Brian Kelly to Sea Eagles

Probably a good deal for both parties.. Was wondering if 2 years was enough for someone who could turn out to be real good.

But it seems right. He would have never accepted a one year deal. Two years for us lets us have a look and see if we have someone decent or a dud.
 
When does he come to Manly?

One article says
"Manly fended off several NRL clubs and the Titans for his signature for 2018-19 and see him as a gilt edged investment for the future."
 
Probably a good deal for both parties.. Was wondering if 2 years was enough for someone who could turn out to be real good.

But it seems right. He would have never accepted a one year deal. Two years for us lets us have a look and see if we have someone decent or a dud.
Remember Michael Chee Kam??
 
I never rated him . After he left us he maintained his NSW cup status with the tigers
The analogy is that I hope Kelly doesn't go the same way, Chee Kam came to us as the gun forward of the NYC at the time!! Sounding familiar???
 
Personally, I don't think Dylan Walker was too bad last year. There were matches where the whole team was rudderless and his natural athleticism (even at 5/8) was the only dangerous component of our attack. He would take the line on and cause some headaches. His kicking and passing wasn't where it needed to be and that's why he is not a 5/8 but he was far from one of our worst last year.

Aside from Taupau's performance at the Bulldogs, Walker's game against Penrith at Brookvale was the single best performance from a Manly player all season. He will be a fine centre next year.
 
The analogy is that I hope Kelly doesn't go the same way, Chee Kam came to us as the gun forward of the NYC at the time!! Sounding familiar???
His mistake was coming to us when we were stacked at his preferred positions and he couldn't crack the squad + being injury prone = stalled career.
 
Personally, I don't think Dylan Walker was too bad last year. There were matches where the whole team was rudderless and his natural athleticism (even at 5/8) was the only dangerous component of our attack. He would take the line on and cause some headaches. His kicking and passing wasn't where it needed to be and that's why he is not a 5/8 but he was far from one of our worst last year.

Aside from Taupau's performance at the Bulldogs, Walker's game against Penrith at Brookvale was the single best performance from a Manly player all season. He will be a fine centre next year.


In at least one game Walker was a star at 5/8. But its true he is suited as a running player not a distributing player.
 
When you think about it even though it was a mistake to play Walker at 5/8 with DCE, they never really got a chance to form a combination with DCE having surgery last off-season and then getting injured twice for a month apiece during the regular season.
 
Last edited:
When you think about even though it was a mistake to play Walker at 5/8 with DCE, they never really got a chance to form a combination with DCE having surgery last off-season and then getting injured twice for a month apiece during the regular season.
Yep, and DCE was also injured whilst playing alongside him, it was just that type of year
 
Also said that he only came because they promised first grade in 2017.....

1) Turbo
2) Locke
3) Kelly
4) Walker
5) Uate

???

I know Tafua is a fan fav and training with the boys - but he still doesn't have a contract for 2017?....
4 turnstiles
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
24 19 5 148 44
24 17 7 212 40
24 16 8 120 38
24 15 9 172 36
24 15 9 109 36
24 14 10 21 34
24 13 10 107 33
24 13 11 132 32
24 12 12 125 30
24 12 12 21 30
24 10 14 -76 26
24 9 14 -146 25
24 9 15 -135 24
24 9 15 -181 24
24 8 16 -130 22
24 6 18 -199 18
24 6 18 -300 18
Back
Top Bottom