorly along with his second stint at Manly, it’s subjective of course.

No it 7 losses in a row. 🌈.It was most certainly ended poor. Might even have been closer to s#$t creek.;-)

 

[double hoops]

In the immortal AI-induced words of Anthony Watmough:

Credit to the coach. Full credit to the boys.

I reckon NRL coaches would universally be very happy with full credit going to the players always.

Have your credit, but be accountable too.

If we miss finals this year, the discussion should be should we sack Guac who was MIA when we needed him most not the coach.

Choc's right. Full accountability to the players too.

 

[manlyfan76]

5th place for a guy who can't coach and was without Turbo for a big chunk is quite the achievement

 

[Dion Johnson]

5th place for a guy who can't coach and was without Turbo for a big chunk is quite the achievement

Now for the Rorters game, DCE can’t play worse than he did today, would be massive to get the win against them.

 

[mave]

5th place for a guy who can't coach and was without Turbo for a big chunk is quite the achievement

For both coach, and recruitment and retention......

 

[The '47ers]

Now for the Rorters game, DCE can’t play worse than he did today, would be massive to get the win against them.

A win against the Rorters heading into the bye would be heaven!

 

[manlyfan76]

For both coach, and recruitment and retention......

Getting Brooks was a great call.
And brown
And talau

 

[frank stokes]

Getting Brooks was a great call.
And brown
And talau

We would be competing for the minor premiership if we had Des and Foz...

🤪

 

[krusty]

Getting Brooks was a great call.
And brown
And talau

Not to mention Simpkin he has made a huge difference.

 

[Dion Johnson]

Not to mention Simpkin he has made a huge difference.

Simpkin at 9 has done a solid job, he is a good runner of the ball also, haven’t seen much of it as yet, could be when we need it in a big game.

 

[Adz]

I may be wrong but I think Hales is in charge of our attack this year,last year was Flanagan.
Not giving him all the credit,but they seem a lot more potent this year from the get go

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

5th place for a guy who can't coach and was without Turbo for a big chunk is quite the achievement

To some , regardless , he’ll always be “ Seidud”.

This is almost the team he built , remember Brooks , Talau , Simpkins are all his work.

I didn’t look at last year , that the team he inherited , this year is more important , if we play finals that’ll be a terrific improvement.

 

[manlyfan76]

To some , regardless , he’ll always be “ Seidud”.

This is almost the team he built , remember Brooks , Talau , Simpkins are all his work.

I didn’t look at last year , that the team he inherited , this year is more important , if we play finals that’ll be a terrific improvement.

Well he beat in des we trust today. Must of hurt some "Manly" "supporters"

 

[maxta]

Not calling out names - but a few bagging bad coaching based on results should maybe give credit to recent results on a team on the Rise