Pre-Game Cowboys V Manly [Round 11, 2025]

[mickqld]

LOL Seidud shuffling the deck chairs on the Titanic. Does it matter who he picks and where anymore. This train wreck team is now a clown show to watch. Every team will be looking forward to playing the guaranteed 2 points. Might as well rename us to the bye.

 

[Thewestisbest]

If they want to be better that is.

Not sure it’s all the coaches fault, I’m starting to see a disconnect on the field and that’s down to the players.

Yep, it's also known as losing the locker room.

When a coach is unable to get his players connected and ready to rumble.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Yep, it's also known as losing the locker room.

When a coach is unable to get his players connected and ready to rumble.

Yes that’s possible as well BUT you’d have to say the $CE issue is the more likely cause as go back to the games before he made his announcement!!

Different team ( same players )

 

[mickqld]

Yes that’s possible as well BUT you’d have to say the $CE issue is the more likely cause as go back to the games before he made his announcement!!

Different team ( same players )

Not sure I agree it's all because of $CE and his self serving show. We've served up this same dogsh*t for years now. We have arguably the most sh*thouse pack in the competition. With no go forward then backs can do very little. The whole club is in a disconnect and it's not just because the captain is moving on. Certainly hasn't helped but last year we had Paseka, Aloiai and Lodge up front giving us a fair wack of grunt. All been missing this year. How the fu*k Waddell and Burbo keep their spots is beyond me but there's just nothing to pick from. Seriously if Lodge doesn't get a run this week and Jake back at lock it's just clueless coaching.

 

[Thewestisbest]

Yes that’s possible as well BUT you’d have to say the $CE issue is the more likely cause as go back to the games before he made his announcement!!

Different team ( same players )

Not really. In most games we have won except the Panthers, which was the best win of all imo. We had ALL the momentum in penalties and six against. We are and have been for many years good under these circumstances, as are most sides in today's game. Yes DCE has contributed, no doubt. Which is why I don't understand how our coach has kept him in charge of the playing group.

Like I said, it displays weakness. It screams "you can walk all over me and the club."

No doubt it would have upset a bunch of our players.

 

[Brookie1973]

Yep, it's also known as losing the locker room.

When a coach is unable to get his players connected and ready to rumble.

All sounds very familiar. What happened at Seibolds last gig again?

 

[Thewestisbest]

All sounds very familiar. What happened at Seibolds last gig again?

Who would have thunk it might happen again Alfred E Neuman?

Not our owners or management it seems. But a bunch of Silvertails and footy heads predicted this was a strong possibility of recurring. None of whom are fortune tellers or prophets. 1 + 2 =3...

 

[Thewestisbest]

All sounds very familiar. What happened at Seibolds last gig again?

And we have Isaac Moses entrenched in the club to boot. It just makes me want to sing oh what a wonderful morning oh what a glorious day.

 

[Highflier]

Is it possible Lodge replaces Waddell on the bench or will he drop Navale off the bench for Lodge
I’m keen to see Navale get more minutes see how capable he is of holding down a permanent bench spot

lets hope so

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Not really. In most games we have won except the Panthers, which was the best win of all imo. We had ALL the momentum in penalties and six against. We are and have been for many years good under these circumstances, as are most sides in today's game. Yes DCE has contributed, no doubt. Which is why I don't understand how our coach has kept him in charge of the playing group.

Like I said, it displays weakness. It screams "you can walk all over me and the club."

No doubt it would have upset a bunch of our players.

I think you are right on this front , I imagine some of the players are fuming at what’s going on.

But who knows what goes on in their heads these days, not me that’s for sure,

 

[Nordburg]

He maybe entrenched in a sense that he has a lot of his players and a coach at the club,but does he really have any power or the upper hand? Moses can hardly hold the club over a barrel with the quality of players he has there.Not sure the threat of taking Brooks or Talau out of Manly if Seibold is shown the door,is hardly going to spook the club hierarchy,at least I hope so

 

[Thewestisbest]

He maybe entrenched in a sense that he has a lot of his players and a coach at the club,but does he really have and power or the upper hand? Moses can hardly hold the club over a barrel with the quality of players he has there.Not sure the threat of taking Brooks or Talau out of Manly if Seibold is shown the door,is hardly going to spook the club hierarchy,at least I hope so

No, but it might be a little difficult to move unwanted players on to another club. Or land an actually half decent Moses client that becomes available who might fit the bill for what we need.

 

[Thewestisbest]

He maybe entrenched in a sense that he has a lot of his players and a coach at the club,but does he really have and power or the upper hand? Moses can hardly hold the club over a barrel with the quality of players he has there.Not sure the threat of taking Brooks or Talau out of Manly if Seibold is shown the door,is hardly going to spook the club hierarchy,at least I hope so

Right now it appears we are a dumping ground for mediocrity as far as Moses is concerned.

 

[Brookie1973]

Right now it appears we are a dumping ground for mediocrity as far as Moses is concerned.

The good news is Seibold is a Moses client, so we know uncle Nick and the roosters wont nab him.

 

[Bradza]

6 8 10 18 29 42
just not sure which week

 

[eaglebuzz]

So the selection regresses back to Jake at lock, Ben in the 2nd row and Waddell on the bench. This to me is the crux of the problem, Jake is too slow for lockforward, Burbo and Waddell are reserve graders. They keep selecting the same old same old and wont deal with the obvious problems we have.

I would have young Joey Walsh on the bench so we can blood a kid who is our future and have a ready made replacement for our halves all set to go!

I actually thought Burbo was one of our better players on Sunday.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

I actually thought Burbo was one of our better players on Sunday.

To give him credit he’s at least having a crack , and yes is getting better

 

[Sheikheagle]

I actually thought Burbo was one of our better players on Sunday.

Was also good against the rif. He has cut down his errors. Unfortunately the rest of the team have gone the other way.

 

[deanm]

At least Burbo showed a bit of mongrel and made some decent hit ups

 

[47MVEagle]

Burbo hits like a Mack truck in the early tackles of the game, you can hear it on the telly.

When he & Jake combine in a tackle they absolutely crunch the ball carrier.