Cliffy was an assistant coach I believe under Tooves in his first year but I don’t know what happened there. Maybe it was the cigarettes or he couldn’t translate his ability to others.
Cliffy was such a brilliant player because half the time he didn’t know what he was going to do, it wasn’t structured, but pure instinct and you either have that or you don’t. Joey Johns can teach players his tricks but even he can’t coach his instinct.
I know a previous World Cup winning Wallaby captain and asked him what it was that made him so good as a player. His answer ... lateral vision, the ability to see what was happening at any time, anywhere on the field. I then asked “So how did you get it, was it coached?” His answer “I don’t think you can actually coach it, you either have it or you don’t and that’s what separates the great players from the good players as they see what others don’t.”
And that was Cliffy, Wally, Lockyer, Thurston, Bozo, among many others. The best players don’t always make great coaches.